web stats

CSBG Archive

What I bought – 3 February 2010

Turkish influence would have been better for Georgia than Russian influence, because Atatürk took a backward Turkey and made it modern, while Lenin and Stalin took a directionless Russia and made it backward. (Robert Kaplan, from Eastward to Tartary)

Oh, Tracy, you crazy fool! I love this cover Subliminal sexual imagery?  Check! Well, that can't end well ... Only the first Zorro book this week! More Zorro than you can handle!

CriminalSinners4Criminal: The Sinners #4 by Ed Brubaker (writer), Sean Phillips (artist), and Val Staples (colorist). $3.50, 26 pgs, FC, Marvel/Icon.

You don’t know how much I want to write what I want to write about Criminal just to piss Ed Brubaker off. I dig that he reads the blog, but he always focuses on the one thing I write about Criminal, and I while I agree with him that I shouldn’t write it because it’s kind of silly, I do wish he’d appreciate that I love this goddamned book, because it’s such an intense read. So I won’t write it, Ed, even though I’m dying to so I can make you all apoplectic.

Because, let’s face it, this is a tremendous comic book. I always say it’s hard to write about it, because Brubillips is absolutely at the top of his game here. I really enjoy what Brubaker has done with Captain America, but Criminal blows it out of the water. With Captain America, we never get the sense that anything matters, even though Steve took a bullet in the gut and stayed away for a few years. With Criminal, however, we get the sense that all of this means something. When Tracy tells Mrs. Hyde that he’s not going to run, he says, “I have to keep my word.” She asks him why, and he says, “… That’s what I do …” In four words and two ellipses, Brubaker gives us both Tracy’s unwavering loyalty and code by which he lives and the fact that he doesn’t really want to live that way, but he has no choice. Of course he could run, and no one would think worse of him. Of course he wants to run, because he’d probably live longer. But he won’t, because that’s not who he is, as much as he wants it to be. We may think he’s foolish, but that’s who he is. Brubaker has done this consistently throughout this series – he creates characters that we might not like, might not even understand, but who are so fully realized that we can’t help but follow them where they have to go. Tracy may or may not pay for his attitude with his life, but the way he moves through this story is the only way he can move through the story.

Phillips continues to dazzle, and his contribution and Staples’ are even harder to write about, because it seems so flawless. These are characters who get shot, fall out of windows, and lie on the ground, hurt. These are characters who see the look in someone’s eye and realize that they’re not deserving of death. These are characters who see something they wish they could unsee, and the only way we know it is because of how Phillips draws them. These are people moving through a neon-lit world, which Staples makes hellish just by the hues he uses. It’s astonishing.

So, I tried to explain how good Criminal is. You really ought to check it out. Plus, this damned comic makes me want to watch Mr. Majestyk, which Joe Hill even admits isn’t that great a movie. Damn it!!!!

One panel of awesome:

He totally meant to do that!

He totally meant to do that!

Demo1Demo #1 (of 6) (“The Waking Life of Angels”) by Brian Wood (writer), Becky Cloonan (artist), and Jared K. Fletcher (letterer). $2.99, 26 pgs, BW, DC/Vertigo.

Demo, in case you don’t know, is an early Brian Wood/Becky Cloonan comic from a half-dozen years ago that was originally published by AiT/Planet Lar. Then, when Wood took the rights with him to DC, Vertigo put out a trade a while back. It’s a collection of single-issue stories about teenagers who sort-of have superpowers. None of them wear costumes, and the powers are vaguely defined, but that’s a good very general description. It was well received, and both Wood and Cloonan went on to other things, but now they’re back with new stories. Why not? This time around, however, I don’t even know if they’re sticking with the original concept, because the first story does not feature a teenager and her superpower, if we can call it that, isn’t much of one. So there’s that. Why is this still called Demo? I don’t know. I’m not even sure why the first series was called Demo. I guess it’s just name recognition for people who bought the original series, which is perfectly fine.

