CBR Live! Archive
John Seavey's Storytelling Engines: Marvel Two-In-One
Here's the latest Storytelling Engine from John Seavey. Click here to read John's description of what a Storytelling Engine IS, anyways. Check out more of them at his blog, Fraggmented.
Storytelling Engines: Marvel Two-In-One
(or "You Can Pick Your Friends, But You Can't Pick Your Family")
For an idea as difficult to write for as the "Team-Up" engine (spotlighted previously in Marvel Team-Up and The Brave and the Bold), comic books that revolve primarily around their central character teaming up with a spotlighted super-hero every month sure do seem to get a lot of play. This week, we're looking at 'Marvel Two-In-One', another book in which a notoriously anti-social hero (although by this point, Ben Grimm, the Thing, has been seriously de-fanged and is more "grumpy" than "anti-social") teams up every month with a different super-hero, forcing the book to come up with reasons every month why super-heroes just happen to keep bumping into the Thing. And, of course, it also has to maintain continuity with the Thing's own title...
But hang on. The Thing doesn't have his own title. Oh, sure, he's a member of the Fantastic Four, and the writer of 'Marvel Two-In-One' has to maintain continuity with that series. But there's a whole different dynamic at work when maintaining continuity between a team book and a solo book than there is between two solo series. A team book revolves around the team, not necessarily its individual members; with four people in the Fantastic Four, each with their own private life and developments as well as the need to tell stories about the entire team, there's a lot less pressure on the writer to make sure important developments in the life of Ben Grimm happen in the FF's own series. In fact, some writers might welcome the chance to let the Thing's life happen in the Thing's title so they can focus on Johnny, Reed and Sue; just keep up to date on the big things, add a few footnotes now and then mentioning important developments in MTIO (which has the bonus of boosting sales of the spin-off to boot), and their job is done.
Of course, it helps that Ben Grimm's life is relatively "big shake-up" free. 'Marvel Two-In-One' didn't do anything like break up the Thing's relationship with long-time girlfriend Alicia Masters, or cause him to leave the Fantastic Four. Indeed, the storytelling engine of MTIO, with its emphasis on team-ups, guest stars, and fast-moving stories precluded the series from getting any momentum with its lone stable character. (Except, of course, that it gave him a side job as security director for 'Project: Pegasus', which served both the storytelling need to give him a supporting cast and location distinct from his 'Fantastic Four' appearances, and the storytelling need to give him an excuse to bump into numerous other comic book characters on a regular basis.)
Eventually, after one hundred issues, this book metamorphosized into a 'Thing' solo series, just as 'Marvel Team-Up' turned into 'Web of Spider-Man'. Without the anchor of having to put rotating team-ups into the book, suddenly the Thing's personal life took center stage and gave him plenty of room to develop his character. However, the attempts to develop a storytelling engine for the Thing conflicted with his position in the Fantastic Four, and he virtually vanished from the FF series until his solo series folded thirty-six issues later. Which is a not uncommon fate for characters on solo books who are also in teams--sooner or later, something happens to their life in their solo book that makes it hard to keep them in a team. That's why there are always a few members of any super-team that don't have their own series; because while it's nice to not have to worry about every member of the team and their personal life, sometimes you just want toys of your own to play with.
- Posted on August 27, 2007 @ 09:53 AM






8 Comments
suedenim
August 27, 2007 at 10:11 am
I never much cared for MTIO as a kid, but it's surprising to me how much I *love* it in the Essentials.
It's a really nice "storytelling engine" in a number of ways. First and foremost, the formula of "(Ben Grimm + Friend) team up and Clobber" is great fun on a pure elemental level. And while Ben often does need to use his noggin or his piloting skills, MTIO fights tend to work with Ben's strengths more than Fantastic Four fights.
What do I mean by that? Read some Lee/Kirby FF stories, and see how many times you get a line like this from Reed: "No, Ben! Brute strength alone won't get us out of this jam!" In MTIO, more often than not, brute strength and clobberin' *will* get Ben out of the jam!
