web stats

CSBG Archive

Danielle Leigh’s Reading Diary — Kimi ni Todoke (From Me to You) vol 1

Kimi ni Todoke, by Kuruho Shiina, is a charming and refreshing shojo take on high school life, friendship and love.  If you’re burnt out on high school shojo, I suggest you give this lovely story a chance as it will remind you how joyful shojo can be.

kiminitodoke01

A part of Kimi ni Todoke‘s excessive charm is found in its heroine’s simple and enduring faith in the basic decency of people.  Sawako Kuronuma has been saddled with the nickname “Sadako” thanks to her long, straight black hair and scary, horror-house smile (Sadako is a reference to the character from the Japanese horror film The Ring).   All Sawako wants is to make real friends with her classmates, but because of her looks and scary smile they treat her like an outcast in spite of the fact they haven’t a single clue who she really is.  They actually run screaming from her presence somehow believing that she’s in league with the demonic (oh teenagers.  You so stupid).

While most people would be understandably bitter at being cast to such a lonely lot in life by one’s own peers, Sawako comes from a long line of indefatigable shojo heroines.  Therefore, she believes that so long as she continues to greet her classmates every day with openness and warmth, one fine day her real feelings will get across to them.   Time after time, Sawako’s efforts come to heartbreaking naught until she befriends all-round class MVP Kazehaya.   Kazehaya is, in the unchecked words of Sawako, “100 percent nice!”  In the mouth of anyone else these words would be an insult, but they represent Sawako’s pure admiration for Kazekaya’s sunny energy.

Although one could easily read Kimi ni Todoke as a romance between the attractive and kind Kazehaya and the pure Sawako, for me the story is more about how we can nurture the bonds of friendship and affection — not because we simply want to be loved but also because we want to love (i.e. Sawako doesn’t care about a flip about popularity, so much as she cares about connection).  While those bonds don’t come easy to Sawako, that somehow that only makes her plight seem more real and relatable.  As the layers of isolation fall away from Sawako, thanks to both her hard work and Kazekaya’s leading by example, we can see that friendship is never out of reach for anyone.

Kimi ni Todoke‘s story is light but not shallow, sweet but not cloying.  Watching Sawako reach for and start to sustain connections with her classmates inspires us to cheer her on in her worthy quest to be accepted for her true self.

Review Copy provided by Viz.

5 Comments

Sawako doesn’t care about a flip about popularity, so much as she cares about connection

*heart*

There is so much here that is well-said. What a wonderful review!

Danielle Leigh

July 14, 2009 at 6:26 pm

Awww, thanks! It’s been a rough few days, so I’m glad I saved this book to read and review for the right moment and I really needed something wonderful in just this way right now.

[...] Kiki Van De Camp on vol. 1 of Hot Gimmick (VIZBIG Edition) (Animanga Nation) Danielle Leigh on vol. 1 of Kimi ni Todoke (Comics Should Be Good) Connie on vol. 2 of Me and the Devil Blues (Slightly Biased Manga) Lori [...]

Oh, I was hoping you’d review this one! I’ve read all the scanlations available, but I’ve already preordered this and am eagerly looking forward to receiving it. Even though I’m SO OLD (okay, 25, but still), I just went head over heels over its easy charm and pure niceness. It and Aozora Yell (by the same mangaka who did High School Debut, so I expect it to be picked up sooner or later) are really lovely, refreshing works that have drawn me back into reading manga after years away. I hope more people read your review and check out this manga for themselves; it really deserves to be supported.

Danielle Leigh

July 15, 2009 at 6:39 pm

hi Kelly! Well, I’m 29 and shojo like this never really goes out of style as far as I’m concerned! :-)

I love High School Debut so I hope Aozora Yell will be licensed soon as well….maybe after a few more volumes are released?

Leave a Comment

 

Categories

Review Copies

Comics Should Be Good accepts review copies. Anything sent to us will (for better or for worse) end up reviewed on the blog. See where to send the review copies.

Browse the Archives