Story continues below

Here’s the thing: I’m not a huge fan of the first series. It’s not terrible, but it’s nothing special, either. Wood has done better work, and even some of the stuff he did back then, when he was a bit raw, is better (Couscous Express comes to mind). But Wood has gotten better, so I thought I’d give the new series a chance. I mean, it’s only 3 bucks, right? And I flipped through the book, and damn, is Cloonan good. I mean, I know she’s good, but this is a really gorgeous book. Even if the writing wasn’t any good, it’s almost worth it for the art alone. Cloonan makes the point in the backmatter that she was drawing the original series in different styles (you can tell), and it appears she’s going to do that in this series (there’s a brief preview of issue #2 in the back), which is kind of neat. I don’t know if each issue is going to look as good as this, but dang, this one is excellent.

The problem is Wood’s story. Now, it’s fairly well established that I’m just not too bright. Hey, it happens. I’m sure that someone will understand this story, but I don’t. I’ve said before that fiction, for me, has to be of one of two types: It has to have a slam-bang plot, or it has to feature characters who are interesting. Unfortunately, “The Waking Life of Angels” has neither. I don’t really care that it doesn’t have a plot – this series is supposed to be about people coming to terms with a giant change in their lives. In Joan’s case, it’s apparently being able to see the future. She’s a corporate drone in San Francisco who, at the beginning of the story, hasn’t slept in nine days because of a spooky dream she had. She’s dreaming of a cathedral, and there’s someone on a railing about to jump, and a man who is either trying to stop her or save her. Joan has no idea who the person is (she knows it’s a woman, but that’s all), nor where the cathedral is. And it’s haunting her. She discovers that it’s St. Paul’s in London, so she dumps her boyfriend (who brought up the fact that she was seeing the future but wasn’t being serious, even though Joan realizes that’s what she’s doing), quits her job, and flies to England on a maxed-out credit card. But she has no idea what she’s supposed to be looking for when she gets there. That’s a problem.

Wood doesn’t really pull any tricks on the reader – I wouldn’t call the “twist” at the end a twist at all, because if I can see it coming, it can’t be that clever (it gets back to those smarts I don’t possess). I don’t even really think it’s a “twist,” because I just assumed Joan was being obtuse about the dream. But that’s not the point. The point is that she is driven to do things she wouldn’t normally do, and Wood wants us to see how a tortured soul tries to find relief. That’s not a bad idea in and of itself, but it doesn’t feel like Wood does enough. Joan might not have slept in over a week, but she doesn’t act like it. She just acts like a mean person who cares so much about someone she doesn’t know that she doesn’t care about people she does know. Wood, I presume, wants us to see how she’s driven to be this way, but because of the format, we don’t know enough about Joan to care. On page 7, she assaults a person at work just to get information about her dream, and because we haven’t gotten a sense of her problem yet, she comes off as a bit unhinged and, well, mean. We know only that her boyfriend dismissed her dream after she told him about it, but not if he kept being a jerk for the entire nine days. The first time she had the dream, it was just a dream. Saying, as a joke, that she could see the future and then moving on sounds like a real-life conversation. But Joan never tells us if her boyfriend kept dismissing it, so the fact that she dumps him makes her sound, well, mean. So by the time gets to London, it’s hard to care about her predicament. It’s interesting that Wood sets himself this limit of a single issue to tell these stories, but that makes it more difficult to create a compelling character. Wood can do it, but he doesn’t really in this issue.

Story continues below

But damn, this issue looks great. As we can see in this one panel of awesome:

Fact: Becky Cloonan is awesome.

Fact: Becky Cloonan is awesome.

LoneRanger20The Lone Ranger #20 by Brett Matthews (writer), Sergio Cariello (artist), Marcelo Pinto (colorist), and Simon Bowland (letterer). $3.50, 22 pgs, FC, Dynamite Entertainment.

Here’s something odd. I never got The Lone Ranger #19. Issue #18 came out in September, and issue #19 was solicited in the September Previews, but I never got it. It’s kind of weird, because my shoppe is good about ordering stuff that’s not from DC and Marvel, and they usually get plenty of Dynamite comics anyway. I’ll have to ask them what happened to issue #19, because I was wondering what the heck was going on at the beginning of this issue. But I wasn’t sure if I had just forgotten what happened due to this book’s wildly erratic shipping schedule. So now I’m bummed.

