web stats

CSBG Archive

Top 100 Comic Book Battles: 100-96

Here we go!

Here is the Master List!


100. Superboy Prime vs. Teen Titans (Infinite Crisis)

In Infinite Crisis #4 by Geoff Johns and Phil Jimenez, the Superboy from Earth-Prime (who has been trapped in a sort of multiverse limbo since the events of Crisis on Infinite Earths) travels to the home of Jonathan and Martha Kent to try to make some sense of the modern DC world (and Alex Luthor’s plans for it). When there, he confronts Conner Kent, the Superboy of this world. After an awkward interaction, Superboy Prime (being a bit of a chump) decides to take out his aggression on Conner.

Conner is pretty out-classed, but help is on its way, in the form of pretty much every Teen Titan (or Titan-related character, period)!!!

They hope to settle things peacefully, but, well, things go a bit awry.

Prime proceeds to take apart the Titans pretty easily (and viciously, killing another Titan and tearing the arm of one), and the day is only saved by the combined force of the Flashes, who take Prime into the Speed Force basically.

99. Skurge vs. the Forces of Hel

Skurge, the Executioner, had always been a bit of a lackey in the Marvel Universe to the Enchantress.

In the pages of The Mighty Thor #362, by the great Walt Simonson, Skurge got his chance to make a better name for himself.

In this issue, Thor wants to free some mortal souls that Hela has wrongly stolen to Hel, the Norse underworld. Thor, his compatriot Balder and a group of Asgardian warriors (armed with swords and M-16s) seek to rescue the mortals. Skurge, looking for redemption, goes along on the mission.

They rescue the mortals, but are now being chased by the hordes of Hel and they make their way for Gjallerbru, a bridge right outside the border of Hel with Asgard.

Thor plans on staying behind to hold off the forces while the rest escape (because Thor is cool like that). Skurge knocks Thor unconscious from behind. What’s going on!??

As it turns out, Skurge wants to do it himself. He stays behind at the bridge, along with a few M-16s and, well…check it out…

Skurge dies in holding the bridge, but that second part is more important – he holds the bridge.

And in doing so, Skurge went from being a pretty minor villain to being an all-time great hero.

How amazing is the panel of him batting away at the hordes of Hel with the empty rifle?

98. Squadron Supreme vs. Redeemers

Mark Gruenwald and Bob Hall’s Squadron Supreme maxi-series was a great precursor to a number of modern comics, in that it tackled the subject of what would happen if superheroes just decide to fight crime in a more “realistic” manner. What if they really just tried to, say, end poverty? Starvation?

Well, in this series, the Squadron Supreme decide that is just what they will do, and spend the series doing so.

However, their former teammate, Nighthawk (who was also President of the United States for a time) believes this to be foolhardy – that they should serve the public, not rule over them. For the entirety of the series, Nighthawk searches for help from various sources (including Captain America and the Avengers) until ultimately, in the last issue, he confronts the Squadron himself, along with a group of former villains (who took issue with the behavior modification aspect of the Squadron’s plans for making Earth a Utopia).

The battle is a long and bloody one, and Nighthawk does not live to see it end.

Upon his friend’s death, the Squadron’s leader, Hyperion, ends the battle when he comes to realize that his fallen friend was correct.

97. Superman vs. Batman (New Frontier)

One of the more intriguing parts of the Darwyn Cooke mini-series, The New Frontier, was the quickly referenced fight between Batman and Superman in the early issues.

The fight is only barely shown, so Cooke took the opportunity in his New Frontier Special #1 (coinciding with the release of the New Frontier direct-to-DVD cartoon movie) to show the entirety of the fight, which involves Superman trying to take in Batman for the government.

Story continues below

The fight is about as clever as a Superman vs. Batman fight can be, and there is beautiful artwork from Cooke. It is also quite interesting to see how Cooke fits Batman’s methods within the time restraints of the era. The introduction of Kryptonite was a nice touch, as well.

96. Thanos vs. Warlock, Captain Marvel, Avengers, Thing and Spider-Man

Jim Starlin was given the chance to wrap up his Warlock/Thanos storyline in two Annuals of other books, Avengers Annual #7 and Marvel Two-in-One Annual #2.

In the first story, Warlock is still attempting to defeat the mad god, Thanos, who is trying to destroy the stars to please Death, who Thanos loves. Thanos’ armada is right outside of Earth, so the Avengers and Captain Marvel show up to help out Warlock.

While the Avengers battle Thanos, Warlock meets his demise by basically merging with the Soul Gem that he carried on his forehead. At the end of the Annual, while Thanos appears triumphant, Warlock is actually pretty happy in the afterlife with his friends Gamora and Pip the Troll (who both were killed earlier, as well, and had their souls enshrined in the gem).

The Marvel Two-in-One Annual involves Spider-Man and the Thing getting involved in the action, freeing the Avengers and taking the fight to Thanos, for an amazing couple of full-page spreads by Starlin of all out brawling.

