web stats

CSBG Archive

Manga Before Flowers — A Love Letter to CMX

A lot of people don’t seem to know about CMX manga. It is a very strange little imprint of DC Comics (it is considered part of “Wildstorm” even though you wouldn’t even guess that unless you examined the copyright info in the back of a CMX manga).

For a large number of manga fans, CMX is best known for one of the biggest mistakes a U.S. publisher has ever made with a beloved title — that being the publisher’s edits of the raunchy & violent title Tenjho Tenge into “pg-13″ respectability. CMX appears to have learned from that very early mistake but there are some fans that will never forgive them for mangling that title so badly from the get-go.

I am very clearly not one of those fans.

Let’s face it….CMX does a lot of strange things. I think its editing choices with TenTen (which they clearly *learned* from) aren’t even its top ten of truly bizarre decisions. And by “strange” I don’t mean “bad” but actually “wonderful yet exempt from what we humans call earth logic.”

Case in point. From Eroica With Love.

Who else would bring us 1970’s shojo manga about an uptight German intelligence officer and the gay British art thief who loves (and therefore delights in torturing) him?

No one, that’s who!

I’ve already named CMX’s SWAN one of the top five shojo manga currently being published in the states, but to be honest, From Eroica with Love owns a corner of my heart no other shojo manga ever will. It is both unbelievably insane and at times surprisingly suspenseful. It is a laugh-out-loud parody of James Bond that can also make you anxious for the safety & well-being of its characters. One the one hand, we have the flamboyant aesthete, Earl Dorian Red Gloria, with flowing, golden tresses who has a thief’s sense of morality and goes by the name “Eroica” when he steals works of art. (And whose character design is apparently based on Robert Plant from Led Zepplin, dating this as the most 1970’s manga ever made. According to me). Then, on the other hand we have the rigid NATO officer Klaus Heinz von dem Eberbach, who inspires such fear in the international intelligence community he is nicknamed “Iron Klaus.” Klaus is beyond stereotypically German — he works his underlings beyond human comprehension (26 men all given an alphabet codename, A, B, C, all the way down to the delicious Z.), has no sense of humor and lives for the mission and nothing else.

There is a formula to the title — Eroica somehow gets into Klaus’s business, and they must work together to 1) save each other, and then 2) save some some precious piece of intelligence that is often 3) lodged in some priceless work of art while 4) Eroica hits on Klaus and is 5) very forcefully rebuffed and 6) the Russians and / or Klaus’s men and / or Eroica’s men run around screwing things up. Sometimes to mix things up someone is kidnapped and/or taken hostage on transportation of some kind (Trains, planes, and yes, even on boats at times.) During the breaks between the crazy missions we get glimpses into Eroica’s and Klaus’s odd home-lives and everyday routines.

It should be noted that this formula doesn’t click in place until the second half of the first volume, basically once Iron Klaus shows up. Before that the immoral and hedonistic Dorian takes center stage and it really doesn’t work until his equal in intelligence and sheer insanity enters the scene (this is simply to warn folks that if you pick up the first volume you have to be very, very kind to the mistakes the mangaka makes in the first chapters — she self-corrects and then brilliantly brings the title into focus by creating Klaus and springing him on the unsuspecting Dorian).

It’s a delightful formula that is surprisingly flexible — so far the characters have run over most of Europe, significant portions of the middle-east (multiple times), and even parts of America (usually Alaska, but once Hawaii). No matter how many iterations the mangaka goes through of the plot it always feels fresh because the scattering of all the players on the board always *is* fresh (and it doesn’t hurt there’s always a fresh, often “exotic” locale explored in each mission). There’s always a new set of circumstances, a new location, a new kooky hijink Klaus must endure (in the lastest volume he has to choose which man he should cross-dress to blackmail a Swiss banker in order to find out where the Russians are hiding $100,000. Why cross-dress a man when one could easily hire a woman? Klaus *cough* doesn’t trust women.)

Story continues below

Even though I read yaoi (read: manga focusing on male/male romantic relationships) Eroica is without a doubt the “queerest” manga I read. Any manga that lets this man (see cover image below) run amok clearly has a fabulous sense of the odd.

I recently went to the manga stack and read volume 12 & 13 back-to-back and more than ever am I convinced CMX deserves copious amounts of love for ever allowing this title to see print in English.

However, there’s more to CMX than SWAN and From Eroica with Love. They also publishing trippy 1980’s shojo which I haven’t even read yet, but already know has to be awesome. You know why? “Trippy 1980’s shojo”! Need I say more?

