web stats

CBR Live! Archive

What I bought - 13 May 2009

There are a bunch o' books below the jump, and for some reason, the beginning of the alphabet gets the shaft this time around. Plus, a treat for all of those people (probably everyone reading this) who think I have horrible musical taste. Dare you read on? DARE YOU?!?!?!?!???!?!?! There's a hint below!


Yeah, that's right, monkey boys. Bwah-ha-ha-ha!!!!!!

Captain Britain and MI 13 #13 ("Vampire State Part Three") by Paul Cornell (writer), Ardian Syaf (penciler), Leonard Kirk (penciler), Craig Yeung (inker), Jay Leisten (inker), Brian Reber (colorist), and Joe Caramagna (letterer). $2.99, 22 pgs, FC, Marvel.

Cornell continues to blow the doors off most of the Big Two titles, as he shows how a vampire invasion ought to be done, as the vampires have centuries to plan, so why wouldn't they plan for every single contigency? We saw last issue that they solved the problem of not being able to get into Britain, and now they strike, quickly and mercilessly. Obviously, I don't believe for a second that the people who get killed in this issue are actually dead, but Cornell has done such a good job with this that it's still shocking when it happens (and, as none of them are "big" characters, I suppose some of them could actually be dead). As it's in the middle of the story arc, this is when things look the bleakest, and next issue, "We fight back!", and even though that's the standard form for this sort of story, the cleverness with which Cornell has written it so far is appreciated. Dracula didn't come in with brute force, and it makes his victory all the more interesting. There are several ways Cornell could go with this, and I'm looking forward to seeing how he gets our heroes out of the pickle.

And here's a question for people who read more Marvel books than I do: Who are the "real Avengers" that include Wanda and are led by Henry Pym. We have the Dark Avengers and the New Avengers - is this the current Mighty Avengers team? So many Avengers ... makes Greg's head ... hurt!

WHICH ABBA SONG IS THIS COMIC? Easy. "Under Attack."

Elephantmen #19 ("Dangerous Liaisons Four of Eight: Sahara") by Richard Starkings (writer) and Marian Churchland (artist). $3.50, 25 pgs, FC, Image.

The always-awesome Richard Starkings sent this on to me, and I always appreciate it. This is, of course, one of my favorite series, and I always feel like I'm stealing from him because I never pay for it!

The series-within-a-series-within-a-series continues, as Starkings looks at the three significant women in the Elephantmen book as part of the eight-part "Dangerous Liaisons" arc, this time focusing on Sahara, Obadiah Horn's consort. When last we saw Sahara, she had been confronted by her father, Serengheti, at the hospital where Tusk was being held. Somehow Sahara escaped, and in this issue, we find out how. Starkings zips back and forth between the showdown in the hospital and Sahara's early life, as we learn more about her and the forces that shaped her. In some ways, it's a bit clichéd (she's whored out by her father to his soldiers) and even a tiny bit anachronistic (I suppose tribes might still be practicing female circumcision 200 years in the future, but it's a very contemporary event in the book), but it's still a nice "origin" story, in that Sahara learns a valuable lesson that serves her well and that she passes on to her father. It's also interesting in that Sahara is not just Obadiah's lover because he's, you know, well endowed, as she shows the empathy she has for all the transgenics, and Starkings shows us why. As has been the case with the last few issues of the comic, it's a quieter issue, but it's still a powerful chapter in the ongoing saga.

As I wrote last issue, Churchland is a good choice for these kinds of stories, as her almost ethereal art fits well with the flashbacks to the savanna and the sterile atmosphere of the hospital. It's a nice contrast to the oppressive atmosphere we've seen in the noir-ish art the title usually features.

And so another fine issue of Elephantmen comes out. I like how the "real" cover (above is the flip-cover) is a drawing Ian Churchill did of Sahara in 2005. Starkings never throws anything away!

WHICH ABBA SONG IS THIS COMIC? Sahara standing up to her father after the abuse she's been through is reminiscent of "Eagle." She doesn't let him drag her down!

Fables #84 ("The Great Fables Crossover Part 4 of 9: Jack's Back") by Bill Willingham (writer), Matthew Sturges (writer), Tony Akins (penciller), Andrew Pepoy (inker), Dan Green (inker), Lee Loughridge (colorist), and Todd Klein (letterer). $2.99, 22 pgs, FC, DC/Vertigo.

It's nice to be reminded why I stopped reading Jack of Fables: I absolutely hate Jack. I'm not sure if Willingham and Sturges love writing him and therefore allow him to dominate any book he's in, but I hate him. I guess it's a testament to how well he's been conceived, but that also means I have no desire to read a book in which he is the star. He's the star in this book, and he's typically dickish. I get that some people would be fooled by him, but why doesn't the Beast, for instance, arrest him like he says he's going to? Is he that flabbergasted by Jack taking over (which it seems) that he's stunned into silence? The best parts of the book are when Beauty, Beast, and King Cole visit Frau Totenkinder, and when Rose Red yells at Jack, as she reveals some interesting truths and some nice depth to her character. Otherwise, it's just Jack being a dick. I can deal with it for a few issues, but it's good to see that there's no reason for me to pick up his own title after the crossover is over.

WHICH ABBA SONG IS THIS COMIC? Jack gets the ladies even though he's a tool. "Angeleyes" it is!

Secret Six #9 ("A Debt of Significant Blood") by Gail Simone (writer), Nicola Scott (penciller), Doug Hazlewood (inker), Jason Wright (colorist), and Travis Lanham (letterer). $2.99, 22 pgs, FC, DC.

