web stats

CSBG Archive

Danielle Leigh’s Reading Diary — not simple

Natsume Ono’s first comic to see print in the U.S. — not simple — is a powerful and haunting work.  Luckily, we won’t have to wait long to see more from her later this year.

not simple

In spite of the book’s title, there is a deceptive simpleness to Ono’s story and art.  The done-in-one volume starts at the end of a young man’s long journey to resurrect the only real family he’s ever had and then backtracks to surgically slice out all the moments in time that led him to his final destination.  Opening with the end of Ian’s story, the narrative immediately returns to where he started and charts the life of a young man brutally tossed about by circumstances beyond his control.  Ian’s one goal in life is to reunite with his sister but events continually conspire to keep her out of his grasp.  I’m hesitant to use the word “fate” because that makes it seems as though there is a grand design at work in the story and Ian’s world is much more haphazard and random than that.  At every turn, though, there is a sense of a world almost entirely void of redemption, although the idea of it somehow endures.

Interestingly, throughout the progression of his life we generally see Ian through other people’s eyes (unusual in that this kind of narrative it is usually the object of the journey, i.e. the sister, that would be the mysterious figure).  In particular, his strange history and personality catches the attention of a young journalist named Jim, whose perception of Ian is terrifyingly distant and intimate all at once.   Most often I’m struck by the easy selfishness of the people Ian encounters.   Through them we see terrible things happen to him — some even happen to him before he’s even born – and I wonder now if his faith in the fact he will see his sister again is actually the worst thing that could have ever happened to him.  When that faith finally falls apart it is like the character’s soul is snuffed out and the rest of the story is about what is going to happen to his poor, tired shell.

This is a devastating work and yet I never felt emotionally manipulated by Ono.  She somehow earns every bad thing that happens to Ian and the people close to him.  While the character may seem like a black hole of pure misfortune, there are small moments of relief, perhaps even triumph, in his journey.  The simplistic art style — very different in tone than Ono’s work House of Five Leaves, currently serialized online at SigIkki — gives everything a childish innocence that somehow perfectly captures Ian’s character.  And just like Ian, it allows for memorable representations of grief, enduring faith, and the chilling emptiness of suffering.  not simple is a work that has stayed with me long after I turned the last page and my mind flies back to its story often, like an emotional Chinese finger puzzle that I can’t quite find release from.

This work is highly recommended, particularly to fans of comics slightly off the beaten path.  Ono’s development as a creator is certainly worth watching, although with this release she’s already earned herself a permanent place on my bookshelf.

Review copy provided by Viz.

7 Comments

I got this today and just finished reading it. I did enjoy it a good deal but I didn’t get into quite as much as you did but that may change on further readings. I did enjoy the art a great deal though but Ian’s eyes, and just his eyes, kind of bugged me throughout the story for some reason. I’ve been enjoying House of Five Leaves but not simple has definitely made Ono a must read creator for me.

Eric — Yeah, I’ve become an instant Ono-believer just from this one work. I’m really looking forward to the print edition of House of Five Leaves (I’ve only read the first chapter online and liked it but prefer to hold the book in my hands).

[…] Danielle Leigh on Natsume Ono’s not simple, because glowing reviews of that excellent book cheer me […]

[…] Comic Book Bin) Courtney Kraft on vol. 2 of Ludwig II (Graphic Novel Reporter) Danielle Leigh on not simple (Comics Should Be Good) Lori Henderson on vol. 3 of Princess Resurrection (Manga Xanadu) Sean […]

I got the book just a few days ago, and didn’t give it a second glance until I got it home, I cracked it open and started reading..

It took me three times, reading it front to back to kind of grab hold of what was happening. Holy crap! This guys life sucks! One turn after another the book gets worse and worse but you still love reading it, (I also noticed on the very last page of the book Jim is wearing Ian’s clothes– or clothes that look alike, I wonder if that meant he was spiraling downward too.) Still, wonderful book! Tragic, confusing, and simple not simple!! XD

(I got kinda upset at the STD part :( AS IF HIS LIFE DIDN’T SUCK ENOUGH *POOF* YAAY, YOU HAVE AN STD~ ) D8 I like her art style, it’s a lot like mine, very inspiring. :3

hi Kio …yes….I’d love to be more specific about how UPSETTING everything is but I’m afraid of spoiling people who might get curious and check out the conversation.

And I think Ono’s style is very interesting, particularly since I know she adapts it to the particular story she’s telling.

[…] would be her family melodrama not simple (Viz). Now, I liked this book quite a bit, and so did some other folks, but critical responses have been undeniably […]

Leave a Comment

 

Categories

Review Copies

Comics Should Be Good accepts review copies. Anything sent to us will (for better or for worse) end up reviewed on the blog. See where to send the review copies.

Browse the Archives