web stats

CSBG Archive

Comic Dictionary – Snowball Idea

A snowball idea is based on the premise of a snowball, rolling down the hill. It starts off as a tiny little snowball, but as it keeps rolling and rolling, it keeps adding more and more snow, until it is one gigantic snowball, and when it hits, it is a big mess.

It applies to comics (and movies and TV and everyday life) in much the same way.

Someone will suggest something, often not even being serious. The idea then is sent down the hill, and if no one cuts it off, it just keeps adding snow and gaining momentum until it is so big that NO one can stop it.

Grant Morrison’s “Batman protocols” (and the Marvel equivalent, the “Xavier protocols”) is a perfect example.

Once Morrison brought the idea up in a Wizard JLA special, you KNEW the idea would be used by SOMEone later on, you just did not know where and by who.

It was a snowball idea.

A current snowball idea is the whole “return of Jason Todd” idea. Once Loeb brought it up in Hush, even if he meant it as something to not be taken seriously, it began its snowball trip. When it will hit and make a big mess is the only question now…

EDITED TO ADD: Note that Jason Todd DID end up returning later that year! I think the current “snowball idea” is Spider-Man and Mary Jane’s marriage ending.


Another variation of the “snowball idea”: when a writer or artist inserts an inside joke, which later creators decide to take seriously and keep in-continuity, usually resulting in any number of lame contrivances in order to justify and/or eliminate the original joke.

Example: Because Dave Cockrum had previously drawn the Legion of Super-heroes, somebody decided it would be a cute wink at the readers to have the X-Men face an alien Imperial Guard made up entirely of characters who very closely resembled the LoSH in bot appearance and abilities.

With each subsequent appearance, the writers and artists worked very hard at trying to distance the Guard from their obvious source, usually involving (as in the case of Guardian’s appearance in Fantastic Four) a lot of heavy exposition of the ways in which the character in question differed from the original due to some minutia regarding the way his/her powers operate, or the introduction of a new costume, or some other such device.

See also: Squadron Supreme.

That’s a very good phenomenon MacQuarrie, but I think its different enought to deserve its own name.

How about Frank Miller’s “grim-‘n’-gritty” FUTURE Batman becoming the template for every inferior writer’s version of the CURRENT Batman to the point that he’s portrayed as a near-sociopath?

Leave a Comment



Review Copies

Comics Should Be Good accepts review copies. Anything sent to us will (for better or for worse) end up reviewed on the blog. See where to send the review copies.

Browse the Archives