Boy, thank God this isn't really a "Battle for the Cowl" tie-in and is just slapped on here to, presumably, goose sales a bit. I mean, it takes place in Gotham, and Catman, Bane, and Ragdoll debate the merits of being heroes and of taking over for Batman, but it's not really a tie-in. And that's perfectly fine.

Simone knocks another issue out of the park, mainly because Ragdoll is freakin' hilarious. Oh, sure, Catman and Bane rescuing kids from being kidnapped because Bane has an issue with kids being hurt is a fine story that allows our "heroes" to be heroic without really being heroic, and the fact that Bane snaps people's spines is nicely parodied by Simone, as one of the bad guys actually begs Bane not to do it, and there's that great visual that hearkens back to Adam West and Burt Ward climbing a building (had I been drinking when I saw the panel, the liquid would have come out of my nose), but Ragdoll steals the issue cleanly, from the moment he shows up ... dressed as Robin ... saying, "Never fear, old chum! The He/She Wonder is on the case! Holy Capital Punishment or some such!" It becomes a riotous comedy routine, but then Simone manages to make a couple of excellent points, one about the Bat-people (notably Nightwing, who shows up at the end) and their sanctimony, the other about Catman's relationship to said Bat-people. Simone is getting better on this title, mainly because she is delving nicely into the characters, and even though the first arc was brilliant for the MacGuffin, what will sustain this book (I hope, although sales are poor) is the nice characterization and interaction between them.

Plus, there's a beefcake shot of Nightwing that I really, really hope is a parody of all the inexplicable ass-shots of women we see in comics. I can't imagine it's not. But hey! ladies (and guys, I suppose, if that's your way) - check out Dick's butt!

WHICH ABBA SONG IS THIS COMIC? Those "Super Trouper" lights are going to find the bad guys!

Secret Warriors #4 by Brian Michael Bendis (storier), Jonathan Hickman (storier/scripter), Stefano Caselli (artist), Danielle Rudoni (colorist), and Dave Lanphear (letterer). $2.99, 23 pgs, FC, Marvel.

Keen observers of the blog might recall that I haven't actually reviewed issues #1-3 of Secret Warriors, yet here I am reviewing issue #4. "What's up with that, Burgas?" they might ask. "Are you some kind of punk?" Well, I very well may be, but not because of this. Secret Warriors #1 sold out rather quickly, and while I wasn't terribly interested in it when it came out, reviews convinced me I might want to check it out. So I had to wait until the second (or possibly third) printing showed up, and for my store to get re-orders on the other two issues, so I just read the first three issues about a week ago. But now issue #4 is out, and I can write about that! Won't that be fun?

Hickman has done a nice job so far with shocking revelations about S.H.I.E.L.D. that seem to fit easily into Marvel history, and he's done a fairly good job with the relatively unknown characters that make up Nick Fury's team. They're still ciphers to a degree, but we're getting to know them, and it's interesting to see what Hickman is doing with them. In this issue, Nick gathers ex-S.H.I.E.L.D. agents to join his cause, which leads to uncomfortable discussions about killing their old comrades who have taken jobs with H.A.M.M.E.R. Hickman writes a good hard-ass Fury, somewhat reminiscent of Ennis's Fury - a war-weary vet who's nevertheless ready to get the job done because wusses have taken over. It's a good version of Fury, and it's nice to see Hickman writing him well. Plus, he has a good handle on the weird mysteries going on, doling out a little at a time (this issue shows us something a bit disturbing about Fury) and whetting our appetite for more.

I do have a few questions about Eden Fesi, the aborigine who Sebastian and Daisy are looking for. I know very little about aborigines, but whenever I've seen them in "real life" and not in Hollywood movies, they dress, well, normally. Is there a reason Eden Fesi is almost naked and has paint all over his body? It doesn't appear, when they reach his camp, that he's in the middle of a ceremony or anything that would require it, so does he just hang out like that? Second, when he's talking about his life, he says, "There's a six letter word keeping me from being what I want to be. You know what that word is? Diaper." And he holds his shorts. Then he launches into a rant about wanting to play guitar. What the hell? Why does he say "Diaper"? Does he mean Gateway still thinks he's a baby and won't let him live life like he wants? That's what I got from it, but I could be wrong. He simply moves on without explaining it, so does that seem the most likely reason for saying it? Anyone have any other reasons?

Anyway, I'm glad I picked this book up. Although, like noted wit Chad Nevett, I also wish the book was called Nick Fury: Agent of Nothing. I suppose it's not just Nick's book, and it's kind of dealing with Secret Invasion, but Agent of Nothing is such a cooler title I can't believe Marvel didn't call it that. If Secret Warriors helps it sell more, I guess it's okay, but still.

WHICH ABBA SONG IS THIS COMIC? Nick Fury disavowed? How about "The King Has Lost His Crown"?

Soul Kiss #4 (of 5) ("Come Alive") by Steven T. Seagle (writer) and Marco Cinello (artist). $3.50, 23 pgs, FC, Image.

