CBR Live! Archive
Scott's Classic Comics Corner: Buying the Whole Company
You've probably all read about the collector who put together a collection of every comic ever published by DC. It took him nearly 40 years and the collection adds up to more than 30,000 comic books. Well, if you're anything like me - you won't be able to duplicate that trick unless you discover that you're Warren Buffett's secret love child. Don't worry, as it's quite possible to put together a collection of a publisher's entire output with relative ease. These may not be DC or Marvel, but you also won't need much more than a short box for any of these collections.
Let's start with King Comics. In the late 60s, King decided to begin publishing some of their own properties, which had previously been produced by thrid parties. Titles like Popeye, the Phantom and Mandrake the Magician were showing up on comic book stands with the King logo. The experiment didn't last very long and by the end of the decade, most of these titles had been transferred over to the fine folks at Charlton. All told, you'd be looking at about 100 books spread over 15 or so titles in various genres. There's some good reading in there (especially the Flash Gordon series, as I've mentioned before) and they are very affordable for Silver Age books.
Next up is Tower Comics - the grand experiment of the Silver Age. Wally Wood & Co. produced some terrific books, but in the end it was a commercial failure as fans were perhaps turned off by having to drop down a full quarter for a single book. Oh well, for whatever reason, it never took off but that makes putting together a full Tower collection that much easier. You would need to track down something like 75 issues spread out over 10 titles. Many of the stories have been collected in the DC Archives format, but you can still find low to mid grade copies of these books at very affordable prices. The thing is, unless you're a huge Tippy Teen fan - it make can a bit monotonous trying to complete this one.
Let's move into the 70s with Atlas-Seaboard, the Goodman family's Titanic-level failure. Atlas-Seaboard came out swinging with numerous titles in a variety of genres, trying to carve out a piece of the DC/Marvel pie. It didn't survive a year, and no title lasted more than 4 issues. There is some good stuff in there (and I'll comment on those in a future column), but much of it is pretty shoddy. Although I know there are plenty of collectors trying to put together a collection of this entire line - many of the books are widely available and quite cheap. All you'd have to do is track down is 60 or so issues spread out over 20+ titles. I've probably got this one 80% completed myself - but the really tough title to find is Vicki. If you're looking to add the black and white magazines, you'll discover that a few of those are quite scarce as well.
If those three companies seem a bit daunting, let me suggest some true micro-collections that won't take up too much space in your house. Skywald was the brainchild of Israel Waldman and Sol Brodsky, mixing new stories and covers with some reprints. They never got into the superhero game, but seemed to focus on westerns at a time when their popularity was waning. To collect all of their comic book output, you'd only need to find 20 or so issues. If you want a real challenge - add their B&W magazines and you'll need to find an additional 60 or so books. These mags are often a lot of fun and some, such as Crime Machine, can be tough to track down.
Here's nice challenge in a small package. For a short period in the early 50s, Ross Andru and Mike Eposito published books under their very own banner - Mikeross Publications. It wasn't a lasting success, but there is some good stuff in there. I stumbled into a partial Mikeross collection through my infinity cover collection as all 3 issues of Get Lost feature infinity covers. Although these might take you a while to track down - you only need to find 7 issues spread over 4 titles. Sure, it's Golden Age stuff - but low grade copies won't set you back much.
Finally, we've got Stanley Publications, which produced a grand total of two comic books in the mid-60s. I've got the first issue of Battle Heroes, and it's all reprints from a pre-Code war book from a Gilmor/Stanmor/Key book. If 2 books just doesn't satisfy you're craving, you can branch out into their horror magazines, which reprint pre-code horror stories (you may recognize the covers above). Although that only an additional 30+ titles, these don't show up all that often it may take you some time to piece together a collection.
There are plenty of other short-lived publishers, so the challenge of buying the whole company can go on and on.
For more classic comic talk - please visit my blog, Seduction of the Indifferent
- Posted on January 6, 2009 @ 08:59 AM












29 Comments
DubipR
January 6, 2009 at 9:30 am
Greaet article. Owning company books is a hard thing to do. Luckily during the 90s when Silver Age was next to dead, I bought the entire Tower Comics line for next to nothing. The line-up of talent on those books alone are worth some sort of mega Omnibus, instead of that one Archive DC put out.
Seeing this, my interest is piqued in the Atlas/Seaboard titles, well some of them
Good job!
Aqualad
January 6, 2009 at 10:11 am
I'm trying for a complete Gladstone collection (dont' much care about condition as long as they're intact), but there are a couple stumbling blocks. First is that later series 2 Gladstones are expensive and can be hard to find. Second is that most Mickey Mouse comics blow and I can't muster the effort to try to collect them.
