web stats

CSBG Archive

Will Pfeifer on “10 Comics That Screwed Me Up”

Will Pfeifer has a cool blog called X-Ray Spex, where Will talks about comics, pop culture and the comics he writes (like Catwoman, new issue out this Wednesday).

For his guest entry, Will is sharing with us “10 COMICS THAT SCREWED ME UP.”

Fredric Wertham wrote a book (and helped maim an industry) with the hypothesis that comic books can screw you up royally. I’m not here to say that the good doctor was right, but I have to admit that they’ve done their job on me. Without comics, I might be doctor, a lawyer, or some other upstanding member of society. But thanks to them damned funnybooks, I’m…well, I’m a comic book writer. Fitting, eh?

So, in the spirit of warning the rest of you (though if you’re reading this site, I’m guessing the comic book monkey has its claws pretty deep into your back), here are ten comics that warped my mind. Check ‘em out – it’s not like they could do the same to you, right? Right? Of course not!



Mom bought me this to read on a trip to grandma’s house. It hit the stands around May of 1973, making me just under six. I had probably learned to read a few months earlier. Perfect time to dive into a comic with Gwen Stacy’s corpse, the Green Goblin’s death and Harry Osborne whacked out on acid. Thanks, mom. (No, seriously. Thanks!)



Bought this one myself, on a trip with dad to the local convenience store. I still can’t remember why – I didn’t even read comics then (late spring of 1979) and this one had nothing special to recommend it. In fact, it’s lame. But I bought it, read it, and for some reason, I was hooked. And I have been for the past 27 years.



OK, I’ve never really read a copy of THE HAUNT OF FEAR 19. It hit the stands in the heyday of EC comics, way back in 1953. That was 14 years before I was even born. But sometime in 1979, a mere two panels from that comic reached across the decades and really got me. The story was Jack Davis’ “Foul Play!,” a revenge drama where the good guys (!) punish the bad guy by chopping him up and playing baseball with his body. His arms and legs are the bats, his intestines are the baselines, and his head…well, you can guess. Wertham reprinted two panels in SEDUCTION OF THE INNOCENT, and the OVERSTREET PRICE GUIDE reprinted the same ones, which is where my innocent pre-teen eyes saw ‘em.


I was upset for weeks. No kidding. Now that’s a comic!



Had to look the date on this one up. I never owned it, and wasn’t sure what issue it was. All I remember was some kid brought it to fourth grade and, sneaking peeks during homework time, I devoured the reprinted comic book spoofs FLESH GARDEN! and MOLE! (with art by the incomparable Wally Wood and Will Elder, respectively). Suddenly, every other comic book seemed bland and tame. These comics were clearly not for kids – not really. I didn’t get all the jokes, but I got Elder’s dark, spooky art and Wood’s insanely voluptuous babes. A copy of THE MAD READER paperback a year or so later gave me a bigger taste, and there was no going back. I still say those original comic book MADs are the finest comics ever published.



Aside from a few panels in an old COMICS JOURNAL, this issue of Warren reprints (a few years old when I bought it at a comic book store) was my first glimpse of Will Eisner. Like MAD, it was one of those moments when a door opens and there’s no looking back. The genius was apparent in every brushstroke, and the stories (like MAD) were clearly written for grown ups. You kids today, with your SPIRIT ARCHIVES collecting ever story – In order! In color! -don’t know how lucky you are.

6. X-MEN 134


I actually bought this sort of by mistake, thinking it was an issue of Marvel’s AMAZING ADVENTURES, which was then reprinting the old Jack Kirby X-MEN (and I loved me the Kirby). But this was something different. And, despite being dropped into a stew of convoluted continuity (Wolverine? The Hellfire Club? Nightcrawler? Who the hell were these people?) I was hooked, and hooked for years. See, I’d been a fan for years, but it wasn’t until I started buying X-MEN that I become a fanboy.

Story continues below



Finally, a comic book for adults that arrived when I was, well, if not actually an adult ( I was about 16) then ready to start reading and appreciating adult material. This one had everything – a brilliant view of the future, killer art, nasty humor, complex characters, sex, violence and all those garter belts. What more could you possibly want in a comic? I read it at least once a day until then second issue finally arrived a month later, then read them both until the third hit, then…well, you get the idea. Still might be my all-time favorite comic book series. Anyone know if that much-delayed hardcover collection is still coming out? I’d really like to know.



