CSBG Archive
What I’m reading: Her Majesty’s Spymaster, Batman by Neal Adams
- by Greg Burgas
- in General
- 35 Comments
Hey, it’s a brand new year! What are we reading to while away the cold winter days? Or, you know, in my case, the 70-degree winter days!

Okay, so I’m a history nut. A NUT!!!!! And I often write that I love a particular era in history, to the extent that you might think I’m a bit strange, because there’s no way I can like so many eras in history, is there? Well, screw you and the horse you rode in on, I can love any era of history I want!!!!! However, Elizabethan England is a particular favorite of mine, and Sir Francis Walsingham, the Principal Secretary for a good deal of Elizabeth’s reign and one of the men who is considered the father of modern espionage, is a favorite within that particular era. Stephen Budiansky’s book, Her Majesty’s Spymaster, isn’t the greatest history book I’ve ever read, but it’s a nice, readable tome that gives us a decent idea of who Walsingham was and why he felt it necessary to create a vast spy system. Walsingham’s system was fairly sophisticated for its day, and Budiansky does a pretty good job showing how convoluted it was. Walsingham triumphed against the two biggest threats to the queen – Mary Queen of Scots, whom he ensnared in a web and got executed, and Philip II of Spain, whose Armada sailed only after Walsingham’s agents had gathered plenty of intelligence about it. Budiansky downplays William Cecil, Lord Burghley’s own intelligence-gathering ring, which makes sense as he’s focusing on Walsingham but also means he makes Walsingham a bit more central to the creation of “modern espionage.” It’s still a fascinating book.
I just got volume 2 of the Neal Adams Batman issues, and while I’ve only read the introductions and not any actual comics, they look tremendous, obviously. I don’t have volume 1 yet, but the issues in this volume go from October 1969 to May 1971. I didn’t know he did any Batman work prior to that, so I’m keen to track down volume 1. These are tremendous stories, at least the ones I’ve read in the past (how can you not love “The Secret of the Waiting Graves” or “Ghost of the Killer Skies”?), and I look forward to diving into this.
So, now that the holidays are over, what are you delving into? Don’t be shy about your reading choices!






35 Comments
RangeLife
January 4, 2010 at 7:45 pm
Before the jump, I thought the title was referring to one work (i.e., a Neal Adams Elseworlds story about Batman as an MI6 agent).
Matt K
January 4, 2010 at 8:00 pm
@RL, that’s exactly what I thought too (and an interesting concept to say the least). That said, the book sounds right up my alley and I’ll be sure to give it a look next time I’m in the library.
Jack Norris
January 4, 2010 at 8:17 pm
Thirded. Also, that’s a definite nominee for any “nonexistent books I really want to read” list.
Da Fug
January 4, 2010 at 8:19 pm
Yotsuba& vol. 3, The Book of Genesis by Crumb, Beanworld vol. 1, Mad Bear by Doug Boyd, Stitches, Ex Machina: Dirty Tricks
RAB
January 4, 2010 at 8:34 pm
“HER MAJESTY’S SPYMASTER, BATMAN” — somewhere, Neil Gaiman is cursing the missed opportunity.
(And then he compares how much he earns with one short story versus how much he gets paid for a Batman comic and decides he can live with the lost opportunity.)
Kelly Thompson
January 4, 2010 at 8:39 pm
Fourthed…or fifthed, I can’t count.
Chris Jones
January 4, 2010 at 8:40 pm
I thought the same thing as everyone else. Make it happen, World.
Bill Reed
January 4, 2010 at 9:00 pm
It’s like 14 degrees here. I’ll trade you. Heck, I’ll write “Her Majesty’s Spymaster, Batman” if you trade me for a month. I’m thinking 96 page graphic novel, drawn by– your choice. I’d probably pick Norm Breyfogle if you let me, because, c’mon, it’s been too long since he drew Batman.
As for what I’m reading, I just finished Deadeye Dick by Kurt Vonnegut (it’s middlin’ K-Vo) and The Final Solution by Michael Chabon (it was alright). Up next, I’m feelin’ Clans of the Alphane Moon by Philip K. Dick, kindly donated by CSBG reader Dan Bailey.
As for comics, I have several trades and GNs piling up, so I should get on those. I just finished the first Chew trade, and it was fun. My box of comics for this month was pretty anemic, though; I am looking forward to Rugg and Maruca’s Afrodisiac this month.