Okay, probably. Much of their contemporary shojo line is also quite excellent — there’s Penguin Revolution (teenagers cross-dressing to enter show-biz!), Land of the Blindfolded (teenagers with special abilities!), GALS! (teenagers with crime-fighting and accessorizing abilities!), Oyayubihime Infinity (teenagers with past-lives!), Two Flowers for the Dragon (a teenager who turns into a dragon!), Venus in Love (college freshman (aka older teenagers) in love!).

On the other hand, one might not always want to read about teenagers. Or. Um. Want to read shojo. (Yeah, this is hard for me to imagine).

Then there’s EMMA. A lovely historical romance set in the late 1800’s, emphasizing the chasm between the merchant and serving classes in its couple, William and Emma. YES, it is still about love. But it is a mature love story aimed at adults and I can honestly recommend this title to anyone who likes comics. (The art alone makes this title a must-have — luckily the writing matches its quiet intensity).

Now, CMX also has a horror line (usually rated “M” for mature themes) and puts out some shonen. I’m sure some of this is good. I wouldn’t know because clearly I’ve very, very happy with old-school & even new school shojo CMX puts out.

The odd thing about CMX is they don’t make a big deal (read: advertise) the fact they happen to be bringing things to the marketplace that NO ONE ELSE DOES. Perhaps because no one else is crazy enough to do so, as these titles aren’t exactly catching fire with consumers). Yes, Vertical brings the 1960’s and 1970’s manga but often with the name Tezuka attached or it is is shonen-oriented 70’s manga (thinking of the Kieko Takemiya stuff they publish). Recently, Matt Blind gave his take on CMX in the marketplace here. My favorite part of his take: “Anyway, CMX is such an outlier (the furthest colonial outpost, as it were) and runs so far beneath the corporate radar that they can actually release good stuff.” However, he also adds that of CMX’s releases none of them have broken the top 500 manga according to his calculations (I think Penguin Revolution has come closest). This is not suprising but it is quite a shame as far as I’m concerned.

But CMX made me a fan for life by bringing over really extraordinary titles that no one else ever has and published them on a very consistent schedule over the past few years (Even though three of four volumes of Eroica a year isn’t a lot, it is enough to make me happy). I’ve finished up a number of their series and while there are things they could do to improve the quality of their releases (generally the print & paper quality are not great) I still treasure my volumes of Eroica & SWAN. Even if I never saw another volume of Eroica in English (14 has been delayed from September to November, sadly), CMX still would have brought over 13 volumes of the zaniest, oddest and (as far as I’m concerned) most wonderful shojo manga ever created. And that is no small thing.


It’s always nice to see a manga or anime company that started out with major editing issues grow up and do some great work. I’m much more into anime than manga, and this story reminds me of Funimation. Who ever thought the company responsible for DBZ’s early butchery would do such a good job on Full Metal Alchemist that I actually prefer the dub to the original?

Danielle Leigh

July 16, 2008 at 9:14 am

*nods* CMX is a really odd little manga company in that i don’t think people know they generally have *great* titles (they just have a LOT of shojo which means they may get overlooked). They certainly aren’t perfect (their production quality leaves a lot to be desired although I find their translations to be quite strong personally).

And, agreed about Funimation. I remember when their reputation was quite bad but FMA was done so well (among other titles, I’m sure) that they’ve really become a favorite of fans for their work.

Andrew Collins

July 16, 2008 at 9:22 am

I very much respect the current group managing CMX as they seem to be doing a good job of with their catalog of mid-level titles, and I think it’s cool that they release the classic shojo titles they do. I wish we had more classic manga available in English (I’d love to finally be able to read Kimagure Orange Road…sigh…).

That said, it’s a rule every online discussion about CMX has to have at least one annoyed TenTen fan, and being one all I can say is: “CMX? Bah. Humbug. Give me uncut TenTen and all will be forgiven”

I adore From Eroica and Emma is another favorite – have also enjoyed Swan – but has anyone else had trouble finding CMX manga at their Barnes & Nobles and Waldenbooks? I have to order on-line. Once in a while I will see maybe one volume – usually the 8th or 9th of a CMX series on the shelf and that’s it. Given that most readers I know get into a series by flipping through it on the shelf, it seems a shame it doesn’t have a bigger shelf presence. Now if they’d just bring out Emperor of the Land of the Rising Sun or Rose of Versaille, I’d be a really happy shopper. :)

After the kerfuffle with Tenjho Tenge I assumed that CMX would fold up in a few months so I quit paying attention to them. Thanks for letting us know that not only has CMX gotten its act together but they have gone nuts in an interesting way as well.

Danielle Leigh

July 16, 2008 at 11:36 am

hi Andrew — yeah, fans of that title were seriously burned so I don’t begrudge them their anger at CMX. The nice thing about the whole mess is CMX doesn’t make that mistake anymore although they’ve taken a different approach with their mature titles lately, giving them a prestige format and a higher price ($12.99).