Because the cover kind of gives away what happened at the end of last issue, I guess. Tonto and Linda Reid, John’s sister-in-law, have been getting busy, I suppose. The horror of miscegenation!!!!!! I do like how John was thinking he had a shot with Linda (as her husband, John’s brother, was killed in the first issue of the series), and according to the Old Testament, he probably should (as we see here in the Brick Testament, although Linda has a son, so I don’t think it applies – I just love the Brick Testament), but isn’t that kind of icky? I mean, my sister-in-law is married, but I wouldn’t consider hooking up with her – she’s like my sister! Ew. Anyway, that seems to be the big news from last issue.

Of course, it’s another slow burn issue of The Lone Ranger, meaning that John has to deal with the fact that the blonde hottie in his life digs the hunky Indian more than the masked man while Cavendish plans his move against our heroes. I mean, it’s an enjoyable comic, and Matthews and Cariello do such a good job with mood and thousand-yard stares and pregnant pauses, but the book does move slowly. I don’t mind, even if I’d like the book to come out sooner. Oh well. It’s a good comic, as usual.

One panel of awesome:

The things you learn from comics!

The things you learn from comics!

Scalped34Scalped #34 (“The Gnawing: Conclusion”) by Jason Aaron (writer), R. M. Guéra (artist), Giulia Brusco (colorist), and Steve Wands (letterer). $2.99, 22 pgs, FC, DC/Vertigo.

At some point, I want to address Rob Schmidt’s objections to Scalped. I think that would be fun. I certainly agree with him that it doesn’t portray Indians positively. However, as I’ve pointed out, it’s a noir title. It doesn’t portray anyone positively. From Scalped, we can assume that all white FBI agents are racist assholes, and that all black people are shifty con men. From Criminal, we can assume that all white people are, well, criminals. And sluts. Schmidt has pointed out that Aaron claims this is “how things are” on the rez, and he has a point there, too. That’s why I want to address it some other time, because he has a lot of interesting objections to Scalped. But I still think it’s fantastic. “The Gnawing” concludes with several nice twists, as Aaron gets Dash out of the world of shit it appeared he was in, while Red Crow himself gets out of the Hmong disaster in his own inimitable way. As we know the series is continuing, I can’t imagine those are that spoilery, but I certainly won’t say how they do it. What’s fascinating, as always, is how Aaron puts these characters through all of this crap and how they make it through. It’s an amazingly intense experience.

And then we get to the end. I will SPOIL this, because it’s not too spoilery and it’s going to become more important as the series goes on. Carol, Red Crow’s daughter and Dash’s lover, finds out she’s pregnant. This annoyed me. Pregnancy is kind of a lame way to advance a plot, and I wish Aaron hadn’t brought it up. There are a few reasons for this: Carol, it seems to me, would have an abortion without even telling Dash (who we presume is the father; is Carol even married anymore?) – she doesn’t seem like the kind of person who would think twice about it. So this isn’t even a dramatic plot point. I assume Aaron isn’t going to do that, because, as I’ve pointed out before, even though abortion is a legal procedure and this is a Vertigo book (so it deals with “mature” themes), I very much doubt a company like DC would touch something as controversial as abortion. So Aaron is going to have to kill off the kid through a miscarriage, or he’s going to have to change Carol’s character so she wants the kid. I’d like the second option more, but I’m not sure if Aaron is going to be able to pull it off. We’ll see. I just wish he hadn’t brought it up. People can have sex without getting pregnant, after all, even if they don’t use protection.

Story continues below

That’s a minor complaint, at least for now. This is still a fantastic issue, which isn’t surprising. It will be nifty to see where Aaron goes next with the series.

One panel of awesome:

The Hmongs really should have known better than to fuck with Lincoln Red Crow!

The Hmongs really should have known better than to fuck with Lincoln Red Crow!

Zorro19Zorro #19 by Matt Wagner (writer), Francesco Francavilla (artist), and Simon Bowland (letterer). $3.50, 23 pgs, FC, Dynamite Entertainment.

