CBR Live! Archive
Scott's Classic Comics Corner: Out Of Print But Not Forgotten
These days, it seems as though there are enough trades on the market to fill the Library of Congressa. It’s a virtual paradise for classic comic junkies. A couple of decades ago, when Trade paperbacks were more of a rare beast, some real gems were published never seen again. This week’s column is a look at a handful of these collections that are worth tracking down.

Remember when every TPB published by DC started with the word “Greatest”? Remember how hokey you thought those were? Well, you were wrong and you should have picked up Greatest 1950s Stories Every Told when you had the chance. Are these truly the Greatest Stories of the 50s? Who’s to say? The one thing that I know for sure is that it is a wonderful representation of what DC was putting out in the 50s. What impresses the most about editor Mike Gold’s selections for this volume is the sheer variety. You’ve got plenty of solid superhero stuff but, since it was the 50s, there’s also a lot of great non-superhero stuff. You’ve got Alex Toth artwork on Johnny Thunder and Johnny Peril stories, Gil Kane drawing Nighthawk, an awesome King Faraday story with very nice Carmine Infantino artwork and lush Nick Cardy Congo Bill story. Did I mention Jack Kirby on Green Arrow, and unbelievably gorgeous Aquaman story by Ramona Fradon and a couple of Frank Frazettas as well? I could go on and on. This is like a comic book art textbook. Many of these stories had not been reprinted before, and may not be reprinted again. There are two solid introductions: one by Mike Gold and the other by Joe Kubert and any student of comic book history should find those to be interesting reads. The whole thing is dedicated to Robert Kanigher, which I thought was a nice touch. This is still pretty dirt cheap through eBay and other on-line sources.

Rio by Doug Wildey is a book that should be on everyone’s bookshelf. I’m saying this as someone who picked this up far too late in life (especially for a western fan). I stumble upon this book at a local used/remaindered bookstore. It was priced at $5.99 and I couldn’t pass up those gorgeous Wildey painted pages. Later, I discovered that it was a limited edition hardcover signed by the man himself. Sometimes you just get lucky. Why is this one worth tracking down? In my opinion, it represents the high watermark in the western genre and may be on of the best graphic novels ever published. The artwork is simultaneously lush and gritty. Wildey has very few peers with the paintbrush. This is 64 pages of comic book heaven. It was published in both hardcover and softcover, and there are still plenty of affordable copies floating around the marketplace. Subsequent Rio stories are also excellent, but never quite reached this level.

In the 1980s, Greg Theakson and Pure Imagination put out a series of Kirby-related books that must have thrilled Kirby fans. This 1987 volume highlights one of Simon and Kirby’s more obscure offerings from the 1940s, Stuntman. It a smallish package (only 52 pages), but it packs quite a punch. Personally, I really like the ‘look’ of this period of the Simon and Kirby partnership and their Harvey work was some of their strongest. It’s good, fun Golden Age action and the original issues are now prohibitively expensive (although I have a Stuntman story reprint via Black Cat #9). Also included is a previously unpublished Vagabond Prince story that I think was to be part of Boys Ranch. There also a decent interview with Jack and Joe. This one isn’t quite as easy to find these days, but it’s worth the search and you may still be able to find it at a decent price.

To paraphrase Alan Moore, this one is for the geek who has everything. While this book certainly doesn’t have the mass appeal of the Greatest 1950s Stories, it is not without its unique charm. In the 1960s, Charlton decided to base a comic book series on the less than awesome UK-produced King Kong rip-off, Konga. Somehow the Joe Gill and Steve Ditko managed to make some have decent lemonade out of this lemon. One would have thought that it would exist in a 1960s time capsule, sought after only by Ditko and Gorilla cover completists. Well, in the late 80s Robin Snyder decided that the world needed a little more Konga and put together this rather charming black and white package entitled The Lonely One, reprinting 4 Konga stories. I found one at the same bookstore as the Rio hardcover, and it was $7.99 well spent. There’s a nice little tribute to Gill and Ditko by the late Pat Boyette and a Ditko checklist at the back. When it was initially published, it would have served as a reminder of a slightly more innocent and goofier time. Now, it seems to exist as a piece of nostalgia in and of itself. If you see this one – grab it. You may not love it, but you’re not likely to find anything else quite like it.
If you love blogs that have zero aesthetic appeal and very slim content, then you’ll love my blog: Seduction of the Indifferent.
Also feel free to drop me a line at scottshouldbegood at yahoo.com
- Posted on March 10, 2009 @ 07:43 AM






