web stats

CBR Live! Archive

I have sinned and throw myself at the mercy of the audience for absolution.

I did something absolutely horrible today. I... can barely bring myself to write about it, but I feel I must, if only for the good of my immortal soul. You see, today, I bought New Avengers/Transformers #1.
And I knew, too; I knew what I was doing. I knew that I was helping to kill comics, by buying this soul-deprived, market driven, fanboy wankfest, when I could have spent my $3 on an indie comic that would have helped to contribute to bringing mainstream cultural respect to this wonderful artform. I even bought it from a shop where they kept the superhero comics in full view, and don't even have a full stock of First Second and Fantagraphics backlist! I'm really going to need to do some serious penance to get back in ADD's good graces. Maybe I should commit seppuku with an arctic shit knife.*

Hell, I don't even have the nostalgia excuse. I liked the Transformers as a kid and everything, and I do have some affection for the cast of the Bendis Superteam All Star Players Monthly, but it's not like either intellectual property was a huge part of my childhood that I'm yearning to recapture. That would be the theoretical X-Men/TMNT crossover where Kitty Pryde and Donatello team up to bring nerd vengeance against the Hand and the Foot Clan and Wolverine and Casey Jones get shit faced. But I've already said too much there.

Even worse I... I kinda liked it. Stuart Moore's script was fun, and, perhaps to make Burgas and Seavey wet themselves, it did a good job explaining who everyone was. There were little text boxes and expository dialogue and everything! Which was nice to see, in what should definitely be an entry level comic. But I wanted to bust our accessibility cop's balls anyway. I'm just in one of those moods today. He even came up with a decent reason for the Avengers to act like assholes to each other, which is refreshing given that someone like Mark Millar never really bothers with that sort of thing. Okay, having Falcon, of all people, call Luke Cage brother was a little much, but I thought he had a good handle on the characters otherwise. It did hit one big nerd spot for me with the Silver Sable cameo, (her fictional European country borders Latveria? I'm even more ignorant of Marvel's geography than of the real world's), but other than that, I thought this was a really strong piece of work for a comic that could have been completely phoned in. 

I didn't like Tyler Kirkham's Top Cow-esque pencils much, but they at least told the story adequately (although I'm disappointed that he didn't have Captain America doing a Liefeld-esque exagerrated yell on the last page). I even want to buy the next issue. So, you know, feel free to flog me with your copies of Louis Riel (which I'm reading right now! Seriously! Very slowly) or your serious comics literature of choice, but I'll be damned if this wasn't fun. I don't want to sing its praises too much, lest the vengeful spirit of Joe Rice haunt me for going nuts at the end of the day over what's just a competent exercise in synergy with a blockbuster movie (Paul O'Brian had a point when he said that an FF/Transformers crossover would have made more sense from a 
"we're having money for lunch!" perspective), but I do like to give comics I buy on flights of sleep deprived fancy credit when they're bet than I expected them to be, much less when they're better than they have to be. I know I would be doing the world blogosphere, and probably the world, a world of good if I had given my thoughts on a comic that wasn't going to sell like crack, porn, or Ashlee Simpson albums anyway (nobody's admitting to buying it, but somebody has to be); hell, I would probably be helping to reduce my carbon footprint and end world hunger if I had, say, taken Burgas's challenge and bought something outside my comfort zone (even if it was the same kind of thing as I always read, just not from Marvel and DC), but... ah, hell, I'm sick of snottily justifying liking this stupid thing. It was fun. I'll get the next issue. It's not great, world changing stuff, but for $3.00 of market driven pablum, I enjoyed it.

*- I really didn't mean that to be as pissy and confrontational as it came off. **

**- Okay, I did, I just don't want to deal with the consequences of actually answering to... whoever it was I was raging against there. Some imaginary comic book hipster snob who is probably as real as Bigfoot or Dick Hyacinth. ***

***- I just get the feeling that he's the elaborate fictional construct of three Indian call center workers, a super intelligent Koala Bear, and pro wrestling legend Randy Savage, you know? I mean come on, people, read between the lines! It's right there!

  • Posted on July 11, 2007 @ 06:32 PM

14 Comments

"Even worse I… I kinda liked it."

Words can not express my reaction to that. I'm used to the writers here being hate-filled bastards who despise everything I like, so to see something resembling praise for a book I couldn't stand is kind of baffling.

I like New Avengers, I like IDW's Transformers, and I like Stuart Moore. That makes me the target audience, but I found it a huge disappointment.

Manomanomanomanoman I want that TMNT/X-men crossover. Or, failing that (or, even better, at the same time) an FF/TF crossover by Simonson and/or Furman. With Simonson on art, of course.

Loved the write up...
Livin'

I bought this to read with my 6-year old son, and it's waaay cooler than the IDW Transformer comics I picked up for him last year. But, man, those Marvel comics use such a dark color palatte, it's really hard for kids to follow the story.

(It's the same complaint I have about Marvel Adventures: Avengers, which is a great comic, except everything is so murky compared to the brightness and joy that you find in the Johnny DC line.)

Also, is Falcon really the guy you want to call in for back-up? He's not my first choice for a robot-stopping powerhouse of a character.

But my son thinks he's cool and so do I. He's got wings!

The seven-year-old in me cried out with joy when I first saw this crossover announced. You don't need to overly justify this, it even validates your reviews when you have the guts to occasionaly like something that's not the blogosphere's darling.

You can dine on gourmet meals by awarded chefs but still get a craving for a decent burger sometimes.

I think just about the first intercompany inter franchise crossover I read was Batman vs Predator by Dave Gibbons and one or two of the Kuberts and really that set the bar so high that none I've read since has measured up. In fact none has been that good at all.

Yet somehow I'm still planning on buying Judge Dredd vs Aliens: Incubus

I enjoyed Avengers/Transformers more than I enjoyed All-Star Superman.

I can't believe I'm saying this either, but I also liked it better than the new All-Star Superman. I think it's because of the awful Bizarro dialogue.

Is this really the comic you want to get on an anti-snobbery high horse for? It'd be one thing if you loved it, but "kinda liked it", "told the story adequately", "It’s not great", and "market driven pablum"?

If you love superhero books or old toy tie-ins, then go for it. But why would anyone spend money on a book that's just okay by their own standards?

Why are you trying to jsutify yourself for liking something? Yes, the crossover is the comic book equivalent of junk-food, but we all crave a little bit of junk food now and then.

Enjoy the book, and let out a big "OHHHHHHH YEEEEEEAHHH"

Sheesh, calm down. At least you bought some cheap mainstream comic you like then some indie comic thats a chore to wrap your head around.

I have the cover as my wallpaper right now...I mean, Captain America and Optimus Prime together? Do I need to draw you a diagram? Probably the second coolest Transformers-realted comic cover ever, if only because the TF #5 Shockwave "Are All Dead?" cover is so goddamn cool it blows my mind...

I find it hilarious that praising or recognizing independent comics automatically means you hate the mainstream ones and look down upon their readers. Insecurity!

Leave a Comment

 

Subscribe to CSBG

Categories

Review Copies

Comics Should Be Good accepts review copies. Anything sent to us will (for better or for worse) end up reviewed on the blog. See where to send the review copies.

Browse the Archives