Lili continues to slaughter her way through the story, but at least the cops are a bit interested in her (she's a serial killer, after all), until the Devil makes that go away as well (a freebie, he tells her). Of course, one of her kisses lands on someone she didn't intend to kill, but that's the way it is, right? Seagle ends the issue with a twist that we could see coming (a bit), but it's still a nice way to set up the final chapter. It's hard to say much else about this series, except that the hints Seagle has been dropping about Lili's relationship were kind of evident from the beginning, not because of anything that was written, but just because that seems to be the way these things go. I know I'm being very oblique, but I kind of have to be. Anyway, we'll see next time how it all ends. Cinello, as usual, does a fine job with the art.

WHICH ABBA SONG IS THIS COMIC? You would think "Kisses of Fire" fits, but it fits better for a comic below! Let's go with irony: "Lovers (Live a Little Longer)."

Storming Paradise #5 (of 6) by Chuck Dixon (writer), Rick Burchett (penciler), Jackson Guice (inker), Darlene Royer (colorist), and Patrick Brosseau (letterer). $2.99, 22 pgs, FC, DC/Wildstorm.

It's been many months since the previous issue of this series came out, and in the meantime, Guice bailed on the pencilling duties, although Burchett is a fine replacement (and Guice inks him, so the art style doesn't change too much). But at this point, this series has lost any momentum it might have had, and although I'm still mildly interested in it, I think I'll hold off writing about it until it finishes. I will say that it seems like Dixon had a pretty good four-issue mini-series here, and it feels a bit padded to fill out six issues. Oh well.

WHICH ABBA SONG IS THIS COMIC? It's a war comic. How about "Soldiers"?

The Umbrella Academy: Dallas #6 (of 6) ("The World is Big Enough Without You") by Gerard Way (writer), Gabriel Bá (artist), Dave Stewart (colorist), Nate Piekos (letterer). $2.99, 24 pgs, FC, Dark Horse.

The way Dark Horse lists this comic is strange. On the cover, the number 6 appears, and there's nothing on it that indicates it's the second mini-series, as the subtitle ("Dallas") does not appear. On the inside cover, the indicia claims it's "NUMBER 12 IN A SERIES," which is true to a certain degree, but that's kind of misleading. I don't really care, I just happened to notice the small print. It's what I do, man!

Way has, once again, done a fine job getting all the plot points into line so that the ending of issue #4 makes sense and the way the mission is accomplished is quite brilliant. If you've read this blog before, you know that time travel stories, as a rule, make my head hurt (even if I like them), so the fact that Way manages it with only a modicum of head-hurtiness is appreciated. What's great about this comic, as with many very good books, is the ancillary stuff. Sure, the mission is interesting, but the way the "siblings" react to each other and some of the more low-key revelations are what make the book. Well, that and Bá's excellent art. Number Five's crazed look is particularly well done - it's angry, but tragic as well. Way has done a good job with the stories, but Bá adds a lot of depth to them. Would Spaceboy be as tragic a figure if Bá didn't make him so grotesque? I doubt it.

Both writer and artist are particularly busy these days, as the letter column tells us, so although they've promised "Series Three," I have a feeling this might go the way of Casanova - you know, on "permanent hiatus." Way, at least, doesn't seem interested in writing for the Big Two (he does have the musical career, after all), so maybe that means we will actually see another mini-series. That would be nice.

WHICH ABBA SONG IS THIS COMIC? I'm not sure why "Cassandra" fits, but it does.

The Unknown #1 (of 4) by Mark Waid (writer), Minck Oosterveer (artist), Fellipe Martins (colorist), and Marshall Dillon (letterer). $3.99, 22 pgs, FC, Boom! Studios.

I already reviewed this (and the comic beneath this), so I'll just leave it at that. I will say that I was speaking to Mark Waid on Wednesday (look at me, dropping names all over the place!), and he did confirm that Minck Oosterveer is, indeed, an "international superstar." Check out his web site if you don't believe me!

WHICH ABBA SONG IS THIS COMIC? Our Swedish friends don't sing about private investigators, but "I Am the City" is about omniscience, so there you have it!

Unthinkable #1 (of 5) by Mark Sable (writer), Julian Totino Tedesco (artist), Juan Manuel Tumburús (colorist), and Ed Dukeshire (letterer). $3.99, 22 pgs, FC, Boom! Studios.

s1rude wondered if these two books were 4 dollars. Yes, it's too bad that they are. Still, I'd rather read either one of these before I read, say, Dark Avengers. I know I'm in the minority, but still.

Oh, and Kristian Donaldson needs more work. That's a cool cover.

WHICH ABBA SONG IS THIS COMIC? "On and On and On" isn't a perfect fit, but it has a good paranoid vibe.

The Unwritten #1 ("Tommy Taylor and the Bogus Identity") by Mike Carey (writer), Peter Gross (artist), Chris Chuckry (colorist), and Todd Klein (letterer). $1.00, 33 pgs, FC, DC/Vertigo.

Vertigo's new policy of offering the first issues of their series for a buck and giving the reader extra pages is a no-brainer, I would think. I don't know if it will lead to more people trying the series and therefore sticking around, thereby saving it the fate of, say, Young Liars, but why wouldn't the Big Two do this more often? What do you have to lose, except one thin dollar? But that's just me.

