CBR Live! Archive
Green Lantern #42 Review
- by Brian Cronin
- in Comic Reviews
One thing jumped out at me from Green Lantern #42 - the coloring of Nei Ruffino and Rob Reis really worked well to give the book a very consistent look even though it had two pencilers who really are not all that similar, Philip Tan and Eddy Barrows. Granted, you could argue that the effect was achieved by darkening things to the point where it blended together (sort of like how darkness in film helps special effects blend together), but in either event, I think it worked. Also, Philip Tan made me feel pretty confident the last couple of issues about seeing him do an arc on Batman and Robin, something I might not have been as confident about prior to this story arc, and while this issue was a bit muddier (that darkness I was referring to), I'm still feeling good about his upcoming arc.
Anyhow, this issue concludes the lead-up to Blackest Night, and writer Geoff Johns has a full plate here, with basically three-four concurrent storylines going on, and I think the last two issues of this story really melded together well for a good lead-in to Blackest Night.

Last issue had a great cliffhanger (you all might know how I feel about cliffhangers being "earned," and I think last issue definitely "earned" its cliffhanger) that was resolved quickly in this issue in a satisfactory manner (and one that was set up earlier in the arc).
The three major stories in this issue were:
Hal Jordan versus Larfleeze, the "Orange Lantern"
John Stewart versus Star Sapphire (who was formerly the villain Fatality)
and
Green Lanterns Ash and Saarek's journey to find the corpse of the Anti-Monitor.
Larfleeze has been a revelation as a villain - an almost comic relief character (if a deadly one at that) who helps break the tension a bit amongst all the seriousness of the lead-up to Blackest Night. Johns handles the humor well here (as he did last issue where we saw Larfleeze's rather humorous origin). I especially dug the bit where Jordan finally recalls the name of the Muppet that Larfleeze reminds him of.
In addition, the usage of the blue ring was well done, particularly where the ring finally kicked in. "Sincerity Registered" - classic.
The John Stewart/Fatality interaction was interesting, although I'm conflicted about the idea of possibly retconning the destruction of Xanshi. Generally, I'm not a fan of re-visiting something that has been more or less resolved for years now to then, I dunno, resolve it again (shades of Janet Van Dyne forgiving Hank Pym then unforgiving him then forgiving him then unforgiving him, etc.). Then again, the original Xanshi plot idea WAS pretty ridiculous (John Stewart, of all people, being arrogant to the point of idiocy, leading to the death of millions? That IS pretty silly), so I suppose it couldn't hurt too much to try to write it off. In any event, the idea of having two characters who are more or less defined by their need to forgive meeting up with each other (with Fatality under the influence of the Zamarons) was a great idea,
Finally (well, not really "finally" as we do first get a little tangent where we see the after effects of Machiavellian Bargain #3545950430553059305935686050 that the Guardians have struck), we see the finale of the mission of Lanterns Saarek and Ash (as an aside - while better than a lot of other captions of this kind - Ash's handwritten captions are still annoying - I am sure that I have seen good handwritten captions somewhere - From Hell, maybe? - but off the top of my head I can't think of any definite examples while I can think of many examples where handwritten captions are hard to read like they are here - although, again, these are at least better than some I have seen - I recall Birds of Prey having AWFUL ones awhile back). Johns adds an extremely nice touch where Saarek (who can hear the dead) has his ear drums burst from all the cries of the dead - and it all leads to an eerie, spooky and highly effective final page (with a great one liner) that leads into Blackest Night #1.
Good stuff - it gives Blackest Night an organic lead-in, which is good to see.
Recommended.
EDITED TO ADD: Commenter rwe1138 did mention a pretty notable mistake that was really odd - early in the issue, Hal says a line of Larfleeze's dialogue. The weird thing is that:
A. Larfleeze has a whole different word balloon design and font, so I'd have thought his dialogue was done separately from Hal's, so it's odd that they would mix together like that.
B. It wasn't even an errant word balloon arrow (you know, like an arrow pointed to the wrong person) - it was just an extra line of dialogue in Hal's otherwise correct dialogue balloon that was clearly not his dialogue.
So weird.
- Posted on June 25, 2009 @ 01:03 PM






26 Comments
rwe1138
June 25, 2009 at 1:13 pm
The Guardians are becoming quite the assholes lately. What they did to Ganthet & Sayd was a total dick move.
I'm not sure about the Fatality plot thread. Unless the Star Sapphires just flat out brainwash their recruits, she's been acting way out of character, and her kissing John just seemed totally off. We'll see.
And I can't be the only one who noticed several mistakes regarding word balloons, am I? Hal saying "It was a... a mirage?!? Bah!" makes absolutely no sense, and I assume that was Larfleeze's dialogue. And a Guardian later: "We cannot allow your greed to grow behind this star system." I'd wager that should've been "beyond."
Still, overall it was a good issue.
Brian Cronin
June 25, 2009 at 1:19 pm
Oh crap, I totally meant to mention that, rwe!
