CBR Live! Archive
Captain America #34 Review
- by Brian Cronin
- in Comic Reviews
What gets lost sometimes in the media hype of the death of Captain America in #25 is that the story was part ONE of a long storyline and that it was all tied into a over-arching story that Ed Brubaker had been doing since the FIRST ISSUE of his Captain America run, so now, 34 issues in, when Brubaker introduces the new Captain America (and here is the New York Daily News on THIS story, as well), the story is a lot deeper than a standard "Hero X is replaced by Hero Y" story (as opposed to Eric Masterson replacing Thor, John Walker replacing Captain America and James Rhodes replacing Iron Man, which were all done on pretty short notice), and the result is a good issue (although I wonder how many people buying the comic will actually read it to find out).

The work that writer Ed Brubaker has done with the character of James Barnes has been nothing short of exemplary, as he has not rushed anything with his character development. There are no sudden revelations for Barnes on his journey from becoming a hardcore assassin to becoming the replacement for Steve Rogers as Captain America.
The plot in the issue details the Red Skull's current plans to destroy America, and it's eerily feasible to see how the Skull has been able to destabilize the country, causing this to be a much larger villainous plot for Captain America to stop than is normal.
Another impressive thing with Barnes is how well Brubaker (and Daniel Way, as well) have integrated him into the lives of established characters such as Wolverine and Black Widow, and one of those characters, Black Widow, guest-stars in this issue, and she is used quite well (I especially loved the way that she tries to pull back to let the new Captain America have his moment in the spotlight).
There is a decent amount of this issue that is a little on the over-exposition-y side, and the scene where he shoots the bad guys in their kneecaps struck me as a bit perfunctory (I know we had to see him shoot someone EVENTUALLY to justify the fact that he is carrying a gun, but it seemed a bit too soon).
Otherwise, it was a strong issue, with very nice artwork by Steve Epting, with inks by Butch Guice, who it seems we have to partially thank for the renaissance in Epting's artwork since Epting went to CrossGen years ago where Guice was working there, so it was nice to see Guice working directly with Epting. The art looked very nice (and they even took an interesting approach to the first scene where we see Captain America in full costume - it was an odd angle, which I appreciated - they didn't go for the obvious shot).
The ending of the comic, in particular, was brilliant - as it was just the type of ending you'd hope for to hopefully bring in those new readers who are just sampling this issue because of the media attention.
Recommended.
- Posted on January 30, 2008 @ 01:31 PM






20 Comments
Dan (other Dan)
January 30, 2008 at 1:44 pm
I feel like I'm avoiding Captain America to keep from being trendy, but that really does a disservice to my enjoyment of comics. I need to stop it. Good review.
Joe
January 30, 2008 at 2:35 pm
Great issue. I've been aboard since issue #1 even though I wasn't a Cap fan (I was just looking to kill some time) and have found myself looking forward to this book more than most others I read. Winter Solider has become a favorite of mine so I hope he has a long run as Cap. Congrats to Brubaker for turning a character a newbie to comics like me thought was goofy since I, admittedly, didn't know much about him and making it a must read.
Also, anyone notice the Lost references popping up all over this week? This issue has one as does the New Avengers annual.
joshschr
January 30, 2008 at 2:39 pm
I should have grabbed it. Cap got sacrificed when reality started catching up with my budget, but I've really missed it.
The lost thing is supposed to be a big cross promotion for the 8-episode season starting tomorrow. Can't wait to see what's in the NA Annual.
SonTenks
January 30, 2008 at 2:41 pm
I just bought the Captain America Omnibus - the first 25 issues of Brubaker's run, and I have to say, I'm shocked there are people who still AREN'T reading this.
Matt D
January 30, 2008 at 3:13 pm
Nitpickery!
Eric replacing Don Blake was done on short notice.
Eric replacing Thor seemed to be building ever since he became bound to him.
Eric TF Bat
January 30, 2008 at 4:52 pm
So is there an explanation for why he's wearing the Puerto Rican flag now? Is he campaigning for statehood? Seems a bit radical for a guy who was born before Alaska and Hawaii were even brought into the union!
Bill
January 30, 2008 at 4:55 pm
"Also, anyone notice the Lost references popping up all over this week? This issue has one as does the New Avengers annual."