Of course, it would help if the books are good. The Unwritten has a ton of potential, so that's nice. If you've read any Vertigo books over the past few months, you know the premise - Tom Taylor's father wrote a series of books starring Tommy Taylor, a Harry Potter-esque wizard, and the theory is that he based the character roughly on his son. His father disappeared, and now Tom spends his time signing autographs at conventions. At one such event, a young lady questions his very existence, as things don't seem to add up in his past, and Tom is swept into a world where his business manager is working against him, the fictional nemesis from the books kidnaps him, and people worldwide believe that he's actually "Tommy," not Tom. It's a nicely constructed first issue, giving us plenty of information but leaving enough out and setting up the longer story. Gross is great, as usual, and Carey once again proves that when's not trying to reconcile every single aspect of X-Men continuity, he can tell a nice rip-roaring tale. There's a lot going on in this issue, and what's keen about it is that we can anticipate that some things will turn out to be red herrings, but we can't figure out what. It adds a nice mystery to the proceedings even if it seems that Carey is showing all his cards.

I honestly have no idea why you wouldn't pick this up, just to check it out. Is it really that important to buy the latest issue of Booster Gold?

WHICH ABBA SONG IS THIS COMIC? It's a first issue for a buck! That screams "Take a Chance on Me"!

X-Factor #43 ("Timely Events") by Peter David (writer), Marco Santucci (artist), Valentine de Landro (penciler), Pat Davidson (inker), Patrick Piazzalunga (inker), Jeromy Cox (colorist), and Cory Petit (letterer). $2.99, 22 pgs, FC, Marvel.

This comic totally freaked me out. Nothing about the actual issue (which is, unsurprisingly, another solid one of this eminently solid series) freaked me out, though. No, it was the recap page that did it. Last month, I wrote that it seemed David was a bit grumpy when he wrote the fake "what-happens-next" blurb in the recap. In this issue, that's specifically addressed, as David (presumably it's him, although it's in the third person) writes that he wasn't in a bad mood at all. I know David reads the blog occasionally (he commented on my last post about The Incredible Hulk, after all), so I presume this was directed, at least partially, at me. I suppose some other people might have made that observation as well, but does any reviewer nitpick as much as I do? I THINK NOT! Even if it wasn't addressing me, it still freaked me out.

"But what of the issue?" you scream. "Why are two people mackin' on the cover? What happened with Longshot and his client?" Well, as usual, David keeps several plates spinning, with Madrox's story arc in the future still feeling like the main plate. That's him on the cover, by the way (in case the tattoo didn't give it away), making out with ... well, I won't tell you, but it's easy to guess, as David has hinted about it for a while now. He's in the future because, apparently, he's the only detective in the space-time continuum who can solve a case for Cyclops (Hercule Poirot wasn't available?), so that should be fun. Meanwhile, the client whom Longshot was protecting and who was shot by her mother last issue is rescued, but then the gang has to figure out why her mother was shooting at her. Finally, Rictor and Guido visit Reverend Maddox, who begins to tell them what happened to Jamie when they're attacked. I won't give away by whom they're attacked, except to say ... really, Mr. David? Really? If this had happened in X-Force and it was Kyle and Yost writing it, I'd laugh and ditch the book. But I trust David just a bit more. Still. Really?

WHICH ABBA SONG IS THIS COMIC? This is easy: "Kisses of Fire." Sing along with me - "Kisses of fire, burning, burning, I'm at the point of no returning ..."

Young Liars #15 ("Imposter! Imposter!") by David Lapham (writer/artist), Lee Loughridge (colorist), and Jared K. Fletcher (letterer). $2.99, 22 pgs, FC, DC/Vertigo.

I always get this way when I comic I read is cancelled but the issues are still coming out. Who cares, right? You had your chance. Oh well.

Still, Lapham continues to dazzle with the book. I mean, just when you think the gang's back together again and things are back on track, two horrible things happen and everything is back to shit. Then, there's a HOLY SHIT! moment that doesn't even end the book. No, Lapham has to leave someone bleeding to death in the desert just to hit us with one more twist, an ending that makes no sense ... unless it occurs in Young Liars, in which case it makes perfect sense. Damn, I'm going to miss this comic.

When Mr. Nevett announced that this was cancelled, a lot of people wondered about Stray Bullets and whether Lapham will go back to that ("probably not" was the feeling, as he makes no money doing it). Here's my question: Can't Vertigo publish Stray Bullets? I mean, Lapham owns it, and it couldn't do any worse than Young Liars did, could it? This would allow them to reprint the trades, make some coin, and give Lapham space to finish. Especially now that they're doing these "crime graphic novels" - why not let him wrap the story up with one or two of those? I don't know how much else he has planned for it (and I haven't even caught up on the trades), but why wouldn't that work? I'm sure there's a reason (DC doesn't want to pick up a series 40 issues or so in?), but it seems like, if they like Lapham, that's a solution. Oh well. Sometimes life sucks and Deadpool gets an ongoing and a bunch of mini-series. C'est la vie.

WHICH ABBA SONG IS THIS COMIC? A few come to mind, but as the book is cancelled, let's go with "When All Is Said and Done," shall we?

Zorro #13 by Matt Wagner (writer), Cezar Razek (artist), Salvatore Aiala (colorist), and Simon Bowland (letterer). $3.50, 22 pgs, FC, Dynamite Entertainment.

As old-fashioned adventures go, this is humming right along. The major's plan to use a fake Zorro to menace Lolita is put in play, while the real Zorro pays a visit to the major and the two fight it out, Errol Flynn-and-John Barrymore style! Zorro can't stick around, however, because he has a señorita to save! Oh, there's a showdown a-coming!