Kiki — great point about their lack of bookstore exposure. It is almost impossible to get most CMX manga in a bookstore — I order most of mine from the comic book shop, which works out well for *me* since DC/Wildstorm/CMX books ship when they should and I usually don’t have a problem getting them. But I don’t think I’ve ever seen Eroica or SWAN in a bookstore. It really is a miracle these books come out at all as far as I’m concerned….EMMA, though, I think can usually be found, although, not always.

Hmm, I don’t think I have read anything by CMX other then tenjho tenge vol. 1. They sound somewhat interesting based on descriptions but I haven’t really heard of them before.

I’ve seen some CMX in the bookstore, but I too order mine from the comic book shop.

I personally love CMX’s variety in shojo titles, and am also waiting on Kimagure and Rose of Versailles. :) I’d take Oniisama E while they’re at it, too!

The other hassle with CMX titles is the availability outside the US.
For the most part, Diamond won’t ship their stuff overseas, which is irksome.


*Resolves to use *Gondammit* in conversation*

On topic: I want to read all of these.

[…] Should Be Good, Danielle Leigh gives a fine example of “covering the material we like” with her latest Manga Before Flowers column on CMX, DC’s stealth manga division: “But CMX made me a fan for life by bringing over really […]

Danielle Leigh

July 17, 2008 at 7:20 am

hey, Mark, you back in the I.C.?

I’ll be back to the comic bookstore this saturday afternoon (looks like I’m working a new day of the week from now on) in case you want to stop by and say hi!

I love CMX’s line of books to bits — but unfortunately the translation of the first two volumes of Eroica kept tripping me up with bizarre misuses of British slang which seemed to have been learned from reading Harry Potter fanfiction. It was like nails on a blackboard! The sheer crazy awesomeness of the story carried me through it, though.

The first I ever heard of CMX was during the TenTen debacle, and no, not a good first impression, but ye gods, that was years ago, people, and it was a one-time mistake. A big one, to be sure, but no bigger than the biggest mistakes made by other manga publishers, and, unlike other publishers, they don’t keep repeating it. I love CMX and their wacky catalog, and I trust their taste enough that I will at least look at every new title with their logo that I see on the bookshelves.

I think someone up there mentioned GON, which should definitely be added to the roster of “weird but awesome things CMX has brought to enrich my life.”

CMX do some fantastic stuff- Eroica is just perfect madness, Cipher is entirely cast by the members of Tears for Fears and The Thomson Twins, Swan is fantastic and I have a soft spot for The Devil Does Exist (even though I see its limitations). They also publish The Young Magician, and Omekae Desu by Tanaka Meca which stars a Shinigami in a GIANT BUNNY SUIT who rides a moped. This is basically a back catalogue entirely made of WIN and which I need to own all of.

And their back catalogue is generally available which I really appreciate.

For some reason CMX reminds me a bit of Blu- they seem to be imprints which have a distinctive editorial feel to them and they are prepared to bring over some titles which won’t be immediately popular but which they consider to be such classics that they deserve to be licensed and which will still sell respectably over the long run. This is just my impression but they do seem to have an eye for the classics and use some of the profits from other titles to subsidise the titles that will build an on-going manga fan base.

Yeah, I’m around.

Not so much on saturday, though. I’ll aim for next week. I’m really curious as to what you thought ’bout Anime-con.

[…] Leigh explains why she likes CMX in her latest Manga Before Flowers column, and I’m with her—I love their classic shoujo […]

Dear Danielle:

Thank-you for spreading the CMX love! I must admit I WAS one of the many who ignored the publisher for a long time, but now I think I’ve seen the light. They do have an eye for those diamonds in the rough (the rough being the overwhelming number of high school shoujo, *shudder*). I have finally made a commitment to see what this publisher was about, and I was pleasantly surprised. It’s too bad I had to do all the work myself (where is the driving force behind this company’s marketing?). I think that makes us feel better about reading CMX series, though, because we know we are the select few who have made a good choice not to miss out on some truly deserving series. Jump comics are fun, but don’t we all need some variety? Am I right?

PS: I’m with whoever else wanted Rose of Versailles, too!

hello there! do you have any information about a story named ” Land of The Blindfolded “? if you have please e-mail me.


Unfortunately,those who like CMX seem to be in the minority.

There are still those who see CMX as butchers who should not be in the manga business
and regard what was done to TenTen as unforgivable.

I don’t know. Too much vitriol it seems.

Leave a Comment



Review Copies

Comics Should Be Good accepts review copies. Anything sent to us will (for better or for worse) end up reviewed on the blog. See where to send the review copies.

Browse the Archives