web stats

CSBG Archive

She Has No Head! – Review: Neil Young’s Greendale

Neil Young’s Greendale.  Joshua Dysart (writer).  Cliff Chiang (art).  Dave Stewart (colors).  Greendale CoverTodd Klein (letters).  Karen Berger (editor).  Vertigo.  160 pages.  Color.  Hardcover.  $19.99

I’ve mentioned my as yet unpublished novel a few times before in this column because it happened to relate cursorily to whatever I was talking about that week.  But there’s nothing cursory about how Joshua Dysart’s adaptation of Neil Young’s Greendale relates to my novel.

Fortunately (and with a huge sigh of relief) plot-wise they are in no way similar, however what Dysart has created in his adaption is exactly the type of powerful female myth, legend, and feminist modern fairy tale that I hoped to create in my own book.  When I looked to superheroes (and make no mistake, despite the lack of colorful pajamas, Sun is a superhero) I found a real lack in strong female characters set up the way Sun is set up here – as the uncontested powerful star with a history of powerful female ancestors and an epic destiny set before her.  It was a lack of truly great stories like that for women that inspired me to try it myself, and I am really excited to see one here, so beautifully executed by Young, Dysart, Chiang, and Stewart.

Greendale is the story of Sun Green, a teenager coming of age in Greendale, California and set against a timely landscape of political unrest, war, and environmental crisis.  Sun, guided by tragedy, ancestral gifts and instinct, and some seriously intense prophetic dreams, is trying to find her way and purpose in life which includes embracing her ancestry, finding love, trusting herself, and rising up to take a stand, but at it’s core it’s simply the well-worn tale of discovering yourself, and perhaps more importantly accepting yourself.

Everything here is interesting.  The environmental crisis, which though a bit dated since it’s so specific, still feels wholly relevant to what is going on in the United States yesterday, today, and I’m sure, tomorrow.  The set up of Sun as a “special” girl essentially since birth is built into the story from literally panel one and creates a great tapestry of the history and future of the Greens.  Every aspect of this story is well-explored and expertly layered, subtly laying down all the necessary elements one by one as Dysart raises the stakes page by page.

The entire piece is engaging and well done, but as a feminist I was most impressed with the fact that the basic mythology of the Greens (and Oaks to a lesser degree) sets up the female characters as the power houses and the males, while still great characters, act more as the important but vulnerable aspects of these womens’ lives.  There was nothing anti-male in the book at all (it’s a sad but all too common misconception that something with a feminist slant or a strong female perspective is somehow anti-male) it’s simply a graphic novel that happens to star powerful women that have fathers, brothers, grandfathers, friends, and boyfriends that they love, but that are not the center of the story, instead allowing the women to be the source of power and the cogs upon which the story turns.  Honestly?  It was nice to see.  It doesn’t mean I don’t love stories that star men…it just means that it’s nice to see a brilliant work that stars women sometimes too.

I wonder if Dysart realized that he was creating such a significant feminist work.  I know if I had been collaborating with Neil Young on adapting a work he was so invested in it would have been the thing farthest from my mind (read: I would have been worrying myself into an early grave).  And yet what has emerged is a significant and decidedly feminist work that really helps broaden the field of great female focused graphic novels available today.

greendale 1 copy

greendale 2 copy

So should we talk about the art and the fact that it is mind-blowingly beautiful?  Yeah, let’s talk about that.  Cliff Chiang’s pencils are nothing short of stunning.  He’s created such a cohesive and fully realized world for Sun that you doubt nothing.  Everything is executed with precision and grace, feeling both loose and expressive and crisp and clean simultaneously.  Chiang’s storytelling is always both clear and beautiful, somehow never having to sacrifice one for the other, as many artists do, and Greendale is no exception.  He illustrates Sun’s every day life, the history of the Green’s, and Sun’s vivid and prophetic dreams all with the same attention to detail and dedication to good storytelling.

It’s also important to note that without Chiang’s equally as female positive art, much of what lands this solidly as a feminist work would have been lost.  A Sun with 36 double d’s falling out of her tank top and mini-skirt are visuals that certainly would have undone or at least severely undercut the vision that Dysart (and Young) were aiming for.  And it’s a great example of why character design is so important and why here it’s a perfect fit.  The Sun Dysart is writing, looks exactly like the Sun Chiang is drawing, and vice versa.  Chiang’s work, as always in my experience, is so in touch with the tone of the story he’s bringing to life, that it’s nearly a seamless collaboration…a nearly perfect merging of word and picture…as if Dysart and Chiang were one.

Greendale 3r

Greendale 4

Greendale 5

Greendale 6

Greendale 7

The colors, by Dave Stewart are sublime in their execution.  Everything slightly soft and faded, except for the occasional well considered hard blacks and reds.  It’s all wonderfully constructed and it’s somehow considered to the point of obsession while still feeling natural and easy.

Visually there’s very little hard black and white in this book, trending more toward softer earth tones, which fits both tonally and thematically and suggests a real care of construction.  The kind of care you usually get (and expect) from single creators (David Mazzucchelli’s Asterios Polyp springs to mind as a good recent example) but rather than a sole creator working towards their own personal vision,  you have here what feels like a finely tuned orchestra all working together to achieve perfection.

And they get shockingly close.

The edition itself is lovely and really lives up to the talent and themes of the book.  The gorgeous embossed cover sans dust jacket (a personal favorite of mine stylistically) really stands out and elevates the book beyond your average graphic novel.  The end papers are beautiful Chiang illustrated family trees and maps of Greendale.  The actual paper is a matte finish that almost has a tooth to it and that carries Stewart’s colors perfectly.  Also appropriately, the book is stamped ‘sustainable forestry initiative’.  My sole complaint about the edition is that the gutters at the binding are almost non-existent, causing some images to get slightly lost in the crease (and also making it a real bitch to scan).  But otherwise it’s stunning – something that can sit proudly on your shelves for years to come.