Sure, we take it for granted now, but remember how thrilling LOVE AND ROCKETS was the first time you saw it? My exposure came when, at the recommendation of a very wise friend, I picked up the first book collection at a Cleveland comic book show. I read it over and over, blown away by Beto’s complex plotting and Jaime’s eye-popping art. Like FLAGG, I read it over and over until I got my hands on another issue, then another, then another. I’m still buying it today. Thank god Fantagraphics is still publishing it.



And speaking of Fantagraphics, that’s who brought this bit of black-and-white nightmare comedy into my life. I’d followed Dan Clowes’ LLOYD LLEWELLYN, but that book’s sly humor didn’t prepare me for the sheer brilliance of EIGHTBALL. Besides a funny Lloyd story and a dark Jack Chick tract parody, this issue introduced me to Young Dan Pussey and kicked off Clowes’ Lynchian serial, “Like a Velvet Glove Cast in Iron.” And here’s the best part: As good as this issue was, it would only get better. Much better.

10. JLA: EARTH 2


I could’ve picked a lot of Grant Morrison comics for this list. I consider him one of comics best, most imaginative writers, and I count his works – ANIMAL MAN, DOOM PATROL and especially FLEX MENTALLO – among my all-time favorites. But this one-shot graphic novel is the one that got under my skin in a creepy way. Morrison took a corny old premise – there’s an Earth where instead of being good, the Justice League is evil – and ran with it, straight into some dark and disturbing corners. These villains aren’t comic book evil, they’re genuinely evil, and so is the rest of their screwed up world. When the Justice League – our league, the good one – admits there’s no way to save a world where good is doomed to fail, it’s a chilling moment. Hell, it still creeps me out just thinking about it. Thanks, Grant. (No, seriously. Thanks!)

So that’s the list. Got any of your own? Warp your mind enough, and you too might have a future as a comic book writer.

Oh, and speaking of that…the new issue of CATWOMAN (written by yours truly) hits the stands Wednesday. It guest stars Zatanna, gives a pretty solid clue to who the father of Catwoman’s baby is and even contains a geeky homage to the shower scene in PSYCHO. Check it out, won’t you?)

X-Ray Spex


The best part is that Harry takes acid because he’s suicidally depressed. Smart move, Harry.

Dammit Will! That Haunt of Fear issue looks good. Now I’ll have to track down a reprint. And yes, I am spoiled by the Spirit Archives; Vol 19 just came out.

The issue of Tomb of Dracula where Dracula quite apparently kills Dr. Strange scared the crap out of me. I regularly read both titles as a six year old since the convenience store was sold out of most other Marvel titles by the time I got there.

Somehow I missed the conclusion of the story in Dr. Strange that month, and thus, thought Dr. Strange really was dead for two months till the next month’s issue came out. I was completely freaked out that Dr. Strange had been killed by the bad guy. Only years later did I find the missing issue to find out what happened.

Polaris-powered punches are *awesome.*

A comic that *really* screwed me up as a kid was an issue of Perez’s Wonder Woman, I think, which scared me so much I hid it under the bed until we moved. #55, I think. Dr. Psycho scares the piss out of me because of that one.

And Flex Mentallo #4 was good enough to blow my brain out the back of my head and make me high on comics for a while there. Changed my life.

That Harry always was a wise user of recreational drugs!

As for a reprint of “Foul Play!,” it’s included in the (highly recommended) EC collection that came out a year or so ago called (strangely enough) “Foul Play.” Great book — profiles of every artist, with a complete story by them showcasing their work. Jack Davis’ is the story in question.

I’d also agree that the end of FLEX MENTALLO 4 is one of the most amazing things I’ve ever read. The beauty of it is is that it could actually be true. Wotta great story.

Comics that screwed me up?

Death of Superman: read it when I was about five and I didn’t read a lot of comics. I thought Big Blue was really dead. First comic I read, actually.

Dark Empire: Luke Skywalker turns evil? Even though he came back, I have never looked at him the same way again. It really alters the entire grand story of the Star Wars Universe.

Arkham Asylum: There aren’t words to describe it.

Morrison’s Animal Man: Along with AA, still informs the way I think about comics more than anything else.

Dr. Psycho’s first appearance: Back when trade paperbacks were new, my (much) older sister got this collection of early Wonder Woman stories, including the first appearance of Dr. Psycho. This was the second comic I ever read, and Dr. Psycho was a scary mo’facky. No one has ever made him quite that scary again.

It seems to me that would have more to do with Baby shower game idea than just about anything else. Hello from the US please give a little more detail for us \’dunderheads\’.

Leave a Comment



Review Copies

Comics Should Be Good accepts review copies. Anything sent to us will (for better or for worse) end up reviewed on the blog. See where to send the review copies.

Browse the Archives