17 Comments
Bill Reed
March 10, 2009 at 7:55 am
One day, people will search bins for cool old trades like these rather than for back issues.
Mike Loughlin
March 10, 2009 at 8:32 am
I have the '50s book, and it is as good as you say.
After reading the Doug Wildey story in Harlan Ellison's Dream Corridor, I couldn't believe I hadn't seen more by the guy. It was a beautifully rendered story. I'll have to keep an eye out for Rio.
jazzbo
March 10, 2009 at 8:40 am
Yep, the '50s book is fantastic. One of my favorite trades. The variety is great. The artwork is much more varied than I initially expected, since pretty much the only '50s comics I had seen were Sprang's Batman and Swan's Superman. The Aquaman story in particular was stunning. I was shocked at how great the art and coloring was in that story.
DubipR
March 10, 2009 at 8:44 am
Rio is a true gem. I picked one up at my friend's comic shop a few years back (softcover). Along with Blueberry, Rio was the part of the essential western comics to read. Another great column, Scott.
Rick Klaw
March 10, 2009 at 8:44 am
The Greatest 1950s Stories Every Told is a shockingly great read as is Wildey's Rio (one of the great comic book westerns). As an ape aficionado, I need to find The Lonely One. Thanks for the informative piece.
Aqualad
March 10, 2009 at 9:10 am
That day is today, Bill! My best finds at the last few conventions have been out-of-print trades.
Matt Bird
March 10, 2009 at 9:18 am
My all-time favorite out-of-print trade finds were Snyder's two volumes of Ditko's "Mr. A". A is A, baby! Now I have to track down that Konga volume, too! Thanks for another great column, Scott.
MarkAndrew
March 10, 2009 at 9:46 am
Speaking as a guy who likes those early sixties Charlon Monster comics more than is healthy (I voted for Reptisaurus in the Top 100 runs)
That Konga trade? I-M-P-O-S-S-I-B-L-E to find.
Agent_Torpor
March 10, 2009 at 11:02 am
"One day, people will search bins for cool old trades like these rather than for back issues."
And one day, we'll all jet off to work thanks to mini-rockets implanted firmly in our asses.
DanLarkin
March 10, 2009 at 11:54 am
The Greatest 50s stories is awesome. So many great artists in one package.
skfl
March 10, 2009 at 1:47 pm
here's hoping that some of these make their way back into print - particularly that 1950's collection.
Random Stranger
March 10, 2009 at 4:23 pm
I had not realized that there was a TPB of Stuntman. I suspect that may be reissued sooner or later, though.
benday-dot
March 10, 2009 at 5:58 pm
"I had not realized that there was a TPB of Stuntman. I suspect that may be reissued sooner or later, though."
The first volume of the new Simon and Kirby Library series, published by Titan, and due this summer, will feature some Stuntman material (not sure as to the extant of it, though only 3 issues were actually published).
Jack Norris
March 10, 2009 at 6:04 pm
Agent Torpor:
Yeah, that was totally called for, and you're not a dick or anything.
John Trumbull
March 10, 2009 at 9:27 pm
Rio really is a spectacular read. Doug Wildey was one of the great underrated artists of comics.
Zack Smith
March 10, 2009 at 11:09 pm
The Greatest Golden Age Stories Ever Told is perhaps the cream of the crop for DC collections, and was never very easy to find. That said, you can find hardcovers on eBay for about $20.
The various "From the '30s to the '70s" collections were absolutely fantastic, despite some mixed results with, well, the 1970s tales. But all of them are great -- the Shazam! one is hardest to find, but it's a great representation of some amazing stories. The Batman one was a huge influence on Morrison's run.
The Private Files of the Shadow collects Michael William Kaluta's gorgeous stories, and is well worth hunting for.
I think they brought this back into print a while back, but Archie Goodwin and Walt Simonson's adaptation of the original Alien is a good read.
So is Stephen Bissette and Rick Vetich's adaptation of Stephen Spielberg's megaflop 1941, which is better than the movie.
Of course the finest collection of all time is Uncle Scrooge McDuck: His LIfe and Times, a gorgeous retrospective of Carl Barks' stories featuring amazing colors and commentary from Barks himself. Also recommended is Gladstone's Uncle Scrooge in Color, featuring several key historical stories, some rarities, and an in-depth essay on Scrooge's characterization. I ate it up as a kid.
Rob Ocelot
March 11, 2009 at 10:39 pm
Rio is excellent and Rio Rides Again is no slouch either.
I'd really like to see an article on Chaykin's GN version of The Stars My Destination. The original version was only half published and the Epic softcover version that prints the whole story is quite difficult to find these days.
Has anyone ever come across the original printing of The Cowboy Wally Show from Doubleday that was intended for the bookstore market? TCBWS was notoriously out of print for more than a decade.
Steranko:Graphic Narrative is worth tracking down if you are a fan of the man and his work (hey, who isnt?)