CSBG Archive
John Seavey’s Storytelling Engines: Booster Gold
Here’s the latest Storytelling Engine from John Seavey. Click here to read John’s description of what a Storytelling Engine IS, anyways. Check out more of them at his blog, Fraggmented.
Storytelling Engines: Booster Gold
(or “The ‘Hero’s Journey’ Just Led Down A Mineshaft”)
Booster Gold is a relative rarity in the universe of storytelling engines we’ve looked at so far, in that he’s a hero created after the 1960s. Most of the series reprinted in the ‘Essential’ and ‘Showcase Presents’ series to date have been creations of the Silver Age, that period of intense creative fertility at both Marvel and DC that sprung forth in the early 1960s, and which both companies have been very happy to harvest ever since. A few of the series we’ve looked at have come from the so-called “Bronze Age”, in the 1970s, but by the time Booster Gold came onto the scene, brand-new heroes were few and far between in the sea of reboots and recreations.
And Booster’s got a good storytelling engine. Heck, it’s a great one; it’s inventive, clever, entertaining, and very much in keeping with the spirit of the 1980s. Booster, you see, is a hero who wants to be rich. He’s altruistic, yes, but he makes his living as a super-hero, not as a mild-mannered reporter or millionaire playboy. He came from the mean streets of Gotham (in the 25th century, if you don’t mind a few spoilers), and growing up poor left him with a strong desire to make it big. So strong, in fact, that he was willing to shave points on college football…and when that blew up in his face, he decided to steal a time machine, pop back to the 20th century with a few high-tech gadgets, and try to strike it rich as a champion of justice.
This opens up whole new, untapped vistas for a storytelling engine. Booster Gold is faced with problems no other super-hero has. He’s got to worry about his public image; is losing a fight going to lose him endorsements? He’s got to worry about being a public figure in general; when Shockwave breaks out of prison and decides to go after a super-hero, Booster Gold is the only one in the phone book. He’s got moral dilemmas; what happens when the company that makes his Boostermobile decides to market it to the general public? In short, he’s got all sorts of interesting complications to his life that a guy like Superman just doesn’t have, and they’re all ones a writer can sink his or her teeth into.
Plus, the series has a great supporting cast. You’ve got the charmingly sleazy agent, the hotshot scientist, the mousy-but-kind secretary, and Skeets, who combines all the best features of Jeeves and C-3P0 to become Booster’s coach, mentor, sidekick, and aide-de-camp all rolled into one. You’ve even got brand-new villains, something that’s almost as rare by the mid-80s as brand-new heroes. Really, this is a series that has a lot going for it from a writer’s point of view.
So what went wrong? Why did ‘Booster Gold’ only last twenty-five issues before the character was rolled off into being a C-list Justice Leaguer, then fading into oblivion for about a decade?
The big problem with ‘Booster Gold’, actually, was Booster Gold. Because despite the interesting premise, it is kind of hard to like Booster himself. He’s greedy, arrogant, self-absorbed, egotistical, and kind of obnoxious. These are not good traits for your main character. (Especially the “egotistical” part. Audiences root for insecure characters, because we can see that the person is better than they think they are. We root against egotistical characters, because we can see that the person is worse than they think they are.)
Of course, Dan Jurgens tried to present these traits as part of a balanced picture of Booster, showing that he’s also genuinely altruistic, that he really cares about crime-fighting as a means of helping people, not just improving his Q-rating, and that deep down, even after he’s made a ton of dough, he keeps putting on the costume and jumping into battle because he’s a nice guy. He even begins to mellow out the ego a tiny bit as the series moves on. But he never gets time to develop Booster into a well-rounded hero, because the audience just wasn’t willing to wait.
This is the important lesson for storytelling engine design today. In a finite story, you can afford to take an initially unlikeable protagonist and show his or her journey to becoming a better person. But an open-ended series asks for an open-ended commitment on the part of its audience, and that audience isn’t necessarily going to follow you if the lead character isn’t sympathetic. Note that sympathetic here doesn’t necessarily mean “sweet and nice and good”; Tommy Monaghan shot people in the face for a living, but he was a very likeable character. It’s all about charisma and likeability; the Sixth Doctor, on ‘Doctor Who’, was supposed to start out being deliberately unlikeable and then mellow as the series progressed, but instead they fired the actor. You have to win over your audience in a hurry in an open-ended series.
Eventually, of course, after said decade of oblivion, Booster Gold was resurrected in the pages of ’52′. Freed from the burden of having to carry a series, Booster was able to go through his journey of self-improvement, and the new series features a more likeable, more sympathetic, more charismatic Booster Gold. It’s a very different storytelling engine, though, and despite its also being a good engine, one can’t help but wish that the old series had the new Booster. Because it really is a concept that deserves another chance.






11 Comments
Anthony Strand
April 1, 2008 at 7:37 am
And, of course, with that new charisma, he was given a new series.
I haven’t read the old Booster series, although I’m a big fan from the JLI days. How much effect do you think that series had on his becoming likable?