Ultimately, Spider-Man frees the Soul Gem from wherever Thanos had it being held, and Warlock (through the Soul Gem) takes out Thanos once and for all (well, so we thought at the time), turning him to stone.

And the day is saved, and Jim Starlin’s cosmic epic was an end – for now!


Yo, you better have the last Spider-Man/Harry Osborn fight in the top 20. Harry drinks a bunch of super Goblin juice, takes Mary Jane to “the bridge”, flies around town harassing Peter in broad daylight, kicks Spider-Man’s ass in a bomb-rigged building, and then goes back to save him, proving The Power of Friendship in his last seconds before he succumbs to his own jacked-up formula. All around, a good companion piece to the original “last fight” with the first Green Goblin, and way better than the movie.

Skurge’s final battle only rated 99/100? Sigh…

(btw, the goddess of death’s name is Hela)

THat is my EXACT reaction.

Only 99…

“Skurge’s final battle only rated 99/100? Sigh…”

Yeah, can’t remember if I listed it in my top ten, but if I didn’t, I should have.

I love these lists but its a shame that no battle from the Walt Simonson run on Thor was in the Top 25.
We can do a Top 10 with that run alone.
Skurge’s battle is one of my favorite comics moments and should be ranked much higher.
And if Thor vs The World Serpent isn’t at least in the Top 30 it’s gonna be a great injustice

There’s two of my ten right there.

My favorite part of the Thanos vs Everybody fight is Spidey freaking out and running away, then getting his shit together and coming back in a most heroic fashion.

Skurge holding the bridge should have been top ten for sure.

Yup, I had that Warlock fight in my Top Ten. Pretty sweet. (It’s odd how Thanos seemed so genuinely menacing without casually ripping off the heads of any long-established characters.)

I’d also stick that Skurge battle much, much higher. I wasn’t even a big fan of Thor, or even Walt Simonson, and read that comic back then only by accident. Those frames have stuck with me better through the years (decades?) than other comics that I collected obsessively.

Well-composed, impactful… noble, meaningful death.

Need to track down Simonson’s Thor.

That Skurge scene was one of the first times that I was really, deeply, moved by a comic. I remember re-reading it several times and actually choking up and I think that — in all honesty — it was one of the formative moments that turned me into a lifelong comic fan. So, I know that I’m not objective about it, but I’d also place this in the top ten battles.

Batman vs Superman in New Frontier should be about 5000 spots above Superboy Prime vs the Titans. They’re literally on opposite ends of the spectrum in terms of quality.

Argh..I can’t believe I forgot MTIO Annual 2, my favorite comic ever!!!!! that’s what I get for rushing.

I thought it was nice that they reprinted Thor #362 in the “God-Sized” Thor out this week. Man, those Simonson Thors were great! Skurge’s Last Laugh should be waaaay higher than this, but people forget just how awesome Simonson on Thor really was, I guess.

The Squadron Supreme cover reminds me a lot of a classic “Legends” scene. IIRC it came after Legends, could it be an homage? Or are both scenes referencing something else?

Skurge at Gjallerbru is a truly iconic moment in comics. Cheers Walt Simonson for the best written superhero comics of the entire 80’s decade.

Glad I’m not the only one who was moved by, enjoyed and still remembers Skurge’s last stand. This is a great list for reminiscing so far!

I read the Skurge story just this week, in the Thor God-Sized special, and was awesome, that’s the way a hero should die, that fight is a Top Ten for sure. Peace.

Skurge at Gjallerbru is one of my favorite comic book moments. And so is Thor vs Jormungand. And Surtur forging Twilight. And Eilif’s last stand against Fafnir. And Beta Ray Bill defeating Thor. Though I never cared an iota for the character before or after this run, Simonson’s Thor was pure gold. Best superhero comic ever.

Seriously???? This is the list??? What did you get your little sister to compile this list???WTF?? Dude, how were you even allowed to publish this? This is pathetic!

[…] Should Be Good has started posting the results of the Top 100 Comic Battles poll. #100 is Superboy-Prime vs. the Teen Titans from Infinite Crisis, a battle which ended only when the Flashes got together and pushed him into […]

[…] is nothing wrong with death, when it’s appropriate (see #99 here). But when the cupidity of dice and the stupidity of players conspire against the story, there are […]

Excellent post however , I was wondering if you could write a litte more on this topic? I’d be very thankful if you could elaborate a little bit further. Kudos!

I just could not go away your web site prior to suggesting that
I actually enjoyed the standard information a
person provide on your guests? Is gonna be back incessantly
in order to inspect new posts

Hey there! I know this is somewhat ooff topic but I was
wondering if you kne where I could get a captcha plugin for my comkent form?
I’m using the same blog platform as yours and I’m having difficulty finding one?
Thanks a lot!

Leave a Comment



Review Copies

Comics Should Be Good accepts review copies. Anything sent to us will (for better or for worse) end up reviewed on the blog. See where to send the review copies.

Browse the Archives