Here’s another series from Dynamite that I struggle to write about, because we know pretty much what we’re going to get, but Wagner and Francavilla do it so well. Wagner continues with his Rashomon-esque story, as General Mancado gets around to asking the magistrate of Los Angeles about his experiences with Zorro. It’s a fun little story, mainly because Quintero narrates the story as if he’s heroic, while Wagner and Francavilla show us differently (one of those things that comics does so well). Wagner can still show us what kind of person Zorro is while revealing more about Quintero (yes, we already knew he’s a weasel, but still). Plus, there’s an interlude with Diego and Lolita that tells us a lot about their relationship and how Lolita feels about it. It’s brought to wonderful life by Francavilla, whose pencil work continues to be outstanding and whose colors continue to dazzle. In the “present,” he tones down the colors, makes the book dusty (befitting its desert locale), but works in enough primary colors (such as in Lolita’s garden) to show how the Spanish are bringing life to it. In the flashbacks, he continues to give us an abundance of red, making Zorro’s appearances much more lurid, which aligns closely with how the people are seeing him. Francavilla is really good – Wagner’s entertaining yarns are fun, but Francavilla gives the book a nice edge. I don’t know if he’ll be back after this story arc or if he’s going to work more for the Big Two, but for now, he’s an excellent fit on the comic.

One panel of awesome:

That Zorro - such a scamp!

That Zorro - such a scamp!

ZorroMatanzas1Zorro: Matanzas #1 (of 4) by Don McGregor (writer), Mike Mayhew (artist), Sam Parsons (colorist), and John Costanza (letterer), and Kel-O-Graphics (digital inker). $3.99, 24 pgs, FC, Dynamite Entertainment.

Speaking of Zorro, Dynamite gives us this four-issue mini-series, which is unusual, to say the least. First of all, it was supposed to come out after the current series’ latest arc was done, and that still has at least one issue to go (Dynamite offered it as a substitute while the regular series took a “well-deserved break”). Now, Zorro might be running late, so couldn’t Dynamite have delayed this so that it would, indeed, replace the regular series rather than running a bit concurrently with it? It’s weird scheduling. The more interesting thing about this comic is that it’s over a decade old but has never been printed before. According to Mike Mayhew, he began drawing it in 1997. According to Don McGregor, it was supposed to see print in 1999. It was for the old Zorro series from Topps back when Topps published comics, but when they went under, it never came out. Mayhew has changed stylistically quite a bit since then (mainly because he paints more than pencils these days), so I have to believe this is completely in the can, or the later issues are going to look a whole lot different than this one. But we’ll see. If it’s not completely finished, maybe Mayhew will try to draw in the style of a decade ago. That would be weird.

It’s interesting to compare and contrast this with the regular series, and with comics in general. It’s not quite as good as Zorro, but it’s still entertaining. McGregor introduces (or re-introduces, I guess) a villain with whom Zorro has tangled in the past, one who lost his hand in battle with our hero. The villain, Lucien Machete, can attach various weapons to his arm, and he has sworn revenge on Zorro, natch. Lucien is also friends with Diego’s father, so Zorro has to keep an eye on him. Don Alejandro and Lucien are off to the Matanzas – the slaughterings (the cover implies they’re slaughtering cattle) – and Diego, of course, must stay behind (much to his father’s chagrin) so Zorro can be present. It’s a set-up issue, but we get plenty of information. Mayhew is perfectly fine – he has some nice page designs, like when Zorro moves through his cave hideout and when we get a cross-section of his hideout and how it connects to the hacienda. He’s not as good as he is today (of course, you might not like Mayhew’s art today, but it’s still better than it was), but it works. It’s probably fine to wait for the trade, because this is very much an opening chapter of a story, rather than a really good single issue.

Story continues below

What’s interesting is how McGregor writes. This is packed full of prose, with an omniscient narrator guiding us through every page, even when it’s not terribly necessary. We get quite a bit of information about Diego himself, which is kind of cool, as McGregor understands that for someone, this might be their first experience with Zorro. McGregor is an old-school writer, and it’s a bit jarring to encounter this comic, as it’s just not how people write anymore. It really does feel like a relic from an earlier time, even though it wasn’t written too long ago. It’s interesting to consider how much comics writing has shifted in the past decade. Even when writers like Moore were experimenting with no narration and no sound effects in V for Vendetta, the majority of mainstream comics still used those styles. In the past ten years, even superhero comics have become less verbose, with writers allowing artists to tell a lot of the story and relying on the reader to make connections. I’m not saying one style is better than the other, but it’s interesting reading this comic, because it’s unlike almost anything you can find out there right now. It feels vaguely like a Marvel comic from the 1970s or 1980s. It’s kind of neat.

