web stats

CBR Live! Archive

Help a striking worker - buy The Middleman volume 3!

I'm not entirely sure if Javier Grillo-Marxuach is actually out on the picket line (probably not, because he's a producer as well as a writer), but he was nice enough to send me a .pdf file of the latest volume of his and Les McClaine's excellent comic, The Middleman, which is skipping the single issue format and going straight to the trade.  It hits stores tomorrow, and I encourage you all to get it.  Support the Commies who are going to force us all to watch reality shows for the next six months!

I have enjoyed the first two mini-series about the Middleman and his new recruit Wendy, and I've been looking forward to the third volume for a while.  The Middleman is a top-secret agent who takes care of problems that are too fantastic for the general public to handle, so no one knows he exists.  Kind of like the Men in Black, except the problems aren't extra-terrestrial in nature.  Wendy is trying to lead a normal life, but her duties as the Middleman's sidekick keeps getting in the way, and even though the comic is one of the more fun (and funny) books you're going to find in the last few years, there's a surprising amount of real emotion in it, too.  But what about the third volume?

Well, I'm not going to get into it too much, because those .pdf files are a bitch to read and I don't want to keep flipping back and forth.  I will say that the book is as funny as ever, and even though some people won't like the self-referential aspects of it (you know who you are!), it's not overwhelming to the point of annoyance, and let's face it - if we were in a position like Wendy's, we'd make references to various things in pop culture too.  You might argue that that doesn't make it right, but in small doses, it's very funny.

The book is called "The Third Volume Inescapability," and in the grand tradition of these comics, the Middleman is kind of an uptight square while Wendy, his partner-in-training, gets to comment on how silly some of the plot points are, like the name of the evil organization that is behind this volume's plot.  The actual plot is simple, and is there just to allow Grillo-Marxuach to play with the conventions of the spy genre and, to some extent, the superhero genre.  It features big alien robots fighting, for instance.  Now, that's not as funny or exciting as the first 20 times we've seen it recently, but the subtle digs at how ridiculous it really is makes it bearable.  Another nice thing Grillo-Marxuach does is have not only Wendy, but the Middleman himself aware of the conventions of the genre.  When they infiltrate their arch-nemesis's casino, it's an opportunity for a lot of spoofing of James Bond, but also allows the Middleman to remark about how things will play out, because he and his enemy have done it so many times before.  Yet, when they do work out as he expects (except for the elephant polo!), it's still exciting, plus it's humorous.

Wendy's "real" life, which was a crucial part of the first two volumes, is also a part of the third, but here the book lags a bit.  The situation is okay - Wendy wants to get her paintings into a gallery show, but she keeps getting called away to fight evil, so she enlists her roommate to pretend to be her and make her case - but Grillo-Marxuach doesn't do enough with it.  In the first two volumes, the humor in the real-life situations, plus the added bonus of it being about someone's actual life, helped ground the book a bit.  In this volume, the sitcom aspect of the book maintains the humor but doesn't give us enough insight into Wendy's life and relationship with her roommate.  It's still charming, but not as much.

The book isn't all goofiness, however, as the ending is unusually dark.  It fits in nicely with the self-referential tone of the book, though, and promises volumes to come.  We'll see if it happens, but it's interesting to read how the book changes over the course of the series.  Wendy has become more interesting, but the Middleman himself, who started out as a fairly stock straight-arrow kind of guy, has loosened up a bit.  I don't know how many volumes Grillo-Marxuach has planned, but it will be nice to see them when and if they show up.

McClaine's art has improved a lot, too, even though it was good to begin with.  His lines have become stronger and his inks a bit heavier, lending some heft to the drawings.  He cuts loose a bit more with the backgrounds, and the scenes in the casino are especially well done.  After working with these characters for a time, he has given them much more personality as well, even a robot like Ida, the nerve center of the operation.  But he still keeps everything light, so that the fun comes through, as when our hero and heroine fight ninjas early on (another instance when Grillo-Marxuach tips our expectations).  It would be nice to see more of his work get out to a wider audience.

