CBR Live! Archive
Danielle Leigh's Reading Diary -- 12/27/08
Quick takes on this week's comics / manga reading:
The Best American Comics of 2008 edited by Lynda Barry
The Super-Cool Life of Strawberry Chan by Ai Morinaga
Venus in Love vol 5 by Yuki Nakaji
One Thousand and One Nights Vol 6 by Han SeungHee and Jeon JinSeok
***
The Best American Comics of 2008 edited by Lynda Barry
I always think I'm going to like Comics Anthologies and I almost never do. This volume was an exception -- it was eclectic in the best sense of the word and most selections were tantalizing enough that I definitely want to track down longer works from these creators.
I spend most of my time in the manga sand-box these days, but reading this book was a wonderful introduction to the exciting diversity of American comics. There was a mix of some of the major sequential narrative "epics" currently being created (such as Jason Lutes' Berlin, Alison Bechel's Dykes to Watch out For, anything by Rick Geary) as well as wonderful short stories from "fresh" new (to me) artists like T. Edward Bak and Sarah Oleksyk.
This was a great book to help pass the time relaxing during this holiday break -- I basically started it the second my grades were turned in and finished it the next morning. And now I almost want to read the whole thing over again just to experience American comics once again through this book.
Highly recommended.
***
The Super-Cool Life of Strawberry Chan by Ai Morinaga
I have a deep fondness for Morinaga's comics but the whole thing with a frog in love with a human boy and the boy who abuses him doesn't really sit all that well with me. This is actually the second volume of zany-frog-boys'-boarding-school antics and the one-note joke of the series probably wore out its welcome in the first volume. However, one highlight of this volume was a very masculine girl who somehow finds herself enrolled in an all boys school...and unlike every other shojo manga in the world, actually is so masculine no one can tell the difference. Even in the shower. Oh Morinaga. You so crazy.
Stick to Your and My Secret or My Heavenly Hockey Club for more robust characters *and* laughs.
****
Venus in Love vol 5 by Yuki Nakaji
Venus in Love continues to charm my socks right off, with gentle romance and love-triangles that are realistic never over-wrought and drenched in melodrama. In this volume Suzuna and Eichi become closer and their silly flirting / fighting never gets old, even though it probably should. It is so darn sweet you'd think I'd go into sugar shock. Somehow Nakaji makes me, cynical old me, believe that college students can actually have real romance instead of drunken hook-ups and morning-after-walks-of-shame.
Another fine volume in this lovely series.
***
One Thousand and One Nights Vol 6 by Han SeungHee and Jeon JinSeok
I came to this title late, but find that it is always a lovely diversion. The basic plot is a re-imaging of the Scherezade fairy tale, but between (what I assume) is a young, tyrannical prince and a kind, sweet young man whose stories will eventually soften the young prince's heart. Most of this volume is devoted to the story within a story, as the young story-teller weaves a narrative about the love affair of the brilliant scholar Socrates and the capricous Alcibiades. The artist is able to represent many different "exotic" locales -- ancient Greece, pre-modern middle east, and while the writing is very strong, the art really grabs you and lets you get lost in multiple worlds, not just the one. The scope of this manga seems both huge (the stories within the story) and yet quite intimate (all stories are really about the relationships between lovers as far as I can tell).
Review copy provided by Yen Press.
***
Titles up on deck for next week's reading diary:
Nightmare Inspector: Yumekui Kenben
Red Blinds the Foolish
Mushishi vol 6
- Posted on December 27, 2008 @ 01:33 PM






6 Comments
jun
December 27, 2008 at 3:18 pm
I like the weekly reading diary idea! I'm actually gonna be reading Venus in Love 4-5 at some point this weekend and my copy of Red Blinds the Foolish is on its way!
Danielle Leigh
December 27, 2008 at 3:40 pm
thanks, Jun! I hope other people enjoy it too, but to be honest, most of the time I like to talk about what I've read but not feel the pressure of doing a whole review (particularly when you are dealing with a volumes past the first couple of a series and the title is pretty established by that point).
Melinda Beasi
December 27, 2008 at 5:05 pm
Oh, lovely! I look forward to these entries!
Grico
December 27, 2008 at 11:02 pm
Hey, always good to have manga content. I am reading Honey & Clover 4 and Sand Chronicles 2 and 3 tonight/tomorrow. I got the latest issue of shojo beat in my christmas stocking but cannot read either series since i am too behind. Sand chronicles 1 was quite good, and after some initial Honey & Clover apathy I'm a bit addicted. It feels like a stranger Here is Greenwood, which is not a bad place to be.
jun
December 30, 2008 at 8:26 am
Hee. That's a good comparison, Grico.
MangaBlog » Blog Archive » Roundup of roundups
January 5, 2009 at 5:53 am
[...] Should Be Good, with short impressions of whatever she’s reading at the moment. She covers three titles in her first entry, takes a longer look at vols. 1-4 of Yumekui Kenbun: Nightmare Inspector in the [...]