Thanks, I'll edit it in now.
Kwas
June 25, 2009 at 1:34 pm
Jaime Reyes as the Last Blue Lantern (up against Larfleeze!!!)
anyone?
........
Just me then huh
rwe1138
June 25, 2009 at 1:34 pm
Happy to help jog the ol' memory.
MLevie
June 25, 2009 at 2:13 pm
I'm calling this now, Hal Jordans hand is going to become a black lantern. Watch its going to be his severed hand and a construct of Hal Jordan as the primary antagonist.
Dave
June 25, 2009 at 2:27 pm
This is the second storyline in a row to end with one of the "bad" Corps wanting Odym. Atrocitus is seeking it and is going to bring the pain when he gets there.
And I'm hoping Larfleeze gets an oath. Even though his Corps is so totally different, it just feels like it's lacking without one.
Loren
June 25, 2009 at 2:32 pm
While I haven't read the issue, I have seen pictures of Larfleeze, and I do know my Muppets, so I'm guessing that it's gotta be Uncle Deadly.
Bill Reed
June 25, 2009 at 2:33 pm
Evil severed hands? What is this, Evil Dead 2?
Dave
June 25, 2009 at 2:55 pm
The severed hand turned out to be an illusion created by the Blue ring to keep Hal safe. They can do anything, remember?
rwe1138
June 25, 2009 at 3:31 pm
Dave:
IIRC, Johns has mentioned writing Larfleeze's oath, and it was his favorite of all the new ones.
Akwasi
June 25, 2009 at 3:49 pm
Pretty sure the oath was "MINE!!" they said it on the dcu blog or something
Paul Moses
June 25, 2009 at 3:56 pm
Larfleeze rocks!
Green Lantern 42 rocks!
I sure hope Blackest Night is as good!
Rebis
June 25, 2009 at 4:42 pm
A very entertaining issue. I agree, Brian, about the Muppet line. I'd just re-read the previous ish before delving into this new one, and I was like, "Really? Hal's so out of touch, he doesn't know the names of the major Muppets?" So that was some laugh-out-loud payoff this issue. And Larfleeze is an entertaining villain, though I'm not sure he's more dangerous than Atrocitus.
"Sincerity registered" was a good bit — although, for such a trivial wish? Shouldn't he actually have hoped for something selfless, like: "I hope that this Blue Ring can help me save my fellow Lanterns"?
Also interesting to note that, as this issue ends, we've an imminent clash between the Orange and Blue, and also between Yellow and Violet. Probably no coincidence that complementary colors are clashing. I did very much enjoy (and believe) Fatality's conversion, and I liked that her main message to John was about forgiveness. I doubt Kryb and Karu-Sil are going to end up Sapphires though — they're sure to get busted out by Sinestro & Co. Kryb is way too awesome a villain to be rehabilitated. (See: "Green Lantern Corps," which is just as good, if not better, than this main title.)
I also loved that the Guardians pulled yet another fast one. By the time "Blackest Night" is all over, those machiavellian little blue bastards are not going to be in charge anymore.
Finally, I really liked that glimpse of the future about Sinestro. It's clear that his arc in all of this is going to be crucial and unexpected — he's one of the keys to it all, and by now I suspect he and Hal will have to forgive each other and work together to help stop the War of Light/Blackest Night. We'll see ...
Dave
June 25, 2009 at 5:07 pm
Well, the preview for Blackest Night from all the way back in GL #25 says that Fear and Willpower must unite...
Ricardo
June 25, 2009 at 7:44 pm
I still sustain that Geoff Johns is superb in setting up a massive and compelling storytelling, going way beyond others have done in the past, but his characterization is awfully bi-dimentional. His portrait of the Guardians is ludicrous and Hal Jordan acted like a two-bit D-list hero when subdued by the Blue Lantern. He simply can't find nuance in characters at all. I mean, look at Carol Ferris - she comes back as Hal's sweetheart out of nothing - especially AFTER Johns had clearly put her beyond that relationship.
Michael Mayket
June 25, 2009 at 8:50 pm
I agree that the Guardians are dicks and it's high past time that Kyle spanked them. He did create them after all, and originally did so as children so that they'd grow up to not be such dicks this time.
Michael Mayket
June 25, 2009 at 8:51 pm
And maybe they have because I'm a trade reader, but I've been waiting to see the Zamoran's reaction to the existence of little bald blue Oan women.
Chris Jones
June 25, 2009 at 8:56 pm
I'm not generally a fan of Green Lantern ever since the Sinestro Corps War finished, and I didn't even really like this last arc all that much, but I LOVE Larfleeze. I want him to stick around for a long time.
stealthwise
June 25, 2009 at 9:49 pm
We should get a review of GL Corps, because while this title is decent, Tomasi is writing circles around Johns in terms of action, set-up and characterization.
Chris Jones
June 25, 2009 at 11:26 pm
Also, what stealthwise just said X 10.
Ricardo
June 26, 2009 at 8:23 am
For me it is just the opposite: Tomasi is writing the best GL book, while Johns is messing up with characters.