The quality of book notwithstanding, there's a nit I always have to pick (didn't you read what I wrote in the X-Factor review?). I've mentioned it before, but it always bothers me that every single female in historical fiction is an independent-minded feminist decades before feminism. It's not really that I want to see women in historical fiction be all subservient, because that's kind of boring, but it's frustrating because it's so very untrue and it makes the character simply less believable. Even great female authors writing contemporary fiction didn't make their heroines all that independent. Yes, the women of Jane Austen or the Brontë sisters are probably more independent than real women were at the time, but even they conform to social customs and are more deferential than is comfortable to a modern audience. When writers don't even try to look at the customs of the day and simply make their female characters "spirited" simply because their fathers wanted a boy and raised them as such (as is the case in this comic), it feels off. I certainly don't want Lolita to be a shrinking violet who does whatever the man in her life tells her to, but I want to at least believe she's living in the early- to mid-1800s. When she says something like "I want to love the man that I marry," it goes against almost everything we know about a staunchly conservative, devoutly Catholic, practically still-feudal society like Spain's (and, by extension, California's). Even her father, who raised her like a boy, wouldn't have instilled that notion in her mind. The concept probably wouldn't have ever entered Lolita's head. Again, I get that it's fiction, but it's kind of frustrating. Of course, that could be just me. Heap your scorn upon me!

WHICH ABBA SONG IS THIS COMIC? Spaniards in the New World and a military presence? It could only be ... "Fernando"!

In an effort to show how cool I am after last week's totally random lyrics (so sue me; I like Billy Joel) and this week's linking of comics to a Swedish supergroup, let's check out totally random lyrics from, I hope, a band that meets with your approval!

"When you're shipwrecked on your mattress I'll come in and show you how
To hijack the past and wind up in the right now
Grab some clothes, three chords and a video camera
Maybe a mic, some handwipes, a typewriter, and a hammer
'X' out all self-supervision
Get your keys out now start the ignition"

How's that?

  • Posted on May 15, 2009 @ 03:16 PM

45 Comments

My laugh-out-loud moment while reading Secret Six:
Ragdoll: "I would be an excellent Robin, if I may just get that in. I like the outfit, and I am not averse to a crowbar to the cranium now and then."

Yes, those are the Mighty Avengers. But that's not really the Scarlet Witch.

I totally agree with you Greg about the unfairness of having Dark Avengers one of the highest selling comics right now, but not about Deadpool.

His ongoing has been pretty entertaining (which surprised me since it's written by Daniel Way) and his mini-series has been good so far. But I also love the Punisher so I know we don't have the same tastes in characters :-)

Also, I read an article on this site where David Lapham talked about a new series he has coming out called Spartan USA. I don't know what he has planned besides that

Oh, and I do buy Booster Gold but that series has been sucking for a while so I think I'll drop it

Dude: I don't have any problem with Deadpool per se (I enjoyed the one-shot that came out a few months ago), but he's approaching Wolverine- or Bendis-level overload. Yes, I know he's in the movie, but sheesh!

Greg--this plan is not as crazy as you might think:

I quit reading Elephantmen around War Toys for financial reasons. (In fact, I canceled my pull list and don't keep current with any new series, so it's not just Elephantmen :( ). It was very good, and I would love to keep up. My proposal: I will buy Elephantmen each month, and you send me $1.50. You are assuaged of guilt, I get to follow this awesome comic, Richard Starkings gets his cut of three dollars, and Elephantmen sells another copy, helping its continued survival. Eh?

I bought The Unwritten because I was in a comic shop and saw, "Oh, there's a new Vertigo book that's 40 pages for a buck? That's definitely worth checking out!" Sounds like a success where I'm concerned. The free #1 issues at vertigobooks.com have caused me to spend money on their other titles, but you have to be actually holding a DC books to know that's an option. This is effectually the LCS equivalent of that.

A few other things:

I know Dark Horse numbers Hellboy & B.P.R.D. as "x in a series," so I don't think it's that odd an inclusion if other minis are planned. Perhaps some business decision was made before this issue was released.

Casanova is on indefinite hiatus, but that's not as dire as it sounds (I usually take 'indefinite hiatus' to mean 'never, never, never!). Fraction is writing the third volume now, so it presumably will be released, maybe not even that far away!

Your solution to getting more Stray Bullets sounds wonderful! I hope someone takes note. As for picking it up 40 issues in, so what? Put out a few trades and give it a new number one or hype the hell out of new OGN releases.

Can’t Vertigo publish Stray Bullets? I mean, Lapham owns it, and it couldn’t do any worse than Young Liars did, could it? This would allow them to reprint the trades, make some coin, and give Lapham space to finish.

Here's Lapham on the topic...

The most obvious benefit of self-publishing—or small press, which is what we were. I didn’t do any of the publishing—is that you’re master of your own destiny. No one can tell you squat, and you certainly can’t cancel yourself. Even with Stray Bullets. Yes, for various life reasons I’ve had to stop. But I’m not buried under layers of red tape. Well, there’s no book coming out, so isn’t it the same thing? Well, no, it’s not. And if I can get SB going again you’ll find out why. A lot of people ask “Why not bring Stray Bullets to Vertigo?” Well, this is why. Nothing against them. They’re a big company. They have no obligation to keep publishing a book if they’re losing money. So if SB didn’t sell (strangely, though, I do think SB would do better than YL simply for the fact that it’s more straightforward than YL) and it’s canceled, then where am I? Yes, technically I would own the copyright but there’s a lot of untangling there. Jesus, I’m going on. Look it’s not impossible, but maybe I’m just more paranoid than other people. Stay tuned…

"It’s nice to be reminded why I stopped reading Jack of Fables: I absolutely hate Jack. ... He’s the star in this book, and he’s typically dickish."

