CBR Live! Archive
An Unfortunate Story of War
- by Brian Cronin
- in General
I was re-reading Garth Ennis' one-shot, War Story: Nightingale just the other day.

The story tells the harrowing tale of a British supply ship during World War II which is eventually sunk. The situation is quite unfortunate, but I think it is worth noting that as bad off as the sailors had it, they, at least, were members of the British Royal Navy.
Their equivalents, the United States Merchant Marine, were not members of the US Navy, and were, in fact, not even granted Veteran status for World War II until the end of Ronald Reagan's presidency.
While sporting a higher casualty rate than the Navy, the Army and the Air Force during World War II (almost 4%), currently, Merchant Marine veterans of World War II do not receive government benefits for their service during World War II. An act looking to pay them a small $1,000 a month pension was recently passed in the House of Representatives, and is now trying to gain approval by the Senate. If you are interested in finding out more about the Act, click here.
Sorry for not being more comic-related. It was comic-inspired, though!!
- Posted on September 24, 2007 @ 07:30 AM






9 Comments
tom fitzpatrick
September 24, 2007 at 5:17 am
If you enjoyed "Nightingale", you should check out "D-Day Dodgers", another excellent war story by Ennis.
Hell, read both volumes of War Story. They're all good.
avengers63
September 24, 2007 at 7:34 am
"There is no greater love than to lay your life down for another."
And all we do is shit on them when they do. It's a disgrace. We should be collectively ashamed of ourselves as a nation for this sort of thing.
Of course, if it doesn't affect us directly, why should we care? And where's my double-decaf mocha carmel latte? I'm late for aromatherapy and I don't have time for your "problems".
mariner
September 24, 2007 at 9:46 am
It should also, be noted...The greater majority of crew members aboard the "floating coffins" (Liberty Ships) during WW2 were 16 year old kids that had dropped out of high school. They were recruited by U.S. Maritime Service officers, representatives of the United States Government!
Brian Cronin
September 24, 2007 at 2:02 pm
Oh, agreed. I've enjoyed them all. I just happened to be re-reading this one recently.
And yeah, "D-Day Dodgers" is another great example of how unfairly history treats people. "You were stationed somewhere else during D-Day? COWARD!" "You were a Merchant Mariner? You're not a veteran!"
Brian Cronin
September 24, 2007 at 2:03 pm
Sad, but true.
But what's even sadder is that the people this essentially DOES affect, the Senators who decide whether to make the Act a law or not, THEY manage to find reasons not to approve it.
It's one thing for Joe Public to be ignorant of the situation, it's another thing for Joe Senator to know the facts and STILL decide to ignore it!!
Brian Cronin
September 24, 2007 at 2:04 pm
Great point.
Sadly, it's just another great point piled upon other great points that, to this point, have not managed to convince the Senate to approve of the Remembrance Act.
Apodaca
September 24, 2007 at 2:16 pm
What?
Who's shitting on dead soldiers?
FunkyGreenJerusalem
September 24, 2007 at 7:50 pm
If it makes you feel better, which it won't, France rallied troops from all over Africa, particuarly Algeria, to help liberate them from occupation.
Not only were black troops not allowed to move up in the rank, or even eat the same food as white/French troops, the government refused to pay them veterans pensions, or even acknowledge the help they gave.
This only changed a few years ago when the film Days Of Glory was released - Chriac saw it (which is amazing as the French government usually ignores, or bans, highly critical films) and changed the law immediatley, and pensions were back paid.
Unfortunately the majority that served died poor, but it is nice they finally got some recognition and compensation.
Corinne Simons
September 25, 2007 at 7:50 am
"Should the colour of your ships ensign determine whether those who died in action deserve protection...
Recent Government acknowledgement now allows veterans to stand proud alongside the other deserving veterans of HM Armed Forces. MN Veterans have now been accepted by Government and the MoD to have been a critical part of what was achieved in times of war and conflict and are entitled to the same recognition emblems and badges that are being presented to all veterans. This has resulted in a unique honour...
The UK Merchant Seafarers Veteran’s Badge. The MN Styled Veteran’s Badge is a specially modified version of the HM Forces Veteran’s badge."
I chanced upon your page, and would like to correct the view that our UK Merchant Mariners were part of the Royal Navy. They were not, and the above quotes are from the Merchant Navy Association web page: http://www.MNA.org.uk.
It took 8 years of campaigning to get the Arctic Star approved. They do not have the same benefits that those members of the RN had. They have only recently been given the right to march in the Remembrance Parade to the Cenotaph in Whitehall on 11 November.
Please also remember that the US Merchant Marine were already facing enemy action from U Boats long before the US officially entered the war. We owe them a great debt of gratitude. I recall reading that owing to breaking the Enigma codes operated by the U Boats, the British told the US Navy that there were Wolf Packs off the Eastern Seaboard, but the US Admiral, who didn't like the British after WW1 chose to ignore this, and silhouetted against the lights of the cities, were picked off as they put to sea.
I am thankfully too young to have experienced that war, but am only too aware that the freedom I have is down to those who sacrificed so much.
Corinne Simons, England.