web stats

CSBG Archive

Top 100 Comic Book Battles: 90-86

Here’s the next five!

Here is the master list!


90. Spider-Man vs. Sinister Six (First Battle)

What a notion for the very first Annual in Spider-Man history! For Amazing Spider-Man Annual #1, Spider-Man faced almost all of his (at that point) solo villains as a team!!! Doctor Octopus, Kraven, Electro, Sandman, Mysterio and the Vulture combine forces to take on Spider-Man!

The Sinister Six were such a major point in Spider-Man history that they did not even show up again as a team for almost 30 more years!!!

The plan in the issue was not exactly brilliant, but the Stan Lee and Steve Ditko issue made up for the villains’ fairly silly plan with the gusto in which Lee/Ditko executed it – especially Ditko, who did a marvelous job on this Annual.

The villains’ plot was that each one of them would fight Spider-Man one by one at a location best suited for each of the villains. The hope would be that after facing them all in a row, eventually he would tire and one of the villains later in the line would be able to take him out. Probably not as smart as actually using their numbers advantage to crush him, but hey, at least it is a plan!

The motivation for Spider-Man to follow their plan is that Aunt May and Betty Brant have been kidnapped. He is told he must defeat each villain and if he does, pick up a card telling him which one he has to face next and where.

Of course, complicating matters is that Spider-Man loses his powers early in the issue (he gets them back really quickly, but still – he begins the battles powerless!).

Each of the fights include one splash page by Ditko of Spider-Man fighting each of the villains.

Naturally, Spidey proceeds to beat each one of the villains and save the day, but at the end of it all, the novelty of six of Spider-Man’s villains getting together proved so popular that even though it was their only appearance for almost 30 years, people still remember it quite fondly.

89. Superman Prime vs. Ion

During the Sinestro Corps War, Daxamite Green Lantern Sodam Yat is given control of Ion, a powerful energy source that the Guardians trust to special Green Lanterns to guard. In return, Ion gives the user powerful energy powers.

Also during the War, Superman Prime made his way back to Earth for the first time since Infinite Crisis, and this time, it is not just the Teen Titans waiting for him, but pretty much every DC hero there is! Their plan was to take him out before the sun comes out, but they were unable to do so, so Sodam Yat shows up to try to stop him.

Their battle is a fierce brawl in Green Lantern Corps #18 by Peter Tomasi and artist Patrick Gleason (Jamal Igle draws some flashbacks during the issue) that leaves Yat, the most powerful Green Lantern of them all – a bloody mess by issue’s end.

Still, he gave a villain who took on the entirety of DC’s superheroes a run for his money!

88. Avengers vs. Nefaria (Second Battle)

Count Nefaria was one of the earliest Avengers villains, attempting to take them on sans powers. That did not work out so well for him, and he was a minor character the next decade or so.

He came to preeminence again in Avengers #164-166, a dynamite three-parter by Jim Shooter and John Byrne, where Nefaria reformed the Lethal Legion with the villains Power Man, Whirlwind and the Living Laser, whose powers were increased by Nefaria to fight the Avengers.

We soon learn, however, that Nefaria experimented with their powers only so he himself could gain their powers! He has a scientist do so and once he is powered, he fatally wounds the scientist and takes on the Avengers!

He handles them easily, in a series of great panels by a young John Byrne. What’s especially cool is the battle between Nefaria and Thor, where he man-handles Thor (who, to his credit, never gives up) including the awesome scene where he just stops Thor’s hammer mid-swing.

Eventually the dying scientist catches up with Nefaria to tell him that the energy transfer is quite unstable (and it is aging Nefaria rapidly), and Nefaria is clearly losing some power, so ultimately, the Avengers just pile on him with all they have until he is very weakened, at which point Vision flies high into the air, turns as hard as diamond and then drops to the ground, crushing Nefaria and finally takes out the man who took on the entire assembled Avengers!

Story continues below

87. Captain America vs. Red Skull (Cosmic Cube)

The Red Skull, Captain America’s greatest enemy, returns from seeming death as well in the 1960s in the pages of Tales of Suspense #79-81, which is also the first appearance of the Cosmic Cube.

The Cosmic Cube gives the bearer of the cube basically absolute power, and the Red Skull possesses the Cube (for the first of a few times he’s handled the item).

Stan Lee and Jack Kirby tell the tale demonstrating just how heroic Cap is (and this is early Silver Age Cap, too!) that he is able to take on a villain with absolute power and still beat him!

A lot of that comes from the fact that Captain America just does not know how to quit – even though the Skull out-powers him tremendously, Cap keeps at it, and eventually he causes the Skull to doubt himself long enough for Cap to separate the Skull from the Cube, saving the day (and really, the whole world!).

It was one of the earliest classic storyline for Captain America – you could really tell how much affection Kirby had for his co-creation in this tale.