Martin Scherer
January 4, 2010 at 9:08 pm
Just a heads up on Neal Adams Batman vol 1, half the book is re-inked/colored in the style in vol. 2 and 3, the rest of vol. 1 is like DC Archive editions, just a direct copy of the source material.
buttler
January 4, 2010 at 9:17 pm
Now I’m heartbroken that there isn’t a Neal Adams-drawn “Her Majesty’s Spymaster, Batman.”
Tom Fitzpatrick
January 4, 2010 at 9:22 pm
I’ve finished reading Dan Brown’s The Lost Symbol (for which I can’t wait for the movie adaptation–if there’s one), and Steve Niles and Ben Templesmith’s Cal McDonald: Criminal Macabre tpb.
Chad Nevett
January 4, 2010 at 9:38 pm
Finished The Book of Illusions by Paul Auster, which was a decent read, but problematic in places and, ultimately, not as satisfying as his other works. I’m just waiting for a Chapters order to arrive so I can read the latest Chuck Klosterman book before starting in on Vineland by Thomas Pynchon.
sterg
January 4, 2010 at 10:04 pm
Mary Roach’s Bonk. Mary Roach RULES!
Greg Hatcher
January 4, 2010 at 10:22 pm
Just finished Showcase Presents DC Comics Presents Superman Team-Ups — I swear, that’s the real title — the Chuck graphic novel, Kull, volume one, The Mona Intercept by Donald Hamilton, and a couple of Doc Savage novels, The Polar Treasure and Pirate of the Pacific.
On deck is more Doc, since I got a bunch of those double pulp-replica volumes from Nostalgia Ventures really cheap last week, and more Essentials and Showcases. Also a nice Andre Norton omnibus arrived day before yesterday, and also a couple of John Burke’s gothic occult books starring Dr. Caspian. And Ashenden by Somerset Maugham.
They’re piling up on me again, yes. When I was a bus commuter I could stay up with the pile, but lately I’m taking the car more and well, I can’t read and drive at the same time.
Dan Felty
January 4, 2010 at 11:27 pm
In prose–
I thought Deadeye Dick was very good, Bill! Why didn’t you care for it? (Although I recognize that “middlin’ K-Vo” might be fairly substantial praise.) I just finished Bluebeard and Hocus Pocus–I actually have Timequake open to page 1 on my lap right now. I’m a little sad that it’ll be the last Vonnegut novel I get to read. Boy, was I happy when I heard about Look at the Birdie!
I’m in the middle of Twinkie, Deconstructed, a look at the industrial processes that go into making packaged food. It’s not particularly appetizing, but it should help me make better choices.
I picked up Inhuman Bondage, a history of the slave trade in the new world. I realized that why I may have picked up a fair amount of knowledge about slavery, aside from a few slave narratives/oral histories and asides in other works, I haven’t really read a book about slavery! I’m chagrined.
Anansi Boys by Neil Gaiman–I had American Gods recommended to me by several folks and enjoyed it; this had been sitting on the shelf for a year because I heard it was a sort of ‘spiritual sequel’. Good stuff. I have a tendency to think of all of Gaiman’s work as being part of Sandman; these felt like, basically, Sandman prose novels with Morpheus missing.
I also just picked up a few books on music theory from the library. I need to both remember what I’ve forgotten and learn what I always should’ve but never did.
In comics–
Just finished:
Moresukine, a compilation of comics posted on the blog of a German ex-pat who invited readers to give him assignments to do while living in Tokyo. OK.
Abandon the Old in Tokyo, a collection of short stories from 1970 written by Yoshihiro Tatsumi. Fairly dour, and an odd mixture of understated and over-the-top. I’m going to check out his autobio A Drifting Life.
One Hundred Demons by Lynda Barry. For some reason, this clicked with me in a way the Marlys strips haven’t. I’m going to give them another chance.
Stitches by David Small. Good, but seemed almost old hat. I don’t share the opinion that’s it’s the best of the year, but I did read it awfully fast.
The Plot–this was actually really disappointing Will Eisner! It looked great, of course, but he did a very poor job of forming a narrative out of historical facts. E. G., there’s a lot of dialogue along the lines of ‘Did you know that the Protocols were written to convince the czar that Jews were a threat?’ ‘That’s interesting!’ It’s a shame it’s got such problems, considering Eisner’s goal of revealing and combating anti-Semitism. It’s a goal he very much reaches in his fiction, but I think, lamentably, he fails here.
