CBR Live! Archive
The Punisher #54 Review
- by Brian Cronin
- in Comic Reviews
The penultimate storyline in Garth Ennis' classic run on Punisher ended today, and it was good.

This issue marks the return of the popular Barracuda character, who has determined he will gain revenge against the Punisher, and he decided to do so by kidnapping the Punisher's infant child (who the Punisher did not know he had until now). At the end of the last issue, Punisher thought he had defeated Barracuda, but something snapped in Barracuda, and the crazed 'Cuda attacked Punisher at the end of the issue, leading to this issue.
Well, right off the bat, this was one extremely violent comic book. It definitely earned that "Explicit Content" warning on the cover.
The Punisher and Barracuda brutalize each other, and in these scenes, we are probably lucky that artist Goran Parlov seems to have rushed the early parts of the book a bit, as done in a clearer style, it would probably be a lot grosser - like when Punisher uses a pliers to rip Barracuda's nose off his face.
Here, while Barracuda chases down the Punisher, we get flashbacks interspersed telling the whole story of Barracuda's ugly, violent life. It is brutal, but explains Barracuda so well - until he meets one of the most violent ends you'll see in a comic (matched with a flashback that describes the Punisher about as well as you can get, as we flash back to Punisher's friend, Yorkie, which is where Barracuda learned of Punisher's child - "He's going to kill you. Not over me. You're going up against him, so he'll kill you. Because you're a joke, in spite of it all. And he's the most dangerous man who ever walked this Earth."
That certainly does describe him well, no?
The book ends with a nice exchange between the Punisher and the sister of the baby's mother, and here, Parlov does a really nice job with the artwork, particularly the facial features (especially a flashback to the baby's mother - SUCH a nice, subtle job).
Here, Ennis has the Punisher basically cop to his one-note nature of the Punisher, as he himself admits that he is barely a human being anymore - and that he could not raise the child, even if he tried, because he WOULD see something in the papers, and he WOULD be forced to do something about it - because that's who he is.
He is stuck in "the long, cold, dark night that I've made of my life."
It's certainly be sad to see Ennis leave this title.
Recommended.
- Posted on January 23, 2008 @ 08:11 PM






8 Comments
Krod
January 23, 2008 at 9:07 pm
Penultimate? I heard this was the end.
Jake
January 23, 2008 at 9:12 pm
There's one more story arc after this one. It'll be Ennis' last.
the poser
January 23, 2008 at 10:43 pm
This issue was so awesome I almost craped myself,,, almost.
David M
January 24, 2008 at 7:22 am
A fantastic issue and an all-around fantastic arc. Each time I go into my LCS to pick up my copy of Punisher MAX, I get sadder and sadder that Ennis's run is coming to an end. I hope that whomever comes next on the book -- I am told that the title *will* continue -- will respect everything that Ennis has done/accomplished with it. If, for example, the next writer attempts some sci-fi resurrection of Barracuda, I will drop the book faster than a hot potato.
BDaly
January 24, 2008 at 11:29 am
I'm dropping the book once Ennis leaves. The new guy may be good, but Ennis fucking owns The Punisher.
It's the same reason I haven't been reading Fraction PWJ, though I read issue four and loved it. Even Ennis' earlier Marvel Knights Punisher stuff, while lots of fun, doesn't touch his Max stuff. I picked up the first issue of the Kitchen Irish arc while on random visit to the comic shop and it brought me back to the hobby after a long hiatus.
sgt pepper
January 25, 2008 at 4:43 pm
Jaysis, just read this incedible issue. To the naysayers, I say if this is one note comics, it's the only note I ever need to hear.
chris
January 26, 2008 at 12:24 am
I will weep sad, sad tears when the last issue of Ennis' Punisher hits the stands. I was never a huge fan of his Knights run, but the MAX series - jaysis, the *first arc*, "In the Beginning", with Microchip. Just absolutely phenomenal.
dave
April 7, 2008 at 1:24 am
I've been reading Garth Ennis's work since his Hellblazer days. I thought he peaked at Vertigo's PREACHER. his Marvel Knights run, and Hitman series were just fun to read. This was until he started writing PUNISHER MAX. He digs deeper into Frank Castle's psyche, and does in-depth research about everything crime related. SLAVERS was the saddest series I've read. Here he deals with an issue he can never solve and can't stop. It couldn't get any truer than this. It's an eye-opener for those who only read Punisher for the fun of it.
Every story arc is so detailed and well-researched, he can make the readers believe that the Punisher could exist... well, maybe not all story arcs (like mother russia and barracuda). I won't be reading PUNISHER when Ennis leaves. His is the definitive Punisher.