web stats

CSBG Archive

Nostalgia November Day 11 — All-Star Squadron Annual #1

Each day in November, I will read and review/discuss/whatever one comic taken from a box of some of my childhood comics. Today, it’s All-Star Squadron annual #1.

The Nostalgia November archive can be found here.

allstarsquadronannual01All-Star Squadron annual #1 by Roy Thomas, Adrian Gonzales, and Jerry Ordway takes place shortly after the group has come together, so shortly that they barely know one another. The issue has three parts to its story, the first focusing on Wonder Woman, Green Lantern, and the Flash performing at a circus to sell war bonds. During their performance, they fake like an accident had happened so they could shift from riding a bike together across a tightrope to acrobatics — this poses a problem when a flash of light screws them up and everyone thinks it’s just another put-over. The flash of light reveals a glowing bubble that has the Atom, Wildcat, and an unknown person that we know is the Guardian inside. That trio proceeds to attack the other three heroes, displaying superhuman strength. After a scuffle, the three attackers return to normal and have no idea how they got there.

Going off together, the six ride a magic Green Lantern flying carpet and discuss what happened. In the process, Wildcat, the Atom, and the Guardian all tell their origins, converging on two points: being sucked up into a glowing sphere before waking up at the circus, and they were all trained to fight by someone — who turns out to be the same man. With this knowledge, they all split up into pairs and go hunting for the man. Each pair finds him, except his glowing a different colour and is all superpowered-up. In each case, the man he taught to fight knocks him out, though. When they bring the unconscious ‘triplets’ together, they merge into one big glowing angry guy who calls himself Evil. The trainer eventually regains control and tells how he was sucked up into the glowing ball after being bitter that the third man he trained (and hoped would make him rich) abandoned him. The ball hates Green Lantern for whatever reason and used the former students now heroes to try and kill GL. But, it’s defeated now, so everyone be happy?

On the final page, we learn that the glowing ball is some evil force that was sent to that universe by the Guardians of Oa, who previously expelled some magical energy to that same universe knowing that it would eventually power this Green Lantern’s power battery or something. So, really, the problem started with the Guardians of Oa… it’s always those little blue bastards, isn’t it?

Not a bad issue, more an excuse to give readers the origins of Wildcat, Atom, and Guardian than anything else. I mean, the villain is very lame. The issue is interesting for one big reason: Roy Thomas does something that’s quite common now by taking three different, distinct origins, and tying them together based on a point of similarity. I imagine that before this issue the three heroes weren’t trained to fight by the same man, but now they were. Instant connection created as Golden Age characters are retroactively tied together to help strengthen that ‘shared universe’ aspect of the comic. Not only that, but Thomas also connects the Earth-2 Green Lantern to the Green Lanterns of Earth-1. Common techniques/choices today, but not so much then.

Really, though, this is a bland comic. Not bad, but not great either. I probably enjoy it more now than I did when I read it as a kid — I recall finding is VERY boring then. Now, I can appreciate what Thomas and company were going for even if it’s not that exciting.


I remember reading this one when I was a kid: http://i226.photobucket.com/albums/dd210/captainatom/All-Star_Squadron_31.jpg

I had no idea what the hell was going on, but seeing all those heroes together was quite epic.

A funny thing about this issue is the page where they go out of their way to explain where every other hero is and why they aren’t helping out.

I thought it was a fun issue when I was a kid, and still do today. Gorgeous art by Gonzales & Ordway.

A funny thing about this issue is the page where they go out of their way to explain where every other hero is and why they aren’t helping out.

A big reason for that is probably so that Roy Thomas could get in a Hawkman cameo. Hawkman was the only JSAer who appeared in every single issue of the Golden Age All-Star Comics, so RT decided to continue that tradition in All-Star Squadron.

Fun fact: the term “Retroactive Continuity” (the source of today’s “Retcon”) was first introduced in an All-Star Squadron letters page!

Daniel O' Dreams

November 11, 2009 at 2:04 pm

Yeah for an Annual this one was pretty dull.
Was this the first time the Alan Scott’s power is the wild magic from Oa idea was mentioned? That was a clever reason why there would be a Green Lantern on Earth Two.

I think it was earlier than this that they introduced the retcon where the meteor used to make Alan Scott’s lantern and ring is actually the “Starheart.” This artifact was made by the Guardians to imprision “all” the magical energy of Earth I, and they sent it into the universe of Earth II. This may have been first mentioned in GL #111-112 in 1978.

A funny thing about this issue is the page where they go out of their way to explain where every other hero is and why they aren’t helping out.

Well, at least Rob Schmidt will be happy.

It was indeed in an issue of Green Lantern (from the 70’s) that it was revealed The Green Flame Of Life that gave Alan Scott his powers came from (but was not the) Starheart, the collection of all the magic in the Universe of Earth -1, created by the Guardians because they felt it disrupted natural laws. (Presumably this was magic *in space* only, since Earth-1 had plenty of magic using characters.) Apparently the Starheart became sentient and decided to imitate its creators by having its own Green Lantern, but in another world so they wouldn’t know what it was up to (this last part is my theory… really it was all just an excuse to link the two Green Lanterns, and not a terribly well thought-out one.)

Similarly, this story was just Thomas linking the origins of Wildcat, The Atom and The Guardian, simply because they had the the same “trained by an unnamed boxing trainer” origin. Not that bad an idea in itself, but ripping off the Starheart just for that? It felt lame, especially since he brought in the character just to kill him.

[…] #148 Nostalgia November Day 09 — What The–?! #16 Nostalgia November Day 10 — Primortals #1 Nostalgia November Day 11 — All-Star Squadron annual #1 Nosalgia November Day 12 — Transformers #63 The Reread Reviews — The Death of Superman The Reread […]

This Annual had nothing over All-Star Squadron Annual 2. That being said, if there is a series that cries out for Showcase Presents treatment, it is All-Star Squadron.

Leave a Comment



Review Copies

Comics Should Be Good accepts review copies. Anything sent to us will (for better or for worse) end up reviewed on the blog. See where to send the review copies.

Browse the Archives