John Seavey
April 1, 2008 at 8:18 am
To be honest, I think it hurt a lot. Giffen and DeMatteis played up the “greedy” aspects of the character and played down the “altruistic” end, so that once his own book was canceled and they were the only people writing the character, audiences pretty much remembered Booster Gold as the super-hero equivalent of a used car salesman. Trying to take the character seriously afterwards was kind of a lost cause for quite a while.
(And I say this, by the way, as someone who liked the Giffen/DeMatteis JLI run. My feelings about whether a particular creator’s run on a series was entertaining are very different from my feelings about how it affected the storytelling engine of that series.)
comixkid2099
April 1, 2008 at 9:54 am
so booster gold has a showcase? i did not know that. something else i am putting on my buy list.
red-Ricky
April 1, 2008 at 11:13 am
I’ll be honest, at the begining, I didn’t like Booster too much. I was young and I felt that Superheroes should be heroes… for free. And even though I was still a kid, I could see through the 80′s embodyment or cliché that he was. You know, that whole “Money-money-money” and “Greed is good” mentality that we all know and love.
It wasn’t until he lost all his money and had to start trying to get rich again, that I really started liking the guy. I mean, “the get rich quick schemes” of the early 90′s… now, those are classics!
Nowadays, I think he is awesome. Just not as awesome as Awesome X!!!
KA-POW!!!
Kirk Boxleitner, a.k.a. K-Box
April 1, 2008 at 11:24 am
It’s weird to think of a character like “Booster Gold” being ahead of his time (I’d honestly never even considered it before now), but in all the ways you say, he really was. Moreover, unlike Rob Liefeld’s supposed take on “superheroes as celebrities” in Youngblood, which wound up being an advertising blurb that was never reflected in the stories, Booster Gold actually did address this head on.
Even now, as much as different creators and companies talk about “superheroes as celebrities,” and as many series as start out with that concept supposedly front and center, it’s interesting how rarely, and how poorly, it’s addressed – Kurt Busiek’s Superstar came the closest of any comic I’ve seen to doing it really well, since its protagonist literally became more physically powerful the more popular he was in the media, but that was apparently only one issue.
Thok
April 2, 2008 at 7:50 am
One other issue with early Booster is that a lot of his story is very reminiscent of Superman, and that comparison doesn’t flatter Booster at all (the proper term is that Booster is a Superman ectype).
Both are essentially the sole immigrants from a place they can’t return to (Krypton/25th century).
Both have similar power sets (flying/invulnerability/power beams: obviously Superman is better at all of these then Booster and has additional powers).
Both had a home base in Metropolis which only reinforced this connection.
Both have connections to the Legion.
Stephen
April 2, 2008 at 2:28 pm
On the other hand, I really liked the idea that there was another high-profile hero based in Metropolis; aside from Booster, the pickings have always been somewhat thin (Thorn, Guardian, Gangbuster, etc.).
Although I guess Birds of Prey is theoretically based there now, although the soul of that book is pretty clearly tied to Gotham.
Vincent Paul Bartilucci
April 2, 2008 at 4:50 pm
I read the first few issues of Booster Gold’s original run and it just didn’t grab me.
Didn’t care for JLI.
But “The Greatest Story Never Told” is just about my favorite Justice League episode.
Dean
April 5, 2008 at 2:42 pm
In retrospect, DC almost could not have planned the early career of Booster Gold any better. John is right that his ego does not make him a great protagonist in a solo title. However, it makes him an almost ideal member of a super-team. The lesson of the Justice League: Detroit was that characters who’ve never carried their own title are not well suited to the JLA. It is a collection of headliners. Those 25 dead-end issues got Booster in under-the-wire for the JLI.
No matter what you might feel about the Bwahahaha-era, it is hard to doubt that it was a success. The title only ran into trouble when Giffen left and other writers had a hard time continuing the template he’d created. Booster Gold was a huge part of that.
Carl
April 8, 2008 at 7:35 am
The genius of JLI was the pairing of Blue and Gold. As Booster was a wannabe Superman, Beetle was a wannabe Batman. Not that they were direct imitations or anything, it’s just that there are enough similarities to make the parallels. However, whereas I classify Superman and Batman as “friends from work”, Blue and Gold are truly best friends. Superman and Batman are friends because of mutual respect and admiration, along with the fact that they’re at least a step above nearly everyone else. Booster and Ted have fun together.
Phantom Dennis
July 3, 2011 at 4:50 pm
The one issue I read of the original run makes me think the problem may be Dan Jurgens as a writer. The episode (which was with Chesire and Hawk) was very flat and dull. He also had Booster very self-righteious in the story which doesn’t work well with that kind of character. One trouble with the early BG was making him too successful too early. Usually with heroes with this kind, Maverick is a good example, they’re only scraping by. Winning enough to keep them temporarily in the black but enough to make indepently wealthy. When they do get that big payoff, usually fate or a hidden altruistic streak appears. Instead, it looks like DJ tried to milk angst from the story of BG’s little sister Goldstar. Frustration as narrative device seem to be at the heart of the new Booster Gold comic book. Whether or not, Dan Jurgens was intentionall reference the Parker Brothers game Careers what Booster wants most is fame like the star on his chest not $. SO in his new series, he must continually save the day while receiving no acknowledgement.