Most of the tale is Cap trying to keep Skull from getting the Cube, but when the Skull gets the Cube finally, the disorientation of the great power is the best asset Cap has, which is how Cap is able to trick the Skull long enough to knock the cube from the Skull’s hand (the battle takes place on Red Skull’s own island!).

Okay, yeah, there really should have been no way for Cap to last this long with a Cosmic Cube-holding Skull, but darnit, it was still awesome!

86. Spider-Man vs. Firelord

The former herald of Galactus, Firelord, is visiting Earth for some Earth cuisine when he is attacked by some construction workers who think he’s a mutant. As he is about to kill the worker for the affront, Spider-Man shows up, and spends the rest of Amazing Spider-Man #269 and 270 fighting Firelord throughout New York.

Writer Tom DeFalco and artist Ron Frenz handle the tale, which is very reminiscent of Spider-Man’s battle against the Juggernaut, in that Spider-Man does everything he can to stop Firelord, but Firelord basically shrugs it all off.

Spidey actually tries to steer the battle towards other heroes he feels better suited to stop Firelord, like the Fantastic Four and Avengers, but that does not work out for him.

Ultimately, Spider-Man tricks Firelord into exploding a gas station. The gigantic explosion softens Firelord up enough for Spider-Man to finally really go on the offensive, and begin pummeling the herald with blows until eventually, all of Spider-Man’s punches begin to have an effect. Spider-Man won’t quit and just keeps at it, constantly punching Firelord until a hand stops Spidey. He turns and sees it is Captain America. The Avenges are here just in time to have seen Spider-Man pummel Firelord into unconsciousness!!

See what you can do when you put your mind to it, kids?


Always loved that Spider-Man/Firelord fight.
Glad to see it made the list.


I see people complain about it, but this story is one of the reasons that people shouldn’t use ‘rpg’ logic in fiction.

They didn’t do the Sinister Six again for three decades, but a couple of years later Stan reprised the gimmick in 1967’s Daredevil Annual #1, with DD’s less stellar cast of villains.

The middle issue of the Avengers/Nefaria fight was the first Avengers I ever read and still holds two of my favorite moments from the entire series: Iron Man nearly taking him down solo and surprising him, and then the final scene appearance of Thor and Nefaria’s genuine fear (even though he’d been bragging about wishing Thor were there the whole time). Great stuff.

Yeah, that three issue Avengers story is one of my all time favorites as well.

I have not read any of these. Huh. They look cool enough.

That first Spidey Annual is one of the most fun comics ever made.

I’ve read all of these aside from the Spider-Man ones, but I’ve always meant to track down the Spidey vs Firelord issues. Pretty good battles in all of these.

Ditko’s full page panels of Spidey punching out each of the villians in the 1st annual are some of my favorite Ditko panels ever. Everyone should read this book and witness Stan and Steve at their best.

I actually have the Sandman splash page from Annual #1 as a T-shirt. It’s so awesome and even says like “Whap!” where Spider-Man’s fist meets Sandy’s face. The Firelord fight reads like a sequel to the Juggernaut fight and I’m sure DeFalco had that story in mind when he wrote these issues. As Rusty said, don’t apply RPG logic to it. Really, neither Juggernaut nor Firelord really treated Spider-Man as a serious foe, but more as an annoyance. In light of this, its not completely unfeasible that Spidey would win.

i really enjoyed the Spidey Vs. Firelord battle, but the Cap Vs. Red Skull was epic. This has everything that you need to know about Cap. Tough, smart, and undefeatable, even in the face of ultimate power! i even had that comic at one point, but sold it to my LCS so that i could buy some crappy ’90s comics. Ah youth is wasted on the wrong people! :[

That Spider-man annual had one of my favourite moments as a kid where Aunt May is kidnapped but didn’t realize it. When Peter saves her at the end he asks ‘are you shook up?” (or something like that) and she scolds him for bad language.

The Nefaria story is my favorite ever! It’s essentially Superman vs. The Avengers, back when the team didn’t have it own “Superman” (oh, how I hate the Sentry!).

Hunter (Pedro Bouça)

Wondered when that Firelord one was gonna come up. The simple truth is that TONS of these involve Spider-Man. Scrappy dude with just enough power to take on the world, and enough sympathy to win OR lose with heart.

Avengers vs. Nefaria really stands out in my mind… and like Pedro Bouça said, i always saw it as “Avengers vs. Superman.”

I own those Avengers vs Nefaria issues. Great storyline. The Whizzer placing a seed of doubt in Nefaria’s mind during their skirmish. Beast, reacting to Nefaria’s presence, seeks revenge for Thunderbird’s death but is casually brushed aside (I was unaware of who Thunderbird was at the time). Thor at the end of the middle issue poppng up out of nowhere (later explained during the “Korvac Saga” run). Lot’s of highlights throughout.

Leave a Comment



Review Copies

Comics Should Be Good accepts review copies. Anything sent to us will (for better or for worse) end up reviewed on the blog. See where to send the review copies.

Browse the Archives