No, he's an incompetent, arrogant @$$hole. Jack of Fables will never sell as well as Fables. And a constant diet of Jack in Fables would drive sales down, but I like both series.

I think Secret Six is easily the best book of the week.

Month after month, X-Factor is the best written X-book.

Omar Karindu, with the power of SUPER-hypocrisy!

May 15, 2009 at 6:26 pm

One of the odder things about Secret Warriors is that the super-powers angle and the kids are being played down heavily for the most part. Instead, it's focusing on the very mortal world of intelligence and dirty wars and conspiracies where crazy and flashy super-abilities seem like a drawback.

I'm still not really sure what the big idea behind the "caterpillars" is. It's a reasonable consequence of a world of crazy superpeople running around, I suppose, but it's not much more than that -- a fan-wank sort of consequence. (Bendis has done this before -- the Secret War mini that started this whole shebang was another one of those attempts to answer the question of where hundred-time loser villains keep getting billion-dollar gadgets, and it didn't really amount to much. Anyone here even remember Lucia von Bardas?)

And I'm likewise skeptical about the decision to rethink HYDRA as not only secretly running SHIELD, but also as some sort of ancient conspiracy with roots in ancient Greece. The back matter of issue #1 and a caption or two since have intimated this in so many words. It's always been a perfectly serviceable stand-in for whatever the subversive or terrorist fears of the day have been. I suppose making it an ancient cult could conceivably tie into the idea of religiously-motivated terrorism, but it's a rather strained fit...and an absurd one if HYDRA is a Greco-Roman menace. But then one might have to ask why its leaders include a Nazi fugitive, a Japanese mutant Satanist, and an Eastern European nihilist with a penchant for green hair dye, hardly a unified ideological front and as far from religion as one might imagine.

The book has been really fun so far, and Fury is a compelling character, a soldier without a country and an ambivalent -- at best -- notion of what to fight for in its absence. But the longer-term plot directions being set up are worrisome, to say the least. If it were just international intrigue with Nick Fury as a thrice-burned, post-ideological anti-hero, it'd be a title I could unreservedly commit to.

I guess I just don't trust them not to eff it up, because next to all the fun stuff on an issue-by-issue reading, warning signs keep appearing.

I did pick up Unwritten #1, on the recommendation of this and other comic blogs, but I won't bother with #2. I always found the Harry Potter books to be the most appallingly derivative tripe, like Enid Blyton trying to rewrite Books of Magic without benefit of editor. Well sorry, but Tommy Taylor is utterly 100% derivative of Harry Potter. Plagiarism squared! I guess if you like HP (and I can't imagine how anyone could, but clearly a large number of people have a blind spot about good writing and interesting plots when Ms Rowling is involved) then it might not give you the screaming irrits, but in my case I found it completely intolerable. The last time I wanted to throw a book against the wall this much, it was Heinlein's Number Of The Beast. It's that bad.

The latest Booster Gold, on the other hand, was a good read.

"Well sorry, but Tommy Taylor is utterly 100% derivative of Harry Potter."

Just from reading the synopsis, it seems like that's pretty much the central premise of the series. You might as well be revealing pro wrestling's dark secret... it's all fake! Spread the word, the world must know!

Dude: I don’t have any problem with Deadpool per se (I enjoyed the one-shot that came out a few months ago), but he’s approaching Wolverine- or Bendis-level overload. Yes, I know he’s in the movie, but sheesh!

I agree wholeheartedly with that sentiment.

However, if Marvel is intent on expanding the Deadpool brand ad infinitum, I would absolutely buy a Dark Deadpool series, featuring Taskmaster in Wade Wilson drag. Maybe he could take on some twisted version of his own crime academy (isn't The Hood doing something similar now, rehabilitating third-rung villains?) or something. I dunno. Whatever's good. As long as it means more Taskmaster.

Mark Temporis

May 15, 2009 at 10:35 pm

I think they've been setting up the SHIELD/HYDRA angle for some time. I'd noted back during CIVIL WAR that the two agencies symbols are VERY similar. Try color-reversing one for a better look.

Andrew Collins

May 15, 2009 at 11:31 pm

Secret Six was hysterical, especially after Doll realizes that no matter what he says, it still comes out kinda creepy and suggestive. Comedy gold.

I agree with Alan Coil above, Secret Six was by far the best issue of this month, but X-Factor is the best month in and month out. It goes right to the top of my reading pile every time a new issue comes out. Kudos to Mr. David and his artists...

It's funny you mention Casanova in conjunction with Umbrella Academy, because I've actually had a few discussions with my friends comparing early Umbrella Academy to early Casanova where we basically concluded that Way's current output represents the level Fraction could be writing at if he wasn't focusing on his mediocre rehashes of licensed properties instead of creator owned stuff that displays some "originality" (I say this fully aware that Umbrella Academy is the modern equivalent of the Morrison Doom Patrol and Casanova is basically just Jerry Cornelius revamped for the 21st century).

I mean, Way could definitely be working on another emo-punk album, sure, but even The Black Parade is a better guilty pleasure than anything Fraction is currently writing. At least I'll listen to "Mama" when I'm drunk. You couldn't pay me to read Invincible Iron Man at this point.

Greg, it could be argued that the depiction of Eden Fesi is similar to what's worn in a ceremonial capacity, i.e at a corrobore, but Yeh its not worn every day. It would be like presenting a Native American in a large feather headress.