ABC has a deal with Marvel to put those references into issues. Amazing Spider-Man also has them, among others.
Tom Fitzpatrick
January 30, 2008 at 9:19 pm
I haven't read C.A. for some years, but, correct me if I'm wrong -- isn't Bucky Barnes supposed to be dead?
Or is this his grand-son (or great-grand-son)?
Veidt
January 30, 2008 at 9:37 pm
While a great comic, and great story, to pick upon other stories that have characters replacing other characters in their well established identies feels cheap. Eric Masterson becoming Thor, and John Walker becoming Captain America were not rushed plots. Indeed both characters were introduced quite a long time before those eventual switches, in Masterson's case several years before, so the idea of Bucky becoming Cap is more fitting in those traditions. (Although we all knew that Eric would stop being Thor and that Walker couldn't stay as Cap, in fact that was part of Walker's character arc.)
Veidt
Brian Cronin
January 30, 2008 at 11:38 pm
Masterson had been around for awhile, and John Walker had been around for a decent amount of time, but the actual REPLACEMENT in each case (which is what I'm talking about here) was extremely abrupt in the former's case (happened the same issue Thor disappears) and pretty abrupt in the latter's case (happened in one or two issues).
So, no, this was significantly different, as it took eight issues from Captain America's death before the new Cap was named.
By the by, Rhodey was around the LONGEST of those characters before he was (also abruptly) named Iron Man - why didn't you argue him, too? That was odd.
Brian Cronin
January 30, 2008 at 11:39 pm
See the above reply.
While DeFalco and Gruenwald were certainly laying the groundwork (especially DeFalco), the actual replacement was abrupt in both instances.
Brian Cronin
January 31, 2008 at 4:05 am
Tom, Bucky barely survived the blast, and his almost lifeless body was fished out of the water by the Russians, who then fixed him with cybernetic parts and brainwashed him into becoming an assassin for them.
His gimmick was that they would keep in cyrogenics between missions, so it would sometimes be years between missions for him, with very little aging happening in between - that way, no one could identify him, as they wouldn't be looking for a 20 year old man six years later.
That's how he got the nickname "The Winter Soldier."
Cap helped him break free of his programming, and he's been slowly working his way to the good guys since.
ks
January 31, 2008 at 5:25 am
I haven't got the issue yet, but it is on hold at the comic store and I am looking forward to it. I have always loved Cap's character,and I admit I was pissed when he was killed. It seemed like he finally got a good creative team and then Steve was gone. I know that it is not forever, but still. That being said, I do like Bucky's gradual replacement of Cap. Brubaker has done an outstanding job of it. I wish more people bought this comic (and Iron Fist) as it is some of the better comics involving superheroes. I just wonder how long it will take before I start thinking of Bucky as "Cap" and not "Bucky", like I came to think of Wally as Flash and not Kid Flash.
Wayne
January 31, 2008 at 9:04 am
Love the story and character development in this book, which might be the best thing coming out of Marvel right now.
That said, the new uniform is shite.
Brian Cronin
January 31, 2008 at 2:01 pm
Agreed.
Rich
January 31, 2008 at 8:30 pm
I was down on the uniform when the initial images came out, but liked it in the book. Hoped that would be the case given my faith in Epting.
Grant
February 2, 2008 at 8:03 am
I got addicted to Brubakers run through the Marvel digital comics site and bought the Omnibus as soon as I found it for a reasonable price. I bought this issue because I didn't want to wait another year or so for the next Omnibus (which is the perfect format for this book).
Lothor
February 2, 2008 at 10:07 pm
BREAKING NEWS! Steve Rogers is alive! And trolling for underage broads on craigslist!
http://abclocal.go.com/wls/story?section=news/local&id=5929823
wwk5d
April 13, 2008 at 5:02 am
I like some of Brubaker's stuff, but this just makes me go......eh. Maybe I could never get over the idea of Bucky being brought back, but Brubaker's work on CA has left me underwhelmed overall.
And yeah, this is a really bad costume.
Hundie Jo [dot] Com » Blog Archive » Blog of the Day: Comics Should be Good!
April 18, 2008 at 7:52 am
[...] Captain America #34 Review [...]