If you have to buy one comic with Zorro in it this week, get the Wagner/Francavilla one. But this is a pretty good yarn. I’m curious to see how McGregor works in the slaughtering aspect.

One panel of awesome:

I know it's two panels, but I do like how, in the larger one, we get a progression of the characters

I know it's two panels, but I do like how, in the larger one, we get a progression of the characters

I’m surprised Brian hasn’t pointed this out yet, but if you’re interested, you can ask 1960s Bob Dylan anything. It needs to be updated more often, but it’s pretty funny. But now, let’s check out The Ten Most Recent Songs Played On My iPod (Which Is Always On Shuffle):

1. “I Remember You” – Skid Row (1989)
2. “Better Or Worse” – Liquid Jesus (1991)
3. “Policy Of Truth” – Depeche Mode (1990)
4. “Sexx Laws” – Beck (1999)
5. “But, Honestly” – Foo Fighters (2007)
6. “Push, Push” – Cinderella (1986)
7. “Filthy/Gorgeous” – Scissor Sisters (2004)
8. “Johnny Q.” – Crazy 8s (1984)
9. “Cannonball” – Breeders (1993)
10. “Monkey Wrench” – Foo Fighters (1997)

Last week, in all the kerfuffle, no one got that the totally random lyrics were from “Working for Vacation” by Cibo Matto. Let’s check out some different totally random lyrics:

“You wired me awake
And hit me with a hand of broken nails
You tied my lead and pulled my chain
To watch my blood begin to boil”

That’s all you get today! Have fun!


Heh, hey Greg,

The first volume of Demo was mostly not-teenagers, and was mostly not-(traditional) superpowers, so in that respect this second volume is very much like the first. Why call it Demo? What else would we call it? We’re doing a second volume, after all. In every way we are picking up where we left off.

Anyway, I kinda get where you’re coming from. Demo isn’t structured or written like virtually everything else I’ve done, before or after, and that’s part of its inherent Demo-ness. It’s not a traditional 3-act structure crammed into 22 pages, but something more like a short film, a moment in time, in some cases a single scene, and as such it’s looser and more open to personal interpretation than other stories I write. There is also an element of the fantastical to it that often doesn’t react well when analyzed with cold hard reality.

Some of what you got out of it, though, is just incorrect. Of course she doesn’t assault her work friend. But she is absolutely unhinged, and what she does in the issue is by anyone’s definition, crazy, since they are all on the outside of the problem. Even her boyfriend, who apparently has little time to spend on what she describes as painful.

Demo Vol. 1 was incredibly polarizing, especially in the early days of its run, and I expect these new ones to be the same… perhaps more so as people are bound to compare them to my more “normal” books like DMZ. I just like that people read them and talk about them as much as they do.

Next month: new story, new characters, new genre, new art style courtesy of Becky. See where the format for Northlanders came from? :)


p.s. you are meant to see the ending coming… if not before, it should be crystal clear by the time she takes off her shoes.

That’s soundgarden’s “rusty cage” (i remember those lyrics from a REALLY old Road Rash game on the playstation).

Here’s a funny story: my shop didn’t get any of these comics this week.

Well, it seemed funny in my head before I typed it. (No it didn’t.)

I did finally get “Batman and Robin” #7, a week late.

Is this what it’s like to be a UK comic book reader?

But I DID read Lone Ranger in pdf for my upcoming review.

My review will not be based on a star system this time, but on a moustache system, which is more reliable and more masculine.

Brian: Ah, it’s been a while since I read Demo, so I didn’t recall that many of them weren’t teenagers. Sorry!

“Assault” is probably a too-strong word, but in the context of a corporate setting, Dev could file an assault charge, which is probably a moot point because Joan quits. Legally, it wasn’t physical abuse, but the workplace is often tougher than “real life” in that regard.

I’m glad to see that Joan is kind of supposed to be crazy, because that means I wasn’t completely off-base. But it is interesting how you describe everyone as being “outside the problem.” It’s a good description, but it brings up an interesting conundrum – how would they get on the “inside” of the problem?