I can't say this is the best volume of the three, but I will still say it's better than most of what's out there, especially in the humor-action-adventure genre.  The main characters are very well done and have a nice rapport, and it looks great.  Plus, it's only ten dollars for what is basically four issues, plus an "alternate" ending, plus a bunch of pin-ups, plus annotations!  I love annotations.  You know who doesn't love annotations?  Fascists.

If you're checking out the comics that come out tomorrow, look for it.  Support the working man!  Fight the power!

  • Posted on November 6, 2007 @ 09:16 PM

11 Comments

Not exactly ringing praise, but a very fair and balanced review. I really loved the first two miniseries (which I have in trades). You do have to be able to enjoy self-referential humor and a little breaking of the fourth wall (if I recall correctly) but its done really well. The art is also very strong (warning--it's black and white!). I applaud their decision to go straight to trade and I wonder how it will work out for them. Here's hoping for more trades to come (something I think you question a little to harshly in your review).

You can read the first chapters of volumes one and two here, by the way (it's how I got hooked): http://www.vipercomics.com/features/the_middleman.asp

KB - I did like the book, though, I just thought the first two volumes were better! And I don't think I question whether more volumes are coming too harshly, but I have seen plenty of creators in the past claim they will continue the story and then get sidetracked, often through no fault of their own. I don't know how the writers' strike is going to affect Grillo-Marxuach, and things always happen. The latest League of Extraordinary Gentlemen was supposed to be out a year ago, after all.

Greg--I hear you, and I guess I shouldn't be too critical of your review, which I thought was very good and very thorough. Yeah, Middle Man tends to come out late, but Grillo-Marxuach hasn't done anything (that I know of--I could be wrong!) to really merit questioning his statement that more books are on the way. (And I join you in really hoping that it's true!)

Love your writing and love the blog. Keep up the great work!

[...] comic Book Resources - USA Yet, when they do work out as he expects (except for the elephant polo!), it’s still exciting, plus it’s humorous. Wendy’s “real” life, which was a crucial … goodcomics.comicbookresources.com/2007/11/06/help-a-striking-worker-buy-the-middleman-volume-3/ See all stories on this topic: news.google.com/news?hl=en&ncl=http://goodcomics.comicbookresources.com/2007/11/06/help-a-striking-worker-buy-the-middleman-volume-3/ [...]

Greg, did you realize you're blurbed on the back cover? I thought that was pretty cool. I got a review copy and just finished reading it today; it's a really fun book, like the first two volumes.

Yeah, Matt, Grillo-Marxuach told me they were using one of my quotes when he sent me the file a while back. I didn't want to mention it because it's a bit, you know, snotty.

I've been looking forward to this one ever since Greg reccomended the first two some time back. A really fun series.

I spent far too much time reading the names of all the Mexican wrestlers and trying to pick them out of the different scenes in book 2. That and the back up alternate Middleman stories were a blast!

I stubmbled upon the Middleman web site at themiddleman.tv when I was looking for the release date of this book not long ago. There are previews of all three volumes among other things. Apparently there is a television project in the works.

Support the Commies who are going to force us all to watch reality shows for the next six months!

Like those aren't scripted.

Snotty? You mean like when you pointed out your blurb on Godland? ;-) Hell, if I ever get my name on a book, I'll be sure to point it out on MY blog!

Yes, but now it's old hat! :) Actually, I pointed the Godland quote out because it shocked the hell out of me. Since I knew about this beforehand, I figured pretending I was stunned probably wasn't the way to go. I do like the quote, though. I imagine it might repel some readers, however, because if I like it, it must suck!

Leave a Comment

 

Subscribe to CSBG

Categories

Review Copies

Comics Should Be Good accepts review copies. Anything sent to us will (for better or for worse) end up reviewed on the blog. See where to send the review copies.

Browse the Archives