Ricardo
June 27, 2009 at 11:26 am
For me it is just the opposite: Tomasi is writing the best GL book, while Johns is messing up with characters.
P.S. - Sorry, forgot to tell you great post!
ZZZ
June 28, 2009 at 9:58 pm
My suggestion for an Orange Lantern oath:
"All that I've seen or see is mine!
All that will ever be is mine!
Let those who try to take what's mine!
Fear my Orange power! Mine! Mine! Mine!"
I've been loving this storyline (regardless of how Blackest Night turns out, I think it's safe to call Prelude to Blackest Night a resounding success), and I'm confident what Johns came up with will be great, but I just wanted to share.
John Seavey
June 29, 2009 at 6:56 am
One of those comic book urban legends I've always wanted to ask Starlin about: Is it true that the Green Lantern in "Cosmic Odyssey" was originally supposed to be Guy Gardner, but they denied him permission to use Guy so he swapped in John Stewart? Or was it just some fan who thought, "He's acting like Guy!" and that wound up being reported as a change?
Mephisto
July 12, 2009 at 8:31 pm
For those who are curious, the Orange Lantern oath:
"In richest profit, in sparsest gain....
Let those who reject us feel our pain....
May those who keep us from the stars....
Beware our wrath, for all is OURS!!!"
Personally, I find the entire concept of the Orange Lantern Corps to be outstanding. The belief that only one can ever truly be an Orange Lantern and possess the Power Battery, while the remaining army is built of constructs consumed by the battery.
Things I liked in this issue:
-Hal imitating the Orange Lanterns, creating a Green Lantern Corps made entirely of constructs (f*** yeah Alan Scott was in it too), and Larfleeze's horrified reaction to it.
-Orange Lantern Hal Jordan ($10 says he'll wear a ring on every finger, become a White Lantern, and murder the hell out of Black Hand and the Black Power Battery. It's cliched, I know, but still....). Because what does Hal Jordan want when he's corrupted by the orange flames of Avarice? Two cheeseburgers. Awesome.
-The Blue Power Ring, which in itself has been a bit of comic relief ever since Hal came to wear it (the banter between Hal and the Guardians when they demanded he remove it was priceless: "Trust me, if I could've, I would've by now. Honestly, aren't you supposed to be all-knowing?"), finally registering the one thing that fearless Hal Jordan truly hopes for: for the ring to shut up and leave him alone. It's so subtle and yet brilliant at the same time ("Sincerity registered." "You've got to be kidding me...."). Hal's reasons for the Blue Ring to be useless on him, aside from keeping his Green Ring at a constant 210% charge, were always valid. Hal Jordan doesn't hope for anything. He just does it. Period. Even after his resurrection in the wake of the Paralax aftermath, he didn't hope for forgiveness. He just set out to prove he was genuinely sorry.
-Discovering the Black Power Battery, and that "oh s**t" moment where they realize that things are about to become really really bad. Same reaction shared by the Green Lanterns when Scar tore Oa apart. That is until Kilowog smacked some sense into everyone (as usual).
Things I didn't like:
-The ongoing brief dialogue between John and Fatality. It's like Johns wants to devote an entire run to them, but can't. Instead we get 1-2 page encounters with them every issue for the last six months. It's not that it isn't relevant, but in the grand scheme of everything going on, I find myself caring less about them. I just feel it wont be noteworthy until the Star Sapphires make their grand entrance in the Blackest Night, and even then will we care?
-I'll go on record to say The Guardians without Scar are more of a threat to the universe than the Black Lantern Corps with Scar is. Ignoring that you've rewritten every law in the Book of Oa to cover your mistakes, ignoring that you still refuse to believe the Blackest Night prophecy WILL HAPPEN unless Black Hand and his horde of living dead show up at your doorstep (just a reminder, the dead have power rings now potentially equivalent or more powerful than your emerald army of willpower), you started the War of Light. Not only that, you betrayed Ganthet and Sayd by unleashing Larfleeze on the Blue Lanterns. Really? Are you THAT bitter? Is it really that difficult for you and your band of Green Lanterns to just destroy Larfleeze and imprison the Orange Power Battery that you have to bargain with him yet again by offering the Blue Lanterns as sacrifice? What has Scar done in comparison? Wake the dead and convince Black Hand to commit suicide so he can be the Black Lanterns' leader. Oooooooo. (sarcasm)
Overall, I'm impressed. But things are just beginning. And I have a feeling that, like many times before, DCU will never be the same. F**k shapeshifting green aliens. The dead have risen, and all hell is about to break loose.
hippoguy
October 15, 2009 at 8:44 pm
i liked this issue. larfleeze is a delightfully malicious villain. blue lantern power rules.
many people are commenting on how Hal activated the blue ring. His whole statement was actually "As soon as we get out of this.. I hope you stop asking me that question." In other words, Hal expressed hope that he would beat Larfleeze. I think the blue ring picked up on that more than it did on Hal's retort.