Despite me not loving the writing, I’m still intrigued by the rest of the series, mainly because the first Demo was the same way – kind of uneven. I never know which story I’m going to love, so I may have to check them all out! See how I trust you?

Shit!! The first time that I recognize the random lyrics and someone else has already answered. Ah,well, next time! :-)

Well, she and Dev are friends, or at least friendly, and all she does is grab a postcard from him. Maybe if he was a stranger on the street… don’t you have co-workers you are on good enough terms with that you could grab something out of their hands without them calling it “assault”? Although I think this scene is starting to be over-analyzed by both of us.

And “outside the problem” means that the conflict/problem/drama is internal for her… who can know what she’s thinking about, dreaming about, feeling about it all? Even her boyfriend can’t appreciate it enough to have a serious conversation about it, much less help her out. So probably no one but her can be “inside” of this, leaving her the only option of solving it all on her own.


Have Dynamite done a Lone Ranger/Zorro team-up comic?

Personally I prefer McGregor/Mayhew’s Zorro to Wagner/Francavilla but I think you hit the nail on the head comparing the different styles about how McGregor is more old-fashioned. I think it’s a good contrast as Wagner is doing Zorro from a time when he’s still starting out, young fresh and raw and McGregor’s is an older, more confident, refined Zorro.

Michael: No, they haven’t. They’d have to solve some time period differences!

Brian: That’s what I meant. It becomes more interesting if no one can appreciate what she’s going through. And makes her a bit more sympathetic.


February 4, 2010 at 7:09 pm

I assume Aaron isn’t going to do that, because, as I’ve pointed out before, even though abortion is a legal procedure and this is a Vertigo book (so it deals with “mature” themes), I very much doubt a company like DC would touch something as controversial as abortion.

They had a series where god was the bad guy, and at the end they killed him.

Here’s a funny story: my shop didn’t get any of these comics this week.

The jokers at my shop made with the same funny!

Oh how I laughed, and laughed, and laughed, and cried.

I heard it first as a Soundgarden tune, but I will forever hear it as the Man in Black’s.

I’ve never heard of the Brick Testament, but the Old Testament insists that when a married guy dies without issue, his brother must impregnate the widow– the resulting kid will be the dead guy’s heir. (Onan pulled out when he was supposed ot impregnate his brother’s widow, and God struck him dead for it. A few centuries ago, church leaders twisted the story around to become a condemnation of masturbation, which is actually never mentioned in the Bible. Just in case you ever wondered.) But if this Linda already has a kid, then sexual congress with her brother-in-law constitutes incest, and is an abomination before the Lord.
Don’t you love the logic of religious dogma?


February 4, 2010 at 10:01 pm

A few centuries ago, church leaders twisted the story around to become a condemnation of masturbation, which is actually never mentioned in the Bible. Just in case you ever wondered.

I reckon it is.
Jesus follows up a lecture on the evils of lust with ‘and if your hand causes you to sin, cut it off’.
I reckon the two are related, it’s just nobody wrote down the hand gesture he was doing at the time.

In Lone Ranger, Linda wants to be with the Ranger, but he’s all emo and everything. So now she is wanting to go all Paint Your Wagon.


February 4, 2010 at 10:38 pm

So now she is wanting to go all Paint Your Wagon.

But the cover looks like the cave at the end of The Searchers!

Jesus follows up a lecture on the evils of lust with ‘and if your hand causes you to sin, cut it off’.
I reckon the two are related, it’s just nobody wrote down the hand gesture he was doing at the time.

Scholars now believe he was nurpling in that passage.

If Jesus was talking about masturbation with that “if your hand offends you” business, then Curtis Mayfield put it best: “If there’s a hell below, we’re all gonna go.”

I saw Cibo Matto about 10 years ago. I’d never heard of them, but a friend of a friend’s band was the opening act. They opened with a slowed-down cover of “Welcome to the Jungle.” I went out and bought Stereotype A the next day. I heard some solo material from the lead singer (Miko?), but, alas, it didn’t measure up.

So, comics… I read Scalped in trades, so I avoided the spoiler, but, if the picture was any indication of how the story is going, I can’t wait to see Lincoln Red Crow take out the Hmong gangsters. You’re right, Greg, nobody in that comic is very admirable. The only characters I can come up with are the older tribal cop (who is used as a patsy) and the kid in “Dead Mothers” (whose story doesn’t turn out so well).

