free hit counter

javascript

CBI Archive

Reviews of Hitmen, Iron Fists, and the Superheroes they hangout with

Tuesday, November 6th, 2007 at 10:02 PM EST

Updated: Tuesday, November 6th, 2007 at 10:02 PM EST

Eschewing parody for the time being, how about some reviews instead?JLA/Hitman #2- I have the first issue of this coming via reorder, which kind of makes me feel dumb for reading the second one already (the only issue my shop had), but I couldn’t stop myself after I got going. I’m sure it will read better as a whole, even though it worked perfectly well if you just looked at it as in media res storytelling, which I dig in my superhero books anyway.

Other than the fact that it was a damn good comic, which really should go without saying when it comes to Ennis and Hitman, I was interested in a couple of things in Ennis’s script. But first, I’ll quickly skim through the art.

McCrea, as always, is Ennis’s best collaborator who doesn’t have the words “Steve” and “Dillon” in his name. I was especially taken with his version of Wonder Woman; you wouldn’t think she’d fit his style, but I thought he did a good job with her. Beyond gawking at his version of Diana, I’ve always thought he was a better than average cartoonist, and he lived up to that here, balancing the disparate elements of the story (It’s a Hitman story! And a Justice League story! And a sci-fi horror story! ) and doing a good job of using the larger page count to provide some splashy visuals without going overboard; you aren’t going to see multipage establishing shots here. David Baron’s colors also help strike the balance between the different story elements as well as the characters, balancing the gritty Tommy Monaghan and the primary color JLA.

Okay, token concessions to the visuals in the visual medium aside, I can get to the part I’m no more qualified to talk about, but still want to talk about anyway; the writing. There were two things that stood out to me about this issue.

The first is how Ennis writes everyone in character. Not that he hasn’t, generally; even when he’s parodying the hell out of them, he gets these characters’ personalities down, whether it’s Spider-Man, Daredevil, or Wolverine getting the tar beaten out of them when they wandered in to an issue of his Punisher run, or Kyle Rayner showing up in the original run of Hitman; he may be making fun of them, but he’s only exaggerating their personalities. I mean, his Batman may come off as a one note dick here, but that’s not much different from how he’s usually been portrayed for years, and has only recently been consciously moved away from. Wonder Woman’s self righteousness more or less works for me, as does Superman’s conflicting emotions. I was also really struck by how much his Flash and Green Lantern were written exactly like they were in Grant Morrison’s JLA.

Which leads to the other interesting point I took from the story. Specifically, how Ennis worked in a commentary on torture in to the story. It wasn’t all that obtrusive, and he didn’t get on his soap box; it sounded like the kind of thing Wally and Kyle would talk about in Morrison’s JLA, if they ever got a chance in between all the angel wrestling and dimension hopping that went on there.

As much as I enjoy his “piss takes” on the superhero genre (although I have yet to read the Pro), it was interesting to see him play it more or less straight with some of the biggest icons in the genre. It was all of the little touches, from Tommy’s Superman fanboy love of Superman to Superman’s memorial on the moon to him, that really made this story sing. Now, hopefully, they’ll finally get around to putting the rest of the original Hitman series in trade, so those of us who are late to the party can read the Superman issue that this story references, and that Dave Campbell, among others, will tell you all about. But it would still be nice to, you know, be able to own a permanent copy of it. It won an Eisner, for god’s sake!

Immortal Iron Fist: The Last Iron First Story- Despite being a big fan of Ed Brubaker and Matt Fraction (other than that bald Scottish dude, they’re my favorite writers working in comics) I was a late adopter of this series. After all the good word of mouth it’s received (well, pretty much just because Chris Sims, Ambassador of Kicks to the Face, was so enthusiastic about it), I finally decided to jump on at the start of the most recent story arc, and it’s delivered. Wanting to get the whole story so far, I decided to pick up the trade of the first arc.

It’s good comics, like I expected from a Frubaker joint. Not quite as fun as the new arc (mostly because it lacks characters named Fat Cobra), but it’s not without its face kicking charms. The idea of the Iron Fist being a legacy hero is done very well here, giving us short glimpses of other past heroes who carried the mantle in the past. Frubaker balance a lot of story elements here and set up some interesting plot threads in the process. Not all of them are paid off in this arc, but even if I wasn’t reading the current arc, I’d be interested in seeing where they were going. Which is high praise, considering I used to think of Iron Fist as that dork with a high collar and slippers who hung out with Luke Cage.

Of course, artist David Aja ditches the old costume as quickly as possible. What he comes up with is sleeker and more stylish, befitting the agile warrior that Iron Fist is. What impresses me most is how Aja’s style has the same striking qualities of a Michael Lark or Alex Maleev (colorist supreme Matt Hollingsworth’s work plays a big part in that, given the work he did with the latter artist on Daredevil) while still doing a good job with the kinetic action and everything else Frubaker throws at him in their script. I was especially taken with how well he did the facial expressions; it really helped add to Danny Rand’s personality, which is crucial in establishing him as a character worth caring about in his own right, instead of just Luke Cage’s kung-fu fighting sidekick.

Frubaker also deserve credit for– aw hell, I just wanted to say Frubraker again. This is a fun comic, worth checking out whether you’re a die hard fan of the old Deadly Hands of Kung Fu magazines or just want a good superhero comic with some martial arts flavor. Also, you really should support Frubraker; besides being fun to type, they’re probably the best collective entity in comics. If for no other reason than that Quierrson is less fun to type.

19 Comments

JLA/Hitman was indeed very good, and I really want to get the rest of the Hitman series in tpb.

Show us some covers!