One thing I know for certain though, is that even in this MTV Americanised world, no Aussie would NEVER ever say "Diaper" In Australia that is known as a Nappy.

@ Dave: I agree that Invincible Iron Man has been mediocre, but I put the blame on the artist more than on Fraction. As for comparing the Umbrella Academy to Morrison's Doom Patrol,well... let's not exagerate. It's good but not THAT good.

@Greg: I forgot to congratulate you on the Abba theme this week. Is there anything that their music doesn't make better?:-) As for Deadpool in the Wolverine movie, let's not even talk about it. My soul died a little when I saw it

Rohan Williams

May 16, 2009 at 5:41 am

I don't know if Umbrella Academy is as good as Doom Patrol, but yeah, it definitely wears its influences on its sleeve. The concept is pretty blatant - 'what if Grant Morrison wrote The Royal Tenenbaums?' - and I love it for that.

Greg, as I recall from Fables, the reason that Beast couldn't arrest Jack [spoilers for anyone who cares] was that Jack was claiming to speak for Boy Blue, and the farm animals would revolt if their leader was arrested. I could be wrong.

That's been the enjoyable part of reading Jack of Fables. He's a horrible horrible person, but things kind of work out for him. Although, he did nail his 3 half sisters. I don't know if there's a way to come back from that.

Dan: I don't know if I feel THAT guilty! Let me think about it.

Omar: Yeah, while I like the revelation about Hydra running S.H.I.E.L.D., I'm not sure about the cult thing going back thousands of years. We'll see about that. I liked the first part of the idea more than that part.

Eric: That's cool if you feel that way, but the point is - you didn't have to spend a ton of money to find out.

Jax: Dang, I should have caught the fact that Eden would have said "nappy." I don't know, if I were writing people from other cultures, I'd be so terrified of making a mistake that I'd be sure to check up on things. Doesn't anyone at Marvel know any Aussies?

Dude: No, there isn't anything ABBA can't make better!

“Well sorry, but Tommy Taylor is utterly 100% derivative of Harry Potter.”

That's missing the forest for the trees. And that's 100% not the point of the story. It's about how stories inform reality, and vice versa, literary geography, probably about an author who abandons his character, etc.

Obviously, the Tommy Taylor books are a pastiche on Harry Potter. But that's background to the main story which has it's own direction, purpose, and themes. It's certainly not about a boy wizard growing up.

It's true. Everything looks better in comparison to ABBA.

Omar Karindu, with the power of SUPER-hypocrisy!

May 16, 2009 at 9:58 am

I'm still not 100% sure of the HYDRA-ran-SHIELD argument either...is the idea that Fury was still so talented that he wa able to take HYDRA down a few times despite that, or are we getting some kind of insane retcon that HYDRA allowed him to do things like kill Strucker and blow up their headquarters twice over for some deeper purpose?

I'm American, but I wrote an entire screenplay set in England and so I had to run it by a bunch of brits to check the language. Some of the corrections seemed familiar ("we say 'superior', not 'boss'"), but some were just shocking to me. "We never say 'fall', we always say 'autumn'". What? Really? You people can't say anything right! That's why you lost your empire, right there.

That's what you have in common with Abba, Apodaca: you make all of us look better in comparison

That, and the two nearly nude women standing next to me.

Omar Karindu, with the power of SUPER-hypocrisy!

May 16, 2009 at 11:03 am

If you have two nearly nude women standing next to you, why are you wasting time posting at Internet comic-book sites?

Check and mate, Apodaca.

I'm glad you had my back, Omar!

I didn't have any answer for the two nearly nude women comment.

Omar Karindu, with the power of SUPER-hypocrisy!

May 16, 2009 at 2:28 pm

I don't have your back -- I saw an opening for a burn and I took it.

No honor among posters,huh?

OK, fair enough.

You strike me as someone who would be watching Eurovision this weekend

Only by proxy. My parents watch it so sometimes I can't help hearing some of it.

FunkyGreenJerusalem

May 17, 2009 at 6:05 pm

.
Jax: Dang, I should have caught the fact that Eden would have said “nappy.” I don’t know, if I were writing people from other cultures, I’d be so terrified of making a mistake that I’d be sure to check up on things. Doesn’t anyone at Marvel know any Aussies?

Due to our slow but sure Americanisation through the TV, so people would say 'diaper' - although they would occasionally get called out on it ('What are you, an American' - said as if you were spitting the word!), however, presumably not someone who is living in the desert and covered in paint.
On that - although some Aborigines do still put on paint and such for ceremony's, or tourist dollars, someone just sitting around painted up is about as likely as a Native American sitting around in their feathers all painted up and such.

Hell, I thought it was weird when Ellis two Aborigines painted up in The Authority, as he had been down here a couple of times...

Of course, at least Eden wasn't African American, until he found out he was related to Gateway, at which point he was an Aborigine, until they decided that was a boring plot, and he was back to African American... Ahh Marvel, 'they all just look the same'....

Greg - you freaked me out, calling me out on Boom! pricing like that. Just so everyone knows I am not only a curmudgeon who worries about funny book prices (although I do feel like I am constantly thinking about my expenditures in that area these days). Seriously, thanks for the shout out. As I'm sure you know, it's nice to know that someone actually reads what you take the time to type.

