web stats

CSBG Archive

365 Reasons to Love Comics #205

Without further ado (except the usual archive link), I present to you one of my favorite creators, a brilliant writer/artist of titanic talent, and possessor of the world’s greatest signature.


205. Walter Simonson

Walt 1.JPG

Walt Simonson, he of the dinosaur signature and the unending sound effects, has written and drawn some of the finest comics to ever grace my eyes. His art style might not be for everyone, but it’s for me– the raw power his art portrays punches its way off of the page to hit you right in the eyeballs. His writing style might not be for everyone, either– but he’s got the ability to tell these sprawling epics that evoke the mythic tales of old. He’s also the only worthy successor to Jack Kirby on the Fourth World, and one of the few creators with enough artistic presence to rival the explosive strength of Kirby’s drawings. Face it. “Uncle Walt” is mighty and fantastic.

His breakthrough work was on Manhunter, at DC, with Archie Goodwin. Sadly, I am a bad fan, because I have yet to track it down, but I know it is good, so you should buy it anyway.

The most popular thing he ever did, however, was his run on Thor, which I talked about yesterday. It’s the definitive Thor run, bringing the character back to his mythological roots whilst telling a massive story that continues throughout all forty-some issues of the run, from the abandonment of Don Blake and the excellent introduction of Beta Ray Bill to the evil of Malekith, the oncoming doom of Surtur, the plans of Hela, the death of Odin, the redemption of Skurge, the beard of Thor, the lovely characterization of Balder and Volstagg, the Frog of Thunder, the machinations of Loki, the fury of the Midgard Serpent, and the invasion of the Frost Giants. I’ve left a ton out– it’s a big series which keeps raising the stakes and getting bigger and bigger until every issue is rocking you to the core. I managed to get the whole run on eBay for an incredibly affordable price. A great deal of it is in trade, but they’re out-of-print. If you haven’t read it, seek it out. It’s the thrill of the hunt at its finest. Here, have more Thor love from Dave Campbell and Chris Sims. They know good comics.

Walt 8.jpgWalt 7.JPG

He collaborated with his wife Louise on a nice X-Factor run during Marvel’s ’80s heyday as well. I’ve got a few issues of it, and it’s really fun, with Walt bringing the same energy and verve to his artwork as he did in Thor.

Then there was Fantastic Four, in which Walt gave us the best run since Lee and Kirby. Yeah, yeah, Byrne, whatever. Pffh. This was Simonson, baby! It starts with Reed Richards deftly destroying any hope of a Superhero Registration Act passing (ahh, if only…) and quickly broke into a crazed time travel extravaganza, where they saved the universe from Galactus and the Celestials, battled the greatest menace of all time (an evil Disney-built Robo-Stalin-mech from a parallel world, of course) in one of the best issues of FF ever, faced off against dinosaurs, and rematched with Dr. Doom, who was returned to his mighty badass status. It’s here, in #352, that Simonson shows us his genius again, and has an issue with a completely nonlinear subplot that involves a Reed/Doom battle where they hop through time (and through the comic’s pages) whilst a linear narrative is occurring at the same time. Oh, and his run also included the new Fantastic Four (Spidey, Hulk, Wolverine, and Ghost Rider!) and some more goodness. It was a short, but ridiculously fun run, filled with Walt’s usual whimsy and over-the-top sense of scale. If you don’t believe that it was awesome, then listen to Chris Sims, already. And read Greg Burgas’ Comics You Should Own piece on the new Fantastic Four.

Walt 4.jpgWalt 6.JPG

The third and final great run Mr. Simonson produced was his work on Orion #1-25, from DC. He truly lives up to Kirby here, which is a monumental feat. It’s also one of my top five favorite comics ever made. When I had stopped buying comics for a while, I was still getting Orion, because it was so damn good. Walt kept me believing in the medium. Hurray!

