free hit counter

javascript

CBI Archive

So, I just read Persepolis over the weekend…

Tuesday, July 31st, 2007 at 1:47 PM EST

Updated: Tuesday, July 31st, 2007 at 1:47 PM EST

Making me perhaps the last comics reader on Earth to do so.* It’s one of those kinds of books I leave my adventure comics comfort zone to read everyone once in awhile, but only begruddingly so; I feel obligated to read it, because it’s “important”. That doesn’t neccesarily mean I’m going to, y’know, like it, but that’s irrelavent; it’s a part of the growing graphic literature canon, and also extremely relevant to many very important events going on in the world.

After all, when the book was first published, Iran was still a fairly freshly minted member of the Axis of Evil, and their stature as America’s new boogeyman has only grown (not without some merit, mind you. I’m trying really hard not to go too political either way here, folks). So, like Pyongyang, this is the kind of comic worth reading just because it offers a glimpse in to a culture that I’m pretty damn ignorant of but shouldn’t be. What surprised the hell out of me is how damn much I liked it.**

First of all, I found Marjane Satrapi a very engaging character in her own story. Lil’ Marji was so damn cute, and her general outspokeness throughout the book gave it a lot of the humor that kept it from being as grim and unrelenting as it could have been, being set during the rise of a repressive regime and all. I’m not neccessarily a huge fan of diary comics, but I liked Satrapi enough that her narration (especially the bits where she talked to the reader) worked for me.

I also liked her artwork more than I expected to. It’s very minimalist, to say the least (to use a word I see a lot in superhero circles, it’s cartoony***), and in some scenes that hurts it a little; I was really kind of hoping that someone like Brian Hitch or Chris Weston could ghost the scenes of the bombings of Tehran, for instance, even if it would have screwed up the tone of the book and what not, because I really wanted to see some cool, lovingly rendered planes instead of the stark, inky figures Satarpi drew. But for every one of those kind of fanboy longings, I found myself struck by how she used the black and white format of the book for effect (sort of reminded me of what I’ve seen of David B’s work, who she does thank at the end of the book). I also loved the way she could draw expressions.

This book had pretty much everything I look for in a comic, or hell, any story. It was funny, poignant, and informative, not to mention impossible to put down. If Hellboy, Scott Pilgrim, and She Hulk had dropped by for a cameo drawn by Mike Allred, it would have been perfect. As it is, it was a really refreshing story that was more than just important; it was actually a joy to read. I look forward to the second one, even if our own Greg Burgas did compare it to a urine coloring vegetable. If anyone else out there’s on the fence about reading this, don’t be.****

*- Now I just need to get it back to the co-worker I borrowed it from. At the place I no longer work at.

**- I wanted to work another soft curse word in there, like piss or crap, but I couldn’t find a way to shoehorn it in there.

***- Which make sense, seeing as how she’s a goddamn cartoonist. Not unlike the Goddamn Batman.*****

****- Especially if you can borrow it from a co-worker and forget to return it for six months!

*****- Is that joke dead yet? If so, how dead? Are we talking total decomposition, or some flesh still on the bones? If I make an effort to ressurect it, does that make it a zombie? And if I keep babbling on like this, can I be cool like Abhay?

11 Comments

FunkyGreenJerusalem

July 31, 2007 at 5:26 pm

r there boobz in it?

Rohan Williams

July 31, 2007 at 6:10 pm

What a great book. I’m looking forward to the movie, too.

Uh…there’s still one comics reader left on Earth that has yet to read it.

Me.

Maybe someday…

Guess what? You can find “important” comics like Persepolis all over the place. Comics that make actual artistic statements; comics that might just serve as literature. Let’s get started! Your homework:

1) Anders Nilsen - Don’t Go Where I Can’t Follow
2) Jeffrey Brown - Clumsy, The Incredible Change-Bots
3) Chris Ware - Acme Novelty Library 16 & 17
4) Craig Thompson - Carne De Voyage
5) Robert Crumb - Kafka
6) Chester Brown - Louis Riel

Carnet De Voyage is a very fun travelogue, but I don’t know if there’s a whole lot of literary merit there. I think Blankets probably makes more of a “statement.” The others I haven’t read.

Anyhow, I really liked Persepolis. I recall walking away from it not knowing quite what to think, which may well be an argument in its favor. I do know that Satrapi is brilliant at putting emotion on the page, and the portrait of a repressive culture that she sketches really connects with you.

I very eagerly look forward to the animated movie — I’ve only seen one or two clips, but they look fantastic.

I read the Dutch translation which is all four books in one tome and I think that’s probably the best way the read it. You get a clear view of the overbearing arc and almost feel as if you’ve grown along a bit with her. It’s not only a great book but also a great exmple of what the comics medium is capable of. I’d highly recommend it!

I do hope they do a second movie too, though I really like to see it it would be a bit depressing since #2 doesn’t exactly end happily (the movie encompasses Persepolis 1 & 2).

BTW, I agree with Patrick’s assessment of Blankets and Carnet de Voyage, i thought the same thing when I saw that list.

If you feel like reading more comics literature with ‘cartoony’ art I’d suggest Manu Larcenet’s Ordinary Victories. Fan-freaking-tastic comic, IMO.

Now, I’m OK with Carne De Voyage.

And I haven’t read it, so I’m speaking from ignorance here. But I just can’t believe that The Incredible Change Bots is a great work of comics art.

Or, well, not a huge pile of suck. Jeffery Brown does a Transformers parody? How could that possibly be good?

On the other hand it’s tough to argue with Go Where I Can’t Follow and Kafka.

And I really should re-read Persepolis. I know I read it, but I’ve got only the haziest memories.

The Hebrew translated version sits in my drawer for the last year and a half, and I have yet to read it.

If you wish to preserve your enjoyment of this book, I strongly recommend you avoid its execrable second installment.

Also the hilarious thing about “Kafka” is that it was never intended to be an “important comic” in the first place. It was merely another installment in the now-venerable Brit (I think) “Introducing” series (”Introducing Kafka” was the original title). It wasn’t until after it had been out a few years that someone realized what an incredible thing Crumb and that other guy (Crumb didn’t write it I don’t think) did, and repackaged it as an “important comic” rather than what was essentially a “For Dummies” book.

If you wish to preserve your enjoyment of this book, I strongly recommend you avoid its execrable second installment.

I thought the 2nd half was just as good as the first half

Leave a Comment

 

Subscribe to CSBG

Categories

Review Copies

Comics Should Be Good accepts review copies. Anything sent to us will (for better or for worse) end up reviewed on the blog. See where to send the review copies.

Browse the Archives