Secret Six and Young Liars were my bests of the week. I still can't believe that Catman, Ragdoll and Bane (!?!?) are some of my favorite characters in mainstream comics - seriously, someone is doing excellent character development work on Bane? - but this is the Simone I love. YL is so good; I just hope that it was within plan to warp it in under 20 issues. Any word on the Lapham to Avatar rumors that were floating around? Who's publishing this Sparta USA book?

And as I now officially have "Take a Chance On Me" stuck in my head, I take back any thanks from this comments start, Burgas. I'm a Billy Joel fan too (70s stuff, anyway), but this is too much!

The points about Fraction are all spot on. I miss Casanova. I'm still hanging on to Invincible Iron Man for some reason, but that's tenuous and I think I have actively disliked his other Marvel work that wasn't on Thor or where he was partnered with Brubaker. Why can't they pair him with an artist that suits his sensibilities? Why all the photoreference and cheesecake pencillers?

I'm in for more Unwritten out of respect and appreciation for Carey and Gross. But I'm leery too, and it has nothing to do with the Boy Wizard thing - is there anything new that needs to be said about the stories as spirituality theme mined by Gaiman/Morrison/Moore? Air seemed to be doing the same thing, when I dropped that. Is this Vertigo's new fantasy trope?

And some Le Tigre lyrics don't make up for that!

Someone finally got the lyrics! That's perfectly fine, avoiding Boom! books for the price, and I understand completely. I wish they could figure out how to lower to even $3.50, but I guess they're doing okay. Sorry to freak you out!

s1rude, I'm guessing that it's less that "stories as spirituality" is Vertigo's "new trope" and more that authors are recognizing that it's literally the only thing that sells anymore when it comes to Vertigo. I mean, you need look no further than the tanking of Young Liars and the continued success of the Fables franchise (or even the sales of everything else Vertigo publishes compared to Fables,) for verification of that.

FunkyGreenJerusalem

May 18, 2009 at 9:49 pm

Sorry Dave, are you saying it's only spirituality books that sell at Vertigo?
Vertigo was founded on 'mystical books', but 100 Bullets, Scalped, DMZ, Northlanders and the Fables books (as they have nothing to do at all with spirituality) for an argument to rebut that.

Oh, and the Dude, I'm not trying to say that Umbrella Academy is the equal of Grant's Doom Patrol any more than I'd say that Casanova is the equal of A Cure For Cancer. It's more that they're clearly influenced by their respective inspirations than that they're equaling them in quality.

FGJ, I'm not arguing spirituality is the sole selling point of Vertigo, but rather that the Gaiman-esque metafictional "stories about stories" element that tends to indentify a success in the current climate of Vertigo. There are titles that break this pattern, yes, but they are mostly ones that were established 5 years ago or more, such as 100 Bullets or Y the Last Man. Meanwhile, Scalped is a title that sells under 10,000 copies a month and would arguably be up for cancellation were it not for trade sales and arguably Warner's hope that they could develop an HBO series about it.

The simple fact is, if you want to last longer than 2 years in Vertigo's current climate, your best bet is for a Gaiman inspired metafictional series about the nature of fiction, and a cursory review of Vertigo's sales numbers basically confirm this.

FunkyGreenJerusalem

May 18, 2009 at 10:27 pm

I know detractors like to say Fables is a Gaiman wannabe - but it really, really isn't.
It's not even trying to be, nor was it ever.
It stars people like other stories, but is much more like LoEG - it's new stories starring those characters.
Testament was a revisiting of stories, and it died quickly.

Also, it's bizarre to say that Scalped has bad sales, and then say 'if it wasn't for the trade sales'... they count as sales.

You also didn't account for DMZ or Northlanders...

The truth is, the only person who ever had success at Vertigo writing like Gaiman, was Gaiman himself.

All the other hits have been quite different.

I stopped reading Fables around volume 4-5 (i don't clearly remember because honestly nothing after Animal Farm remotely qualified as memorable,) but none of it moved beyond the level of Gaiman pastiche for me.

In fact, the only thing I've ever read by Willingham that stood out as a unique voice that held my attention was Ironwood, and that was mainly because it was about centaur blowjobs and hardcore fucking. Outside of that, Thessaly: Witch for Hire was completely disposable and the first 2 years of Fables didn't fare much better.

You can complain that I'm tasteless, but whatever, if disliking the Juno-meets-Naruto aesthetic of Scott Pilgrim is tasteless, I don't want to know what tasteful is.

FunkyGreenJerusalem

May 18, 2009 at 11:54 pm

I stopped reading Fables around volume 4-5 (i don’t clearly remember because honestly nothing after Animal Farm remotely qualified as memorable,) but none of it moved beyond the level of Gaiman pastiche for me.

In what way specifically is Fables a Gaiman pastiche?

Both use established characters is really as far as it goes.

Sandman was about using stories to talk about story telling, Fables is pretty much X-Men or Buffy but with characters from Fairy tales.

I'd go as far to say that Vertigo being the publisher is the only link between the two.

You can complain that I’m tasteless, but whatever, if disliking the Juno-meets-Naruto aesthetic of Scott Pilgrim is tasteless, I don’t want to know what tasteful is.

Oooh nice, bringing in something else to counter... nice trick.

If you don't like Scott Pilgrim that's your loss, it's got as much to do with this as Fables does with Sandman.

Leave a Comment

 

Subscribe to CSBG

Categories

Review Copies

Comics Should Be Good accepts review copies. Anything sent to us will (for better or for worse) end up reviewed on the blog. See where to send the review copies.

Browse the Archives