CSBG Archive
Top 100 Marvel Characters #51-55
Don’t expect this on any regular schedule! I still need to do the Judging Books By Their Covers!
51. Captain Marvel (Mar-Vell) – 126 points (1 first place votes)

52 (tie). The Angel (Warren Worthington III) – 125 points

52 (tie). Green Goblin (Norman Osborn) – 125 points

52 (tie). Moon Knight – 125 points

55. Scarlet Witch – 124 points

Here is why John Cupach voted for the Scarlet Witch…
Wanda is by far my favorite female character. I grew up with the Avengers and she was a prominent part of the team in those days. Her powers were interesting and unique. Her costume is simple but still vibrant. I started with the Avengers oddly enough in Marvel Two-in-One Annual 2. From there I started buying the Avengers from 162. Wanda really stood out in 171 with that great Perez cover. She also showed her potental by taking out Ultron singlehandedly. Over the years she seemed to be a central figure in the Marvel U. She was featured in the last chapter of the Serpent Crown Affair in MTIO. Her background was further expanded on in later Avengers issues and her limited series with Vision (in which she was revealed to be Magneto’s daughter). Also I always felt she was sexy without going overboard.
Of course I’m not surprised by her low ranking. Over the past decade Marvel really has ruined her character. I think she’s gone mad about three times now? And her powers have been misinterrupted into what we’ve seen in House of M. I’m hoping that one day some writer will retcon her back to the great character she once was.
If anyone wants to e-mail me reasons why you voted for these people, feel free to do so at bcronin@comicbookresources.com






15 Comments
km
October 4, 2007 at 7:23 pm
Interesting how most of the Marvel people everyone missed are all bunched together just below the line, isn’t it?
Except Ghost Rider. Dude’s gonna haunt my dreams, I just know it…
Ian
October 4, 2007 at 8:28 pm
Wow, if I put Moon Knight two spots higher he would have been in the top 50. By the way.. Angel? Even 51 seems like a high place for a character that has had no use aside from destruction over the past 10 years. But no, he beats out Professor X.
Chris Coke
October 4, 2007 at 8:33 pm
Green Goblin beating Venom has restored my lost faith in humanity.
All great characters here who should have made the list.
I’d have kicked off Winter Soldier, the two Ultimate characters and… not sure who else.
Probably there’s about 75 characters I claim “deserved” to be in the top 50.
Chris Coke
October 4, 2007 at 8:37 pm
And even though, he says no regular schedule, I’ll hit refresh every 5 minutes just in case.
KittyPryde
October 4, 2007 at 10:17 pm
Yay! I’ll feel a bit better knowing that Moon Knight came that close to cracking the top 50!
Richard
October 4, 2007 at 10:26 pm
That’s John Romita’s first issue and cover for Spider-Man. Romita is the greatest cover artist ever, in my opinion. Spider-Man became Marvel’s best seller after he came on, and I think those covers were a huge reason why.
Chris Coke
October 4, 2007 at 11:47 pm
That is among my favourite comic covers.
Spider-Man No More remains my favourite cover ever. So I’m inclined to agree about the strength of Romita covers
SanctumSanctorumComix
October 5, 2007 at 6:39 am
One thing that strikes me immediately about that Spider-Man cover is Peter Parker’s HANDS.
They are the only thing that DON’T look like they were drawn by Romita.
They look almost DITKO-like.
If he were trying to emulate Ditko, it would be more apparent in the rest of the cover.
But since he obviously wasn’t doing that it looks a little odd.
Weird.
~P~
P-TOR
Danar
October 5, 2007 at 7:06 am
wow. only 4 points seperate the 55th and 50th position.
hmmm. that’s odd. I looked at the top 50 list again so i could comment on something and noticed that at rank 31 we have a tie between colossus and galactus, but they don’t have the same points at all. Colossus clearly wins. wonder why i didn’t notice that before?
anyway, i was going to say, if you look at the top 55 places, there seems a clear division seems to be right around 31. people below that have fewer than 200 points and the pretty small (less than 3 points per position). the top 30 have much higher divisions between each position (though some like 9-10-11 are still close). It looks like the top spots garner a LOT of votes, but when you get down to the “second tier” characters, the love is pretty evenly distributed. scarlet witch lost out to Jessica Jones at #45 by a single first place vote.
and WHERE IS GHOST RIDER?
Thenodrin
October 5, 2007 at 8:07 am
I still can’t look at that cover without seeing the doctored up Christmas ad that Marvel did with it. Goblin wearing the Santa hat, and dragging Spider man with garland.
Theno
Brian Cronin
October 5, 2007 at 2:12 pm
Sorry about the Colossus typo!
Vincent Paul Bartilucci
October 6, 2007 at 6:33 am
Although he didn’t make my Marvel Top Ten, I’ve always kind of liked Angel. Granted, he works best in the original X-Men line-up since, in that company, he’s the only character who can fly. But I always dug the fact that he was out there fighting crime before Professor X came knocking on his door.
taylor
October 6, 2007 at 1:20 pm
So that’s where Green Goblin ended up…but where are the rest of the Spidey villains!?
Brent
October 8, 2007 at 10:09 pm
I voted for Angel and am glad to see others did too. I’ve always just found him very iconic as one of the original Marvel heroes, and a character whose only ability is flight. It didn’t take long before tons of characters could fly (many w/o even a reason *cough* DC comics *cough*)
Eric
October 19, 2007 at 9:51 am
Warren was my #9. He has always been my favorite X-Man.