Story continues below

Walt 5.JPG

Anyway, the story involved Orion finally fighting Darkseid to the death. He wins, becomes ruler of Apokalips, and systematically takes the place apart, ending with his defeat of Desaad, through which he is gifted with the one thing his father always wanted– the Anti-Life Equation. It leads him down a dark path, however, and he enslaves a good portion of the universe, against his own wishes. Darkseid turns out not to be dead, though, and it is Orion that the Black Racer comes for at last– but Orion manages to survive by a hair’s breadth, and finally purges the Anti-Life Equation by bestowing it upon the evil anti-Source, aptly named the Ecruos– thereby destroying it. He’s semi-redeemed, but must still meet the Green Lantern of Apokolips, the Jokerized version of one of the Deep Six. It is a human being named Arnicus Wolfram that finally brings him down, tortures him, and holds him captive, however. Orion breaks free, and, of course, has his revenge, in a magnificent sequence that proves Orion is the New God of War– and also has a moment that may out-Kirby Kirby. There was only one issue left after that, unfortunately, but it’s a great one involving Mister Miracle. This run is filled with new and interesting additions to the Fourth World mythos like Mortalla and Father Boxes and Orion’s hound Sirius and a lot more. It’s the story of the rise and fall, the corruption and redemption, of Red Orion, and it’s one of the best comics ever produced. There’s only one trade, and it’s probably out of print. Remember the thrill of the hunt? Live up to the memory of Orion the Hunter, and track down those back issues. You won’t regret it.

Walt 2.JPGWalt 3.JPG

Walter Simonson has written and drawn some of the greatest comics of all time, and I offer my infinite thanks to him. His larger-than-life, rock-and-roll style of writing and drawing has kept me entertained for years, as he’s made some of the best comics ever. In fact, no– he doesn’t make comics; he makes experiences. The power and energy and strength he brings to all his projects has served him well, and I’m always following him to his next work, awaiting a new masterpiece. When he’s on, he’s on, and my brain explodes with wonder. He can be huge and dramatic and serious, and he can be wacky, wry, and just plain fun. I think I’ve hit the peak of my enthusiasm levels here with discussing his work, but dammit, it’s great stuff. He can dust off a concept and make it shine like new. He can play in the sandbox, but he also brings his own sand with him. He’s… wait for it… awesome!, in every sense of the word.

He’s also immensely gracious to his fans, contributing to the Thor and New Gods message boards on Comicboards, as well as a few other forums, and that’s great to see. He’ll be seen next writing a World of Warcraft comic for DC. I never played the games, but I’m interested in the comic based on Walt’s name alone. Because in my book, the name “Walter Simonson” means I have to read it.

(Also, there’s only one letterer for Simonson’s work, and that’s John Workman. Trust me, we’ll be seeing him one of these days.)


Tom Fitzpatrick

July 24, 2007 at 6:12 pm


Written by Michael Moorcock and drawn by good ol’ Mr. Simonson!

Definitely worth the read.

Dan (other Dan)

July 24, 2007 at 6:40 pm

Bill, what are your thoughts on his recent Hawkgirl stint? I only read one issue (not a pejorative statement, I just only happened to pick up one issue).

Simonson is definitely a reason to love comics.

He is also responsible (indirectly) for Comic Book Urban Legends Revealed! :)


July 24, 2007 at 6:52 pm

Manhunter is in a trade Bill, you have no excuse!

It’s anti-decompression, it’s the most compressed motherfucker I ever read – and it shows why it’s better.
Screw comics stealing from film, Simonson makes every panel a part of the whole page.
This shit should be studied, yo!

World of Warcraft is a great fit for him, isn’t it?

Simonson may be the only person who can make (in FF he did) a five parter so crammed full of stuff that if you miss two issues a whole galactic armada can disappear as if it never was…

and the plot still remains comprehensible.

The Kirbydotter

July 24, 2007 at 7:40 pm

Archie Goodwin & Walter Simonson’s MANHUNTER (shame on you!) is one of the gems of the Bronze Age (my favorite era). I don’t understand how you can be such a fan of Simonson and not have read this yet!?!? It’s a must!

You are saying almost exactly what I was writing in yesterday’s entry: Simonson is one of the rare artist who can do Kirby’s creations justice (not just the New Gods). John Romita Jr, Bruce Timm, Darwyn Cooke, Mike Mignola and yes John Byrne (which you dont seem to like, which is too bad cause it probably means he won’t get his own entry…) are among the other very few.

Visually, I liked Simonson on ORION but I don’t hink his stories were that much better than Byrne’s. I don’t remember a single storyline from Simonson’s ORION… So I guess they didn’t make a deep enough impression on me to remember them even though it wasn’t that long ago. Anyway, I have yet to see anyone other than Kirby write a good NEW GODS story… Well COSMIC ODYSSEY was nice (Starlin wrote it) but Mike Mignola’s art had a lot to do with it.