Greg I look forward to this every week, not so much for what you are reading, but for what you are listening to on your ipod. Every now and again up pops an absolute classic… this week The Breeders – Cannonball.

Always wondered if you listen to all 10 or do you skip any?

FGJ: Yes, really. Preacher’s God could easily be explained away as complete and utter fantasy, just like the rest of the series – there’s a vampire in it, after all – so it wasn’t as controversial. Scalped is obviously meant to be “the real world,” which is where the controversy comes from. I’m not saying DC WON’T allow a character to get an abortion, I would just be really surprised if they did. I’m basing this on the fact that whenever a character in any form of popular entertainment gets pregnant, they never get an abortion. Heck, they barely consider it, even if the character has been established as someone who would make a horrible mother or who has no interest in children. I don’t care what Aaron does with the pregnancy, because he’s good enough that he’ll probably make the story interesting, but I would just be really surprised if she terminates the pregnancy.

Stephen: I listen to all of them. I put them on there, after all, so they must ALL be classics, right? I mean, come on – Skid Row!!!!!

Matthew Johnson

February 5, 2010 at 9:57 am

I really liked “Eastward to Tartary,” and have enjoyed Kaplan’s work in general. Have you read “Soldiers of God”?

Greg: I won’t grant you your foregone conclusion about Scalped. Remember how badly she wanted a kid back in that 2-parter about her losing it? I’d imagine that’s going to come into play. Plus, there’s no guarantee that it’s Dash’s. Just saying.

Although I haven’t read the issue as yet, Aaron has clearly been hinting at Carol’s pregnancy in the last couple issues. And I think the dramatic potential of the pregnancy is enormous, when you consider its implications for Dash’s relationship with Red Crow and his relationship with Carol, not to mention Carol’s relationship with her father. All this is of course assuming she goes ahead with the pregnancy. I don’t think she would have an abortion; not when you consider the fact that she already lost a baby before and the manner in which that happened. What I do think she might consider, however, is leaving the Rez.

Matt: That’s true, and I didn’t like her pain then. If she wants a baby so badly, why does she act like she does? I agree with Andre, that there’s a lot of potential with a baby, and I’m reasonably confident that Aaron will make it a decent story arc, but given what we know about Carol – not what she says she wants, but how she acts – I have a hard time believing she’d want a baby. But hey – that’s why I hope Aaron can convince me!

Matthew: I actually haven’t read Soldiers of God. It’s one of the few by Kaplan that I haven’t read. I don’t know why – I’ll probably have to rectify that!

I’d hijack your column for a debate on SCALPED, but it would be wrong. This column is about your reviews in general, not SCALPED in particular.

That’s why I’d love to devote a specific column to it, Rob!

I agree with your point about Ginas pregnancy but I also could see her getting an abortion in a second.

Maybe you should just wait until Scalped finishes up as a series since alot of the early criticism (like alot of the characters being one note bad guys compared to the characters on the Sopranos/wire ect ) has been revealed to be completely off the mark in the issues since.


February 7, 2010 at 4:26 pm

Scalped is obviously meant to be “the real world,” which is where the controversy comes from.

I’d argue that, which is why I disagree with Rob Schmidt about Scalped being racist.

It’s as much the real world as Criminal or 100 Bullets, which whilst they don’t have superheroes, are not the real world.

I’m basing this on the fact that whenever a character in any form of popular entertainment gets pregnant, they never get an abortion. Heck, they barely consider it, even if the character has been established as someone who would make a horrible mother or who has no interest in children.

Well, I’d say that’s because there’s more drama in a character having a baby than getting an abortion.
They get an abortion, there’ either no drama as they are fine with it, or they get really depressed afterwards.
You can put the characters through a lot more hell and drama if they go ahead an have the baby.
I’m only going by the trades, but if she’s still smacking it up as much as she was last time, I’d be surprised if she could carry a baby to term.

Leave a Comment



Review Copies

Comics Should Be Good accepts review copies. Anything sent to us will (for better or for worse) end up reviewed on the blog. See where to send the review copies.

Browse the Archives