CSBG Archive
God Save the Queen OGN Review
There is an interesting scene early on in God Save the Queen, the new original graphic novel out today from Vertigo Comics, written by Mike Carey and painted by John Bolton, where we briefly see the mother of our protagonist. Throughout the book, we see characters through our protagonist (Linda, by the way)’s eyes, and it is clear that she does not think well of Ava, which is what she derisively refers to her mother as. And at first glance, we, the readers, are not meant to think any better of her than Linda does – but then there is a little scene early on, just a short one, not more than a panel or two, where we get a glimpse at Ava, and though it isn’t spelled out to us blatantly, Carey is clearly hinting that there is some inner depth to Ava that we are yet to see. It’s such a nice, nuanced move, and it really captures the spirit of Mike Carey when he is hitting his strides as a writer.
This is a fun graphic novel with nice painted artwork from John Bolton.

The conceit of the book is as follows – the evil former queen of the Faerie kingdom has returned to reclaim her throne from her successor, and a young girl (Linda) gets caught up in the mess, through some fairies she meets who get her involved in a dangerous, yet exhilarating, drug. Eventually, Linda learns she is half-Fairy, and ends up getting further involved in the attempt of the attempted removal of the evil queen.
This book isn’t about the plot, really, so much as it is about character pieces – which Carey excels at in this book, especially character interactions. Linda, at times, like any teenager, is completely unfair to all of those around her, but she is never unbelievably so – her actions all seem drenched in reality, even if she is hanging out with fairies.
John Bolton’s art is strong – but the photo-realism gets a bit much sometimes, especially when it looks like he is casting panels not by the character, but by what pose he wants a character to use. It is sorta disorienting at times. For instance, while I give Bolton credit for the transformation he does later in the book to Ava, he also seems to have,rather than done a bit of “if you have someone dress differently, they can look a lot different,” just simply “recast” the character of Ava. That being said, while he seems to be fishing for good poses – when he DOES get those good poses, the resulting pages are stunning.
A drawback to the book is the portrayal of Linda’s best friend, Jeff. I think he really gets short shrift in the book, characterization-wise. Now that I think about it, the drug-dealing fairy that Linda gets involved with isn’t exactly the deepest of souls. Heck, no man in the comic is all that deep. Perhaps that is intentional on Carey’s part? He DOES have the “good” Queen state, “About the souls of men, I am as ignorant as you.”
The fact that I use quotes around good is another nice bit by Carey – the “good” Queen has her own problems – she just happens to be a significant improvement over the old one (who we are introduced to early in the book in a tremendous action scene that is evocative of the opening scene in Star Wars and the introduction of Darth Vador).
While, as I mentioned, this book is not about the action, really, when there ARE action sequences, Bolton illustrates them wonderfully, and Carey sets it all up quite well. I especially loved the way that the old queen escaped from imprisonment, and how her escape was directly tied to other story in the book, regarding the new drug (that Linda’ blood is used to make – which we also see a nice reveal regarding – was it purely coincidence that Linda met up with these particular fairies?)
All in all, this is a nice adventure tale, with a lot of nice character moments, and good (and sometimes stunning) painted artwork by John Bolton. It is also strong enough of a story that I think these characters could easily return again in the future. A job well done by Mike Carey.
Recommended.






12 Comments
Ye Olde Iowa
April 25, 2007 at 5:40 am
I’m interested in the premise of this and the art that I have seen, but I’m worried about accessibility. I know this takes place in an offshoot of Gaiman’s Sandman, which I’ve never read any of. Do you think this is something someone unfamiliar with the Faeries could easily pick up?
Ryan Day
April 25, 2007 at 6:29 am
I’ve been looking forward to this for ages – I loved The Furies, and I’m a huge fan of Carey.
It shall be mine in about 8 hours.
Greg Burgas
April 25, 2007 at 7:49 am
“reclaim her thrown,” Brian? Do I have to get on a plane, fly east, and kick your butt?
J To The AAP
April 25, 2007 at 7:50 am
Oh, that John Bolton! He was the main reason I didn’t pick up The Furies so I guess I’ll pass on this even though I often enjoy Carey’s writing.
Brian Cronin
April 25, 2007 at 12:09 pm
I just wanted to test you, Greg.
Brian Cronin
April 25, 2007 at 12:11 pm
Great question. It is totally accessible in the sense that you don’t need to know anything about Gaiman’s comics. However, I wonder how easy it would be if you knew absolutely nothing about fairies period. Hmmm…I think it would still be accessible, but yeah, if you had SOME knowledge of fairies (like who Puck is, etc.) then it would be a lot stronger read for you.
Brian Cronin
April 25, 2007 at 12:12 pm
I agree that Bolton can be a bit much at times, but I do not think he distracts from the story here. And Carey’s story is quite good.
Bully
April 25, 2007 at 1:55 pm
Is this an official Sandman-universe comic? Neil Gaiman didn’t invent the idea of fairyland and its queen by any means, and Brian’s description doesn’t even hint that it’s set in the Vertigo Sandman universe.
Brian Cronin
April 25, 2007 at 2:12 pm
Yeah, Bully, that’s what I meant by you not having to know anything about Gaiman’s comics, as these very well might be characters he mentioned, but there is no direct connection that I am aware of. Then again, I last read Sandman about the time it ended, which is over a decade ago, so I could certainly be missing something.
GarBut
April 25, 2007 at 9:58 pm
Given last week’s shock at the Alex Ross “tentpole,” I’m surprised that this discussion (or one chez MacPherson) overlooks the fact that Queen Mab’s nipple is clearly protruding in the interior panel from which the cover image is culled. I wonder how many more (or less) copies of this already niche book would be sold if that half-moon was to have risen the way that JB intended. And I wonder if he knew about the alteration?
Agreed that MC is a great character writer. Also agreed that he fails w/Jeff. God, I was convinced that he loved Linda enough to NOT do drugs with her; finding him caught up in that tangled jungle would have been less shocking if he had simply been written into enough scenes to show him on the downward spiral. Subsequent events w/him become shocking less for their content than their brusqueness, IMO.
Overall though, a superb original OGN, and one that I am quite convinced would be a fine read sans Gaimanization.
Brian Cronin
April 25, 2007 at 10:39 pm
Excellent point. A very nice summation about Jeff’s characterization.
And yeah, that is interesting about the cover.
dhollmusik
July 31, 2008 at 8:16 am
I didn’t enjoy it…too dumb. Predictable plotting, offputting artwork, juvenile writing, two-dimensional characters straight out of a factory line. Plus the pacing’s all wrong, at least for this reader.
Can anyone recommend slow-building deep, dark GN-storytelling?