web stats

CSBG Archive

Danielle Leigh’s Reading Diary — Dorohedoro volume 1

In Dorohedoro, manga creator Q Hayashida takes a matter-of-fact approach to dismemberment, human experimentation and beheading by reptile jaws, resulting in a wickedly funny gross-out comic.


Before I read the book, I had heard Dorohedoro described as a comic told from the point of view of the “monster.”   This is accurate to a large degree since the main character — Caiman — is a literal monster, having been turned into a half-reptile half-human mashed up being by a “sorcerer,” which in this universe appear to be human beings with magical powers and absolutely no sense of morality.   In an absurd and hilarious extra at the end of the book it is hinted that “The Devil” himself may be their ultimate office manager.

In Caiman’s town, which is known as “the Hole,” sorcerers descend upon the town and pluck humans off the street in order to experiment on them.  Powerful sorcerers can turn humans into something like Caiman, while lowly sorcerers often mangle the poor victim’s body and force a slow agonizing death upon the person.  Fun times, right?  Actually, everyone is so blasé about this existence as kind of normal, that a lot of humor comes from their almost flat reactions to the most hellish of experiences. 

Caiman doesn’t remember who experimented upon him or his original human identity, so he’s on a mission to find the bastard responsible for his current state.  His strategy to locate that person is to place suspected sorcerers in his mouth in order to be seen by “man” inside his reptile mouth (possibly his original self) and have the two communicate since Caiman is unable to question this mysterious phantom self directly.  Once the sorcerer is extracted from his jaws and tells him what his little man said (usually “You aren’t the one”), Caiman cheerfully beheads them.  If they’re lucky he uses a knife, if not…well.  He’s got some awesome reptile jaws and he knows how to use them.

“Good” and “evil” seem like trite, almost quaint notions that just don’t apply to this world or its inhabitants.  Caiman kills people who enjoy making human beings their quasi-“scientific” playthings, and Caiman enjoys killing them.  While I found myself squeamish about some of the more “body parts are flying” violence sequences, this was an incredibly compelling and often very funny read.  The art is rough as hell, somehow scratchy and structural all at once, and is an absolutely perfect vehicle to tell this story.

Dorohedoro‘s unusual treatment of its disturbing subject makes this comic a must read for fans of either horror tales or of sly, smart humor.


Yeah, I’m pretty much gonna need this.

Danielle Leigh

April 29, 2010 at 4:54 pm

It is way awesome. I picked it up because I can’t NOT pick up new VizSig releases but I was delighted to discover it was weird and wonderful.

Sounds pretty awesome. I’ll have to see what the art actually looks like inside before I commit though… I’m already buying a buttload of manga.

Danielle Leigh

April 30, 2010 at 8:34 am

hi Joe — it might be shrink-wrapped at the store but it looks like you can preview it on the Viz website:

[…] (The Manga Critic) Julie Opipari on vol. 16 of D.Gray-Man (Manga Maniac Cafe) Danielle Leigh on vol. 1 of Dorohedoro (Comics Should Be Good) Erica Friedman on El Cazador (Okazu) AstroNerdBoy on vol. 9 of Gakuen Alice […]

I’ve read a few reviews of this title, but yours is the first to really open my eyes to its awesome potential. I think the blasé reactions would be what appeals to me the most.

Danielle Leigh

May 3, 2010 at 5:18 pm

hee! I’m so glad…I was really surprised by this work. I’ve never really read anything quite like it, which is always exciting (particularly when it’s *innovative* and *well done*).

Leave a Comment



Review Copies

Comics Should Be Good accepts review copies. Anything sent to us will (for better or for worse) end up reviewed on the blog. See where to send the review copies.

Browse the Archives