You should also track down a TPB that came out from DC a few years ago. I think the title was THE ART OF WALT SIMONSON (but I’m sure about the exact title). It had a few good example of his early work at DC: Hercules, Metal Men, Batman, Manhunter and some cool pirate tales he did in one of DC war mags.

You should also track down a black & white magazine from that great Bronze Age again: THRILLING ADVENTURE STORIES #2. It was published by Atlas/Seabord in 1975. Issue # 2 was the last issue… But what an issue! Cool pulp style stories by: Russ Heath! Alex Toth! John Severin! and yes, Walt Simonson! A cool samurai story written by Archie Goodwin (IIRC). All this under a Neal Adams cover. Is that a nice package or what?

Twomorrows has recently published a book about Simonson in their MODERN MASTERS SERIES (it’s volume 8). Lots of pictures and a long interview. But I would have prefered a little more details about the Bronze Age when Walt started and also a deeper exploration of his THOR days. To the point: I cannot get enough Simonson!

The Kirbydotter

July 24, 2007 at 7:43 pm

i don’t understant how come it was erased but the MODERN MASTERS volume about Simonson is # 8

I have some of the original issues of that Manhunter storyline, and a reprint of the whole thing (couldn’t resist when I saw it.

I’d contend that, pound for pound, Simonson’s THOR is the greatest example of a superhero comic ever produced. So yeah, kinda tough for anything else he does to compete with that. The fact that his FF and Orion DO compete with it is a testament to how great he is. Great as Pak and JRJr are on WWHulk, just imagine Uncle Walt getting a crack at it — it’d be legendary!

I don’t know. I bought 337-355 but wasn’t too thrilled by it. Going to sell them again.

Rather oldfashioned good vs. evil saga. Which is too boring for my taste.

FF #352 was one of the best comics my teenage self ever read. Truly amazing stuff, and, even better – the cover of the issue is itself part of the main story (the Reed/Doom fight through time). The cover’s not just an illustration of what’s inside the book. Note the clock in the bottom right corner!

Yes, that was what I was going to mention–the fight in FF #352 is non-linear, but it isn’t random; as Reed and Doom hop back and forth in time fighting each other, you hop back and forth through the pages of the book to follow their battle. A brilliant way to handle time travel in a comic, one of the all-time best Reed/Doom battles, and part of one of the all-time great runs on the Fantastic Four. (I don’t dismiss Byrne’s, but I love Simonson’s just as well. I remember so well coming out of Englehart’s run, which had been badly mutilated by the end by editorial, and just feeling that energy coming off the page. It was like it was springtime again.)

Then came Tom DeFalco…

If you’re a Simonson fan you have to pick up his Alien graphic novel adaptation with Archie Goodwin.

Awesome Simonson take on HR Giger designs!

Of course the Thor run was his best, and Orion as close to a kirby feel (in the best of ways) as we’ll ever see with those characters.

But I just couldn’t get into his FF. At all. To the point that I’m surprised that people liked it.

Visually, I liked Simonson on ORION but I don’t hink his stories were that much better than Byrne’s. I don’t remember a single storyline from Simonson’s ORION… So I guess they didn’t make a deep enough impression on me to remember them even though it wasn’t that long ago.

Pfah! Byrne’s Fourth World run was absolutely terrible, but Simonson’s blew my brain out the back of my head. In a good way, of course.

the Goodwin/Simonson Manhunter is a reason comics are good!

The Kirbydotter

July 25, 2007 at 4:45 pm

Well put Lauren!

Bill: I don’t remember a lot of Byrne’s run on the NEW GODS either, but, c’mon man, I don’t think it was that terrible. It was not great, granted, it certainly wasn’t as good as I would have expected a classic Kirby creation done by Byrne would be.

If you’re a Simonson fan you have to pick up his Alien graphic novel adaptation with Archie Goodwin.

I really didn’t like that – but then I don’t think I’ve ever enjoyed a comic adaptation of a film

Leave a Comment



Review Copies

Comics Should Be Good accepts review copies. Anything sent to us will (for better or for worse) end up reviewed on the blog. See where to send the review copies.

Browse the Archives