web stats

CSBG Archive

Blue Moon Reviews — Darker Than Black

Based on the anime by the same name, this two-volume series (collected in an omnibus edition) depicts a side mission of the series’ main character, Hei. The characters are pretty interesting and the basic framework of the story has potential. If only the plot made more sense!

darkerthanblackDarker Than Black
Story by BONES and Tensai Okamura, Scenario by Saikoa Hasumi, Art by NOKIYA
Yen Press, 384 pp.
Rating: Older Teen

Score: C+

In the world of Darker Than Black, a strange dimension known as Hell’s Gate has suddenly appeared in the middle of Tokyo. Coinciding with this event, some humans sacrifice their souls to become “contractors,” people without emotions who are able to control “the powers of darkness.” One such contractor is Hei, who works for a shadowy syndicate while searching for his missing sister. The government built a wall to block out sight of Hell’s Gate, so most normal people don’t even know contractors exist.

In this manga side story—serialized in Asuka, a magazine aimed at female teens—Hei encounters Kana Shinoh, a high school girl whose world is thrown into a tizzy when she spots her dead father walking down the street talking on a cell phone to some guy named Klang. As she tries to figure out what’s going on, Kana makes enemies of Klang somehow, who sends a couple of his minions to kill her, including her own father. Hei protects her reluctantly, but not as unkindly as someone presumably without emotions might be expected to do.

You’ll notice my usage of the word “somehow,” which could really be a theme word for this volume. Within a scene it’s easy to follow what’s going on, but the story lacks a strong sense of cause and effect and never seems to come together in a cohesive whole. In its second half, and I suspect that this is in an attempt to tug at the heartstrings of its audience, the focus shifts from attacks on Kana to showing how Klang really isn’t a bad guy, he’s just misunderstood. You see, he’s lonely and sad and everything he did was for love, so that makes it all okay, right?

There are some interesting ideas here—and I did like Hei and his talking cat companion, Mao—but I’m left scratching my head over many things. Perhaps having seen the anime first would’ve helped, but I honestly don’t think so: the flaws are in the construction of the story, not in its concept or central characters. A