Also (compared to, say, Marvel Team-Up, or even The Brave and the Bold), you can usually set up the team-up in a fairly plausible manner. The FF are the most famous superheroes in the world, and everybody knows their address. Having people just wander by (and Reed and Susie are off experimentin' in the ever-lovin' Negative Zone, and Match-head's off workin' on his hot rod, which leaves just bashful ol' Benjy!) - it's not all that big a stretch (so to speak.) And the FF know just about everybody. It's hard to get beyond 3 degrees of separation, let alone 6, to any Marvel character, and that's even discounting "casual acquaintances met in the Big Crossover" stuff.
In MTU, by contrast, you're often reduced to "Spidey web-swingin' across town, and - hey, look! Isn't that Wonder Man? And why's he fighting a giant dinosaur in Central Park?"
But, really, it's all about the clobbering.
ken
August 27, 2007 at 11:12 am
The nice thing about MTIO (and MTU) was that the issues were standalone.
If you just wanted something to read -- just to pass a half-hour -- you could choose a book basically at random, and not have to worry if it was Part 3 of a 6-part arc.
Also, it gave the oxygen of publicity to a few minor characters that you almost never saw otherwise.
Doug Atkinson
August 27, 2007 at 11:57 am
To clarify the context of the Thing leaving the FF when his own solo title started, it should be noted that a) John Byrne was writing both titles at the time, and b) the specific reason he left the FF at the time was so he could stay on Battleworld from Secret Wars, where he could return to human at will. The first several issues of his solo title focused on his Battleworld adventures, which precluded his being on Earth with the FF at the same time.
Eventually he returned to Earth but didn't rejoin the FF right away; I don't know if it was so the Thing series could stand on its own or because Byrne wanted to keep She-Hulk in the FF. During this era he hung out with the West Coast Avengers a bit, and the Unlimited Class Wrestling Federation was introduced. (Why has this concept pretty much vanished entirely for the past 20 years, incidentally? It would be hard to sustain it as a series, but if nothing else it would be a useful dumping ground for characters who didn't work as crimefighters.)
suedenim
August 27, 2007 at 12:14 pm
Actually, it's surprising how many story arcs there actually *are* in MTIO. There's quite a lot of that going on in the 2nd Essentials book. For instance, there's a story with Nick Fury where the bad guys end up using Deathlok, who's the cover guest in the next issue. The good guys win, but Deathlok needs treatment from a scientist in London who's The Only One Who Can Save Him. Ben travels to London (with Alicia, to make it a sort of vacation too), and there's a Hydra plot against the scientist, which brings in the then-new Spider-Woman as guest star, and that story leads into the next with a "???" mystery villain, and so on....
It actually takes a half-dozen issues or so before Ben's back in America and Deathlok's no longer at death's door. OTOH, unlike many of today's comics, you could pick up any one of those issues and still get a non-confusing "done-in-one" experience - it's just there's linkage between them and a broader story if you read them all.
FunkyGreenJerusalem
August 28, 2007 at 1:27 am
I don't know if you should keep doing team-up books - they aren't built with proper engines.
On Brave & The Bold there wasn't one (neither in the book or in your post), and in this one the storytelling engine got squashed into a throw away sentence.
John Seavey
August 29, 2007 at 5:57 am
Well, I'm definitely not doing any more team-up books; there aren't any more.
I tried to focus on the nuances of each team-up book, since they share an essentially identical basic premise; if I failed, then I'm sorry. Hopefully you'll stick around now that I've gotten it out of my system.
And I know why Ben left the FF within the fictional Marvel universe, but my point is that from a storytelling perspective, he left the FF because there's a limited amount you can do with him in a solo series while still keeping him tied into the Fantastic Four's series. That's why pretty much every character who has their own series takes extended leaves of absence from whatever team they're a member of (Captain America, Thor, Iron Man, et cetera, in the Avengers)...it's because when they're running a major storyline, it gets hard to co-ordinate. So he left for Battleworld both because he had a good "in-character" reason to stay there, and because John Byrne didn't want to make the Thing's own series into "Fantastic Four-A".
The Mutt
August 29, 2007 at 1:47 pm
What ever happened to Ron Wilson?
John Seavey
August 30, 2007 at 5:03 am
He's head coach of the San Jose Sharks, now, and...
...oh, wait. Wrong Ron Wilson. Apparently he'll be at New York Comic Con in 2008, so you can go there and ask him yourself. It looks like he's been doing work here and there, but has been kind of quiet lately.