I tracked down some key issues on the Ebay, but mostly I just buy whatever Disney or EC Reprint that I come across in bargain bins.
Aqualad
January 6, 2009 at 10:13 am
Now that I think about it, it probably wouldn't be that hard to assemble a complete "Disney Comics" collection. Those only ran a couple years before the rights went back to Gladstone.
Dan Bailey
January 6, 2009 at 10:24 am
I guess the only time I ever really actively collected Atlas Seaboard was when I was buying 'em off the spinner racks as they came out. (I've mentioned before on the Classic Comics forum that the only comic theft [knock wood] I've ever suffered, back in the mid-'70s, consisted of a stack of comics that would've been largely Seaboards, oddly enough.)
These days I pick them up as I come across them for dirt cheap ... which included, bizarrely, a copy of Vicki for probably a buck at a shop in Birmingham, Ala., 3 or 4 years ago.
Aqualad
January 6, 2009 at 10:27 am
Why is Vicki so hard to come across? Is it Archie collectors buying them up?
suedenim
January 6, 2009 at 10:41 am
I think I've got pretty close to the entire output of Milestone Comics. Just missing one or two partial runs on minor titles I didn't particularly care for, I think.
Michael
January 6, 2009 at 10:45 am
Not quite a whole company, but I wonder if anyone's tried to collect the entire Star line of comics. That'd run up pretty well, since Spectacular Spider-Ham hit the triple digits.
Michael
January 6, 2009 at 10:45 am
Also, Aqualad, I'll meet you at the flagpole after school. Nobody talks about the Mouse like that to me.
suedenim
January 6, 2009 at 10:49 am
Why is Vicki so hard to come across? Is it Archie collectors buying them up?
I suspect it's probably part of a more general problem - that romance and "teen humor" titles weren't usually read by the male audience of comics collectors, instead being purchased by girls who probably threw them out later, or don't go to comic book conventions, etc. So they're genuinely scarcer compared to adventure titles, which were saved and "collected" more frequently.
Blackjak
January 6, 2009 at 11:10 am
I know they were in the 90s, so they probably don't count, but TeknoComix was relatively short-lived...
TeknoPhage and Mr. Hero were quite good! (at least the early issues...)
Blackjak
January 6, 2009 at 11:11 am
Oh, and my wife has a copy of Vicki #1 which she is rightly quite proud of!
Dan Bailey
January 6, 2009 at 11:17 am
DC's Impact imprint -- The Web, The Comet, etc -- totaled, what, something like 110 issues? I know I've got all those. Same with the shorter-lived Focus imprint.
Andrew Collins
January 6, 2009 at 11:17 am
The Mike Danger title from TeknoComix was fun too, but yeah, pretty much the rest of the line was a waste...
Jeff R
January 6, 2009 at 12:05 pm
I was expecting a lot more 80's-90's microimprints. (Spiderbaby! Palliard! King Hell! )
Then there are a few where, if you've already got a collection of a particular book, it shouldn't be too tough to round out the company. (Cerebus to Aardvark-Vanaheim, or Elfquest to Warp, for example)...
Blackjak
January 6, 2009 at 12:07 pm
@ Jeff R: Cerebus #1 would be a purse-stretcher though...
Aqualad
January 6, 2009 at 12:23 pm
Hey Michael, when the comics are good, they're really good (most of the Gottfriedson adventure strips were good). But most of the rest of Mickey comics are bland at best. I have the full run of Mickey and Donald/ Donald and Mickey, and man there are some stinkers in there.
Stephane Savoie
January 6, 2009 at 12:39 pm
I'm quite proud of my Impact collection. I'm less proud of my New Universe collection.
Someday I'll get back to my Milestone collecting.
Collecting entire runs sure is fun, though!
The Mutt
January 6, 2009 at 12:39 pm
I think I owned the complete Atlas output before my last big purge. Minus Vicki, of course. All bought from the spinner racks.
I'll bet Vicki is hard to find because of guys like me who thought, "Say, with just a couple of Vickies, I could have a complete set!"
Scott
January 6, 2009 at 12:48 pm
Good conversation, folks.
I didn't mention some of the publishers noted above because my mandate is pretty much pre-Crisis here.
As for Vicki - I don't have any first hand experience re. the title's scarcity - just from old market reports etc... There are a few copies of #4 on ebay right now, with BINs at $20+. I understand that Gothic Romances mag, and one of the Movies Monsters mag is tough to find. I had the one with the Harryhausen Cyclops on the cover as a kid, but it's been lost to the sands fo time.