Currently reading:
American Splendor (the re-release of the first two collections that came out around the movie)–great stuff, incisive and often charming, despite the curmudgeonly outlook.
V for Vendetta–I gave my copy away last Christmas, so I picked up a used one I found.
MW by Osamu Tezuka–The Robot 6 comic college on Tezuka recommended this as his least fantastical, so I thought I’d try it out. I loved Buddha, didn’t care for Blackjack, and thought Metropolis was fluff. So far it’s quite good. I got a (admittedly ethnocentric) kick out of seeing it was initially serialized in Biggu Komikku magazine.
Wednesday Comics–I just picked up the whole shebang online. Sure is pretty!
Ah, seasonal lay-offs, what a great opportunity to get some reading done!
JackKing
January 5, 2010 at 2:11 am
Just about to finish The Invisibles. Not quite sure what to read next.
Mike Loughlin
January 5, 2010 at 6:30 am
I’m 1/3 of the way through Tales Designed to Thrizzle, vol. 1. It’s one of the funniest comics I’ve ever read. I just finished Noir, the recent Dark Horse short story anthology. It was okay, the highlight being a Stray Bullets story. If there’s one comic I would like to see return to the stands on a regular basis, it’s Stray Bullets.
I borrowed the most recent Dennis Lahane book (name escapes me), and will start it this week.
Gavin Bell
January 5, 2010 at 7:08 am
I just finished Killer in the Rain, which is a collection of the early stories that Raymond Chandler cannibalised for his novel. The stories were all great but as a writer I was even more fascinated with how the stories had been mashed up seamlessly later on.
Finally got around to reading Maus, which was great, but I’m slightly ashamed that I enjoyed the Punisher Max stories I read directly afterwards way more. I really hadn’t expected to like them so much, as I dislike Ennis on everything else, but these stories just blew me away. Best thing I’ve read in ages.
Gavin Bell
January 5, 2010 at 7:19 am
…oh yeah and Neal Adams – best comic artist of all time. You could publish his Batman pages unchanged today and they’d still be the most exciting thing out there. One of the many tragedies of All Star Batman is that its lateness has made the rumoured Adams run less and less likely.
Luis Dantas
January 5, 2010 at 7:32 am
I, too, thought that this was a single book, some sort of Elseworlds by Neal Adams.
I blame the italics in the heading. They cover both titles’ names but stop before Neal Adams’, therefore leading me to believe that Adams is responsible for both and hinting that it is in fact a single book.
Matthew Johnson
January 5, 2010 at 7:33 am
Hey Greg,
If you liked “Her Majesty’s Spymaster,” check out “God’s Secret Agents” Alice Hogge for the other side of the story — how Catholic priests continued to operate in England during the period. It’s full of fascinating details, like the relative merits and drawbacks of lemon and orange juice as invisible ink…
Daniel O' Dreams
January 5, 2010 at 8:01 am
Just picked up a few volumes of The Early Works of “Winsor McCay” by Checker Publishing for $2 each at a local bookstore. Missing the first three volumes (and anything above volume eight if such a creature exists). Stuff is AMAZING. Rougher than his Little Nemo work but still amazing and bizarrely ahead of it’s time. I’m continually amazed that this stuff was printed a century ago.
Greg Burgas
January 5, 2010 at 8:17 am
Sorry about the confusion with the titles, everyone! I too would love an Elseworlds book about Batman being a spy for England. In any time period, really. My bad for getting everyone’s hopes up. But how cool would that have been if I’d been the only person to know about this project????
Thanks for the suggestion, Matthew. That’s just what I need – more books to check out!!!!
Peter Woodhouse
January 5, 2010 at 8:50 am
Hi Greg – although I haven’t seen the contents of the Neal Adams Batman volumes, Vol 1 would be concentrating on his Brave & Bold work (including 2 Deadman team-ups) — & anything else I’ve missed?
Neal was working on these 1968-69 so the dates tally. Other team-ups off the top of my head included Flash, Aquaman, Creeper, & the new-look ‘whiskers’ Ollie Green Arrow.
Mike Blake
January 5, 2010 at 9:57 am
Well, at least by the word “spymaster” I knew before the jump the implied Elseworlds by Adams would be Elizabethan. The author downplays Cecil? Good to know — I’ve read more about Cecil than Walsingham, as it happens.
