CBI Archive
Echo #1 Review
- by Brian Cronin
- in Comic Reviews
Thursday, March 6th, 2008 at 4:12 AM EST
Updated: Thursday, March 6th, 2008 at 4:12 AM EST
It’s been awhile since Terry Moore launched a new creator-owned title, so I guess that explains why the first issue of Echo has a special foil cover! Seriously, though, the foil cover is a nice touch, as the end result is a very attractive cover that stands out from the pack (which, I suppose, was the intent of foil covers in the first place), which is nice, as this appears to be an interesting new title by Moore, as Moore tries out fantasy a bit (albeit still intermixed with realism).
The book is about a woman who is testing out this new super suit for the government, which is powered basically by nuclear power - she’s essentially wearing a nuclear bomb. The head bad guy, in a nicely done piece of characterization by Moore, is one of of those guys who probably honestly do not think of themselves as evil - he thinks of himself strictly as a scientist, and if he has to kill some innocent people to test his ideas out? So be it.
One of those innocent people who perish is the lady in the super suit, but when her suit explodes, parts of it rain down on an unsuspecting female photographer in the desert.
Here is that scene, which is where Moore gets the cover idea from - and boy, does he do a nice job depicting the showering of the pieces of the suit…




Check out that sweet linework by Moore. He’s always been an impressive line artist on Strangers in Paradise, and he brings that skill to Echo, as well. It’s a style you don’t see too often (mostly because it only really exists in black and white comics, as in color, it bleeds a bit).
The concept of the comic is that a piece of the super suit is going to bond to the photographer (Julie), so she’ll find herself running afoul of the government and the evil scientist. The “echo” is probably going to be that the woman who died wearing the suit is somehow bonded with the suit, so that an “echo” of her still exists in the suit, and she’ll probably help Julie out. That’s strictly me guessing, though, which is a bit annoying, as you’d like for a new book to at least explain the gimmick of the book within the first issue (or at the very least, the TITLE of the book).
Moore does a fine job, through his story and his art, of introducing us to Julie’s personality, and there is a park ranger we meet in the comic who gets a similarly nice intro. I bet he’ll have some connection with Julie before this is done (sorta like that movie, Broken Arrow, only with the genders reversed!).
As I mentioned before, I would have liked the plot to be advanced a bit more than what we already have, and the sheer amount of set-up (there is a page of exposition where Moore uses what seems to be almost a parody of exposition scenes, as it is an info dump re: Julie’s answering machine - one message explains that she is broke and the other one explains that she is getting a divorce) drags on the quality of the first issue, but the good part about that is that it means the odds are great that later issues will even be better than this one.
That said, there is enough of a plot that, when combined with the nice introductory characterization and the great artwork, I can still feel safe recommending this one.
Recommended.







7 Comments
Tom Fitzpatrick
March 6, 2008 at 4:29 am
You FEEL safe?!?
Patrick
March 6, 2008 at 6:39 am
I thought it was a good book too, but there wasn’t much story too it. As an example, using what was posted, that’s 4 pages with a total of 5 words on them. With the amount of time it took to get this out I hoped it would take me more than a commercial break to read the entire thing.
Dan Bailey
March 6, 2008 at 6:59 am
What Patrick said. I glanced through an issue yesterday at my LCS, & by GOD did it seem flimsy for the price … so much so that I even counted the pages (something I’m pretty sure I never do) just to make sure the count wasn’t in the mid-teens, or something. I guess it was the fact that the pages weren’t printed on the usual fancy-ass stock. I mean, I got the impression that I’d read the entire story in the few seconds it took me to flip through the book.
Didn’t pick it up, though thanks to the review above I do believe I’ll email the store’s owner in a minute or so to have him stick one back for me anyway.
Andrew Collins
March 6, 2008 at 10:45 am
I compared reading the first issue of ECHO a lot to my experience of reading the first issue of Jeff Smith’s RASL last week. I was immensely disappointed in RASL. With ECHO, I enjoyed it a lot more but was still a little underwhelmed. The story felt a little too decompressed, especially when you compare to how much we got in the first issue of SIP.
I will probably not keep up with RASL, but with ECHO I plan on at least buying it in trade paperback format, as that seems to be the format it will read best in anyway.
Brian Cronin
March 6, 2008 at 10:52 am
Ha! I suppose you could put “I feel comfortable” there or “I feel secure.” They all basically mean the same thing, right? But if you like them better than “I feel safe,” feel free!
Tom Fitzpatrick
March 6, 2008 at 6:42 pm
Well, it’s a free (north-american) country, isn’t it?
We should be able to say whatever we think without having to worry about walking on eggshells.
Without being reprimanding for being politically incorrect.
sigh. We can dream.
Can we?
Journalista - the news weblog of The Comics Journal » Blog Archive » Mar. 7, 2008: Gone all porno
March 7, 2008 at 3:04 am
[…] [Review] Brian Cronin on the first issue of Terry Moore’s new series, Echo. […]