web stats

CSBG Archive

Comic Book Urban Legends Revealed #26!

1 2 3
Next »

This is the twenty-sixth in a series of examinations of comic book urban legends and whether they are true or false. Click here for an archive of the previous twenty-five.

Let’s begin!

COMIC URBAN LEGEND: US Postal Laws made for some interesting comic title transitions.


My pal MacQuarrie reminded me of this fact recently (it is funny the stuff you have in your brain that you forgot you knew!) in his post here.

You see, postal service laws require (or at least they did require at the time) that, whenever a publication begins a new volume, that is reapply for a new postal code for subscriptions, and, naturally, pay a new fee.

Magazines generally could afford such a fee, so they were fine with starting a new volume each year.

Comic companies, however, did NOT like to pay this fee, so they would not start a new volume, but rather simply change the title of the book to the new feature (as a “#1 issue” did not have the same panache back then) when the book changed features.

The most infamous example of this frugality HAS to be EC Comics and their Moon Girl character.

Moon Girl began in the late 40s as a new superheroine.

Image hosted by Photobucket.com

But this was when the superhero fad was drawing to a close, so EC quickly picked up on the new CRIME comic angle, and changed the name of the book to Moon Girl Fights Crime.

Image hosted by Photobucket.com

Two issues later, they decided to make the move to ROMANCE comics, and the best name change ever occured, as Moon Girl Fights Crime became…. A Moon, A Girl…Romance.

Image hosted by Photobucket.com

1 2 3
Next »


i wonder if rumored homophobe mike miller would’ve agreed to draw the comic if he’d known Triumph was gay?

[blockquote]”Plenty of current Marvel characters existed BEFORE the Fantastic Four made their debut in 1961. Patsy Walker, Fin Fang Four, Captain America, Namor, etc.”[/blockquote]

I assume you meant “…the Fantastic *Foom*…Fin Fang Four…” I really enjoyed those early Fantastic Foom issues. Remember when they fought that guy from the Simpsons – Hans Mole Man? Neat.

(Rassa-frassin can’t do HTML and snark at the same time…)

The Grand Comicbook Database’s indexes acknowledges that the TOMB OF DARKNESS reprint changed the story’s name from “I Made the Hulk Live” to “I created Grutan” (implicitly, the word “hulk” there was just a descriptive term, not the monster’s name) “so as not to confuse readers with the current (1975) Marvel character Hulk.” No mention of a character being renamed Pym, which would be a more significant–albeit less blatant–change, but admittedly there are no mention of character names at all, either, for this reprint or for the original. In fact, the original doesn’t even acknowledge the reprint.

Apparently the ‘Moon Girl’ name changes go further. A text by Ted White, included at the end of Fantagraphics’ collection of Jack Davis’ EC tales “T’ain’t the meat… It’s the Humanity” (in which there’s also a mention of Moon Girl’s previous name changes) indicates the following:

“The same month Haunt of Fear made its debut so did two science fiction titles, Weird Science (with # 12, previously Saddle Romances), and Weird Fantasy (with #13, previously A moon, A Girl… Romance).”

It’s clear that by then they didn’t even bother trying to keep any sense of continuity within the title, like they did with the two previous changes, but technically it was still the same book, thus giving it four titles in thirteen issues.

Leave a Comment



Review Copies

Comics Should Be Good accepts review copies. Anything sent to us will (for better or for worse) end up reviewed on the blog. See where to send the review copies.

Browse the Archives