Show us some covers!

It’s like we’re in the nerdiest strip club imaginable. :)

Sweet Mother of God, I love Hitman. And JLA/Hitman was so good. Let us give you money for trades, DC!

Will

There was just that one comic that wasn’t like the others. That had ridiculous ammounts of violence, but with meaning at the same time. Even when it was done on comedy it all built up to the character. “It’s a job”.

And so I did have fun with it. And I also felt for him, like Tiegel couldn’t understand how she could love a murderer like him. But she loved him, and I also cared about him. Through his own variety of “Constantine Hell”. Everybody around him died. With the big difference that it wasn’t because of him (most of the time anyway), yet he still felt responsible.

This was a hitman with a silly little moral code that he didn’t really believe he followed to the letter. He tried not to kill good guys, but heck, he is living proof of how someone can be just that complex. A “bad guy” who did the right thing every once in a while, and Kant would agree that made his actions more significant than Superman’s third save from the day. He had no reason to help anyone and yet… Look at how he ended.

I still re read the entire Hitman (minus the Demon issues that I haven’t bothered to collect… I mean, seriously, what was up with that scarf?) every year or so. And I still tear up at the end, when I realize he’s not coming back.

So JLA/Hitman made me really warm inside. I hope that isn’t a bullet in my guts, though.

Stephane Savoie

November 7, 2007 at 8:39 am

Hitman is the best thing Ennis has or will every do. Unlike other Ennis works, it has heart.
Where are the trades?!

Keimako - the second bunch of Demon stories (51-54, though he’s not in 51) is important with regard to Tommy’s relationship with Etrigan as it plays out in “Ace of Killers”.

but, as much as I love Tommy, the ‘Hitman’ issues of ‘The Demon’ tend to be among the worst of the run. I’d say that the Haunted Tank stuff is worth reading, and the last story, about a war in Hell, is great and has a lot of stuff which comes back in ‘Hitman’ … especially Baytor.

Loves me some new IRON FIST as well, and well coined on ‘Frubaker.’ The one complaint I have about the series is Aja’s consistently ridiculous torsos on the covers. What, does he get paid by the millimetre or something?

“Hitman is the best thing Ennis has or will every do. Unlike other Ennis works, it has heart.”

I have to strongly disagree with this. What other Ennis have you been reading? Almost ALL his stuff has heart. Preacher, to name but one. There’s also Hellblazer, Unknown Soldier, a lot of his Punisher work (most notably “The Tyger” special), Battler Britton, Enemy Ace, the War Stories…I’m sure there are many more.

Even the goofier stuff Ennis does like The Pro, Rifle Brigade, and Fury ALL have vestiges of “heart.” It makes me think you haven’t been reading. Or just superficially.

One of things I find curious about the new Iron Fist book is how Brubaker (seems to) steal so nakedly from the Buffy the Vampire Slayer TV series, yet how well he makes it work for IF.

(If the heritage of the Slayer is stolen from a root source, from which Brubaker is also pilfering, please let me know. I can’t think of one off hand.)

Yeah, I’m going to have to go with Paul - actually, I’ll go further and say that Hitman’s popularity completely mystifies me. With the exception of Who Dares, Wins (And JLA/Hitman, if only for Ennis’ brilliantly characterized Superman & Wonder Woman), I found the series facile and shallow. Mawkish and forcedly sentimental compared to Hellblazer/Preacher’s depth and heart, and toothless and bowdlerized compared with Dicks’ fearless depravity, it just failed to grab me on either level.

The concept of a champion whose identity is passed down from generation to generation goes at least as far back as the Phantom, although since the identity is passed down within a family and doesn’t convey any powers it’s not strictly comparable to the Slayer concept.

Beyond the concept, I found the deployment in Iron Fist to carry some (maybe superficial, or maybe unavoidable) similarities to some episodes of Buffy, and to the Tales of the Slayers TPB I just read–or maybe I’m just hung up on the Boxer Rebellion era Chinese Slayer and the Chinese pirate queen IF, plus the two-champions team-up/old champion passing new knowledge to current champion elements.

Regardless, I’m not complaining, and I’m a little intrigued to see a story concept that could have been pitched as “Just like Well-Known Female character, except it’s a dude!”

“Quierrison” made me laugh very loudly.

Although I’ve never heard him acknowledge the fact, the idea of a hero chosen each generation to combat evil goes back at least as far as Lee Falk’s The Phantom, which started back in 1936.

Oops … by “him” I meant Joss Whedon.

Sorry!

Sean-

That’s interesting to know about Ennis’ Demon being relevant to Hitman.

I grew up reading 2000AD, and so was a huge fan of Alan Grant’s Demon, and was also really excited when I found out Ennis was going to be taking over from him. Then, when it happened, I couldn’t drop the book fast enough. I really didn’t like Ennis’ version at all. So while I dimly recall that Tommy’s first appearance was in a Demon annual, I had no idea he’d appeared in the regular title.

I haven’t gone back issue hunting in years. I think it might be about time.

[…] I can’t blame you for waiting for the trade on this book, because Brubaker and Fraction (or, you know, Frubaker) are building nice subplots that continue on from the first trade while still telling a good story on top of that, and having read the first trade, I know these read well in that format.  But then you miss out on the Bride on Nine Spiders for another 6-8 months, and I don’t know if you can afford to wait!  That’s how cool she is. […]

Leave a Comment

 

Subscribe to CSBG

Categories

Review Copies

Comics Should Be Good accepts review copies. Anything sent to us will (for better or for worse) end up reviewed on the blog. See where to send the review copies.

Browse the Archives