I think Dysart and Chiang have created a work that can easily stand on its own without foreknowledge of everything Greendale.  Personally, I’m familiar with the album (but not obsessively so) but haven’t seen the film, art books, theater productions, or website, etc., and so I come to it somewhat in the know, but far shy of those who are experts in all things Greendale.   With my limited experience the book easily stands on its own for me, yet it still feels respectful of the source material – I have trouble imagining a Greendale purist taking issue with such a beautiful, well-executed book.  It’s no easy task to straddle those two extremes (uber fan and virgin) but Dysart and Chiang do it and make it appear effortless.

Neil Young’s Greendale released on June 15th, 2010 and is available in book shops and comic stores everywhere and online at Amazon.

15 Comments

Thanks for reviewing this. Had no idea it was in the works. My Dad is the ultimate Young fan. This will be a great gift for him (although a little late).

Looks interestings. Good review. I look forward to check out Greendale and your forthcoming novel.

Is the environmental crisis dated because it’s not about oil destroying the gulf of Mexico? I mean, Greendale is what, seven years old? Have we resolved anything in that period? Is it dated because green is not hip now? I was completely sidetracked at that comment.

@Joe: It’s dated in the sense that it’s very specific in the book what environmental crisis Sun is reacting to (relating to Alaska and drilling) but as I said in the post:

“The environmental crisis, which though a bit dated since it’s so specific, still feels wholly relevant to what is going on in the United States yesterday, today, and I’m sure, tomorrow.”

it’s still incredibly relevant since we are currently, were yesterday, and likely will be tomorrow and for the foreseeable future in an environmental crisis. The fact that it’s about drilling in Alaska also makes it especially timely considering the massive problems in the gulf.

weird that nobody’s commenting on this, so i’ll jump in!
i am completely unfamiliar with Neil Young outside of his soundtrack/score for Dead Man, but Josh Dysart is good and Cliff Chiang’s stuff looks good so maybe i’ll pick this up, it sounds pretty good even if it has destiny or whatever in it. ;)

is the guy character’s name really Earth, though? XD is there a scene where he and Sun comment on the weird correlation of their names? Sun: “wow, your name is Earth?! it’s like it’s symbolic or something! what a coincidence!” hehheh.

i really dig the faded out/brown linework, that’s a great effect. is the book really printed on definitely sustainable forest paper for sure? i wish i could do that, i wish i could pull strings to get that for my books, too.

@ross: Totally depressing to me that nobody is commenting on this post…such a great book…it deserves comment and discussion!

The destiny stuff isn’t too heavy…the ancestor stuff is pretty heavy, but the destiny is light :)

No, the guys name isn’t Earth…it’s a joke from earlier in the book…kind of him making fun of her name, but in a nice non-jerky “hey I think I’m charming but really I’m cheesy” kind of way, and then she kind of punishes him by continuing to call him that.

The brown linework was so effective here – I agree completely. It is stamped in the credits ‘sustainable forestry’ so I think they’re serious, and considering the content it certainly makes sense.

Poor Todd Klein. He doesn’t get a link!

I was on the fence about this book, and I’m not sure if you’ve pushed me over or not. I love Chiang’s work and Dysart is generally good, but it just sounded so very hippie-ish. Now I’m more intrigued. I’ll have to flip through it when next I see it. And it wouldn’t kill DC to bring out a softcover version within the next five years!

@Greg: If it helps any I’m pretty hippie averse but it felt more superhero-y and maybe activist-y than hippie to me.

A softcover would be nice, but for a book this good looking, a hardcover is a great edition to really stand the test of time…it’s worth it.

Hmm…

I like Neil Young, but don’t know Greendale.
I think Cliff Chiang is one of the best artists around at the moment.
I really hated Dysart’s Violent Messiah’s and Swamp Thing.

I’m really not sure whether to try this.

Mike Loughlin

June 22, 2010 at 5:14 am

I’m a huge Neil Young fan, but I tend to shy away from comics associated with celebrities. (Tekno Comics, anyone?) I’ll probably try this one, though, as it looks good. I’ve only listened to Greendale once, and didn’t love it, so I have no idea how the comic and album relate. Could be worse, though: Re-Ac-Tor: The Comic. *shudder*

Tom Fitzpatrick

June 22, 2010 at 5:32 am

That female character with the green leaf on her face looks similiar to one of the Astro City covers (Dark Age Book Four # 2 or 3, I think) and something out of the Swamp Thing series.

Neil Young, who? (just kidding) ;-)

I loved this book a lot, and this review perfectly summed up why. Posted a link over at Josh/Cliff’s message board, so hopefully they’ll wander across and take in the love too.

Really great review of an incredible and unique book.

Thanks for reviewing this, I had never heard about it but I am adding it to my wishlist.

[…] life as a independent film, and was released this month by Vertigo (an offshoot of DC Comics) to rave reviews from […]

[…] First off…Last week I should have mentioned Neil Young’s Greendale, the graphic novel by Joshua Dysart, Cliff Chiang, and Dave Stewart, which is excellent and most certainly a BUY. You can read a more detailed post about it and a preview, here. […]

Leave a Comment

 

Categories

Review Copies

Comics Should Be Good accepts review copies. Anything sent to us will (for better or for worse) end up reviewed on the blog. See where to send the review copies.

Browse the Archives