web stats

CBR Live! Archive

Couple of Fan Awards Open for Voting!

Here is a list of nominees for this year's Gylph Awards (honoring excellence in black comics).

In addition, here is where you can vote for the Fan Award for Best Comic of the year.

I dig the Glyph Awards. I should be a judge for 2010's competition!

The Comic Buyers Guide Fan Awards are also up!

Here is a list of nominees.

And here is where you can vote for the winners! The CBG Fan Awards are the longest-running comic book fan awards that I can think of - so please support it!

  • Posted on March 6, 2009 @ 06:39 PM

9 Comments

The selection for that Comic Buyers Guide award was really dreadful.

For most of those questions I was like "None of them!"

Yeah, I was initially ready to vote for CBG, but there really wasn't much reflective of my actual tastes in there, so I decided to abstain.

Man, I was thinking the same thing. I like some of the stuff, but none of it would be even close to my favorite of the year, except maybe Captain America for best series. I love George Perez and Sergio Aragones art, but have they really done anything this past year? And who the hell is Derf? Seems like it must be a pretty specific group of fans that did the nominations for those awards.

I don't understand those CBG nominations. Bad choices, indeed.

[...] So, after reading through the CBG Awards Ballot, I had the same reaction as commenter jazzbo* did in Cronin’s post linking to them: [...]

The nomination process must be rigged. It's the only answer.

It was fan voted nominations, as well. Of course, what I DON'T know is how many people voted on the nominations. It could be few enough that, like, a few dozen Derf fans could affect things.

And I'm pretty sure the Sinestro Corps War shipped entirely in 2007, so it shouldn't even be eligible for this list. Weird choices.

yeah the CBG awards... not a list of noms i would have selected but still fun to vote. the Glyphs fan award though... some of the best comics of the year were on that list!!! personally, i voted for War Machine, but Vixen and Young Avg Presents #1 were also super excellently AWESOME!!! and you gotta LOVE Afua's art in Genius. great stuff.

Leave a Comment

 

Subscribe to CSBG

Categories

Review Copies

Comics Should Be Good accepts review copies. Anything sent to us will (for better or for worse) end up reviewed on the blog. See where to send the review copies.

Browse the Archives