What am I reading? After seeing it on most of the year’s best lists, I got Asterios Polyp today. And I’m reading Final Crisis in trade to see if it makes more sense (I didn’t read all the comics it contains as they came out).
Argo Plummert
January 5, 2010 at 11:31 am
I am reading Matt Kindt’s Super Spy (about halfway through), a book on how to coach youth basketball (volunteered to coach my 9 year olds team), just picked up first five issued of Batgirl and Greg Rucka’s run on Detective and am going to dive into them after I finish Doctor Tomorrow (yes, the Acclaim book by Bob Layton and various artists–found the entire run at a used book store in my town and it’s not that bad, definitely worth what I paid, especially since it was trade-in credit, although I understand it falls apart at the end), and am have just started “The Razor’s Edge” by Sommerset Maughm. Whew! Got a lot going on plus College Football Bowl games and the NFL playoffs, which is why I haven’t finished more of the above stuff.
Omar Karindu, with the power of SUPER-hypocrisy!
January 5, 2010 at 2:31 pm
Oh, man, the sheer possbilities of it….the reveal that “M” was chosen as both an inverted “W” for Wayne and as an emblem of the bat-ears; Robin taking his codename from Robin Goodfellow; the Penguin turning up as a corrupt Anglican bishop; the Scottish roots of the names “Wayne” and “Kyle” being played up in tune to Mary,. Queen of Scots’s aborted coup attempt; a version of the Joker that really is an evil version of the Renaissance-era hero of the old Man Who Laughs book and film; a Riddler who plays off of the tradition of actual English riddle-rhymes and may be prophesying what shall come; and Ra’s Al Ghul as a strange foreign prince out to marry the Virgin Queen.
It really does write itself, dunnit?
Brian Cronin
January 5, 2010 at 2:37 pm
Excellent…the Gospel of Thrizzle is spreading!!!
Roman
January 5, 2010 at 4:14 pm
I hope that somewhere, Grant Morrison is reading this. Issue #5 of Return of Bruce Wayne: Batman as an Elizabethan spy — it really is too good to pass up!
Roman
January 5, 2010 at 4:17 pm
BTW, The Book of Illusions is, I feel, one of Auster’s best “later” (i.e. post-New York Trilogy) works. It’s much more satisfying than Oracle Night and is more substantial than Travels in the Scriptorium. Not as good as the Brooklyn Follies, though.
Oric7d
January 5, 2010 at 9:04 pm
Bought some trades on sale for the cover price in AU$ (not much of a steal considering the current exchange rates). Still some good stuff – a book on Peter Milligan’s work, 4 volumes of Tangled Web and an odd Avengers trade – two annuals & issues 161-162 and 201
Bill Reed
January 5, 2010 at 9:08 pm
Deadeye Dick was fine, Dan, but I wouldn’t put it near Vonnegut’s best. There were good bits within, but it never quite gelled for me.
I think Galapagos is an overlooked Vonnegut classic.
Louis Bright-Raven
January 5, 2010 at 11:14 pm
A KILLNG IN COMICS by Max Alan Collins is sort of started on. Eventually I’ll read the first Rick Castle novel (the book they spun off the CASTLE TV show), the name of which escapes me. I still have the entire TITANS run that Greg sent me to read, plus a bunch of other comics from Christmas, plus about 30-35 SF magazines to read from the past year…
But what I’m delving into is writing my own stuff again. I haven’t written fiction for the past few years as I was editing and drawing, and had some serious upheaval in my life. Hopefully 2010 will see some of my own stuff back into print.
Which means back to work for me.
Dan Felty
January 6, 2010 at 4:55 pm
I’ve actually had a lot of people hold up Galapagos as one of his best books, but I felt the same way about it that you did towards Deadeye Dick!
Roman–hey, I randomly picked up The Brooklyn Follies as my first introduction to Auster; that’s some good luck! Can I dive right in, or should I read his earlier works first?
Chad Nevett
January 7, 2010 at 5:38 pm
Roman — I’ve been slow in getting Auster novels, but The Book of Illusions had been my least favourite of his works yet. I think it suffers from its length, which seems to demand more whereas Travels in the Scriptorium and Man in the Dark were more concise…
Dan — Just dive in. It’s completely self-contained.