I took some time off from piecing together an Atlas-Seaboard collection - but I'm thinking that I might jump back onboard. For those interested in A-B - check out the old Comic Book Marketplace and Comic Book Artist issues dedicated to the company - and check out the 'Atlas Archives' website.
In terms of Tower - I have most of the superhero stuff (it's still quite affordable), but I can't see myself buying all of those Tippy Teen books. I never even mention those weird Tower paperbacks.
Another I thought of mentioning was Simon and Kirby's Mainline comics - but those are soooo pricey.
suedenim
January 6, 2009 at 1:02 pm
Just from looking at the Vicki covers here, I get a bit of a feel for why Atlas-Seaboard failed:
http://comics.org/covers.lasso?SeriesID=13685
(I've become a minor connoisseur of third-tier teen humor titles starring blondes due to using them as fodder for my own "It's Cookie!" recaptioned stuff....)
The artwork is fine, but the first 3 cover gags are all weak, even for this sort of thing, with #1 being downright confusing in its layout. I can't see any reason why someone looking for this sort of comic would choose it instead of an Archie. Ditto when I look at most of their other covers and ponder the decision of a typical DC or Marvel buyer of the time.
Aqualad
January 6, 2009 at 2:26 pm
I've stopped buying new comics several times in my life, but have never stopped collecting. Why? Because every so often I will read a blog post like this one, or the one about the Archie Experiment of 89-90, and I will discover an entirely new reason to go rooting through convention bins.
Torsten Adair
January 6, 2009 at 2:57 pm
Collecting Disney comics gets painful/tedious post-Barks/pre-Gladstone. I know artists and writers were not hacks then, but some of that stuff is just BAD.
However, there are subsets which can be quite rewarding... Disney Showcase (their movie tie-in title) has wonderful photo covers and comicbook renditions of great celebrities (I've got a dogeared copy of "The Boatniks" with Phil Silvers, and a copy of "The Love Bug"). Huey, Dewey, and Louie Junior Woodchucks contains Barks stories (but not art), many of which were redrawn in the 1990s by Daan Jippes. (Look for the issue with HDL on the cover, and a bird has made a nest in the bugle. Flip to the back story, where Uncle Scrooge has an hallucigenic vision!) And then there are the Alex Toth Zorro comics, many of which have been collected in trade paperbacks. The Disney Comics of the 1990s, edited by Marv Wolfman do feature many writers not normally associated with Disney comics. The production values of those issues was pretty high.
Another short pre-Crisis run, which SCREAMS for a hardcover slipcased edition, is Witzend. However, the copyrights are a mess (Steve Ditko was a contributor). Apple Comics is another interesting publisher, as is Starblaze, and Pacific Comics. But I guess you could lump them in with the Black-and-White publishers pre-implosion, since they fall into the Pre-Crisis, Post-Direct Market time period, and this article deals more with titles which might appear on newsstands.
Michael
January 6, 2009 at 3:53 pm
I will forgive you for honoring the awesome that is Floyd Gottfredson.
Edo Bosnar
January 7, 2009 at 5:29 am
I'm not much of a collector, myself, but this is an interesting topic - and I have to say I'm surprised that no one has yet mentioned Pacific Comics. That should be a pretty easy collection to compile in terms of the limited output, although apparently the issues in the initial run of "Groo the Wanderer" are pretty hard to find, and probably a bit pricey as a result...
Blackjak
January 7, 2009 at 7:57 am
From "across the Pond" you could always pick up the complete run of Warrior too... Giving you the very first printings of both V for Vendetta and Miracleman!
Not to mention loads of other fun strips, like Axel Pressbutton and Zirk!
Complete runs show up quite regularly on eBay.
Jeremy A. Patterson
January 7, 2009 at 9:45 am
How about the 1980s Red Circle line: There are good books (with the occaisional crappy one thrown in) & it is easy to fill!
Or Victory Productions: There are only four titles (Shuriken, Phaze One, Komodo & The Defiants, and Shrike), & only 15 overall issues published, so that is a cheap run to fill (and it started in 1985)!
J.A.P.
Aqualad
January 7, 2009 at 11:51 am
Red Circle--weren't they the Archie heroes (Mighty Crusaders, etc)?
Jeremy A. Patterson
January 7, 2009 at 12:50 pm
Yes.
J.A.P.
John
January 8, 2009 at 10:03 pm
I need two books to complete my Pacific Comics collection: Groo #7 and something called 'One', which I am unfamiliar with, but which ComicBase states was the first Pacific title.
I thought that I was fairly close to completing a First Publishing collection, but after checking find that i still need 99 regular issues, 21 Classics Illustrateds and 4 OGNs (done in mostly by latter issues of Whisper, Lone Wolf & Cub and Mars and some of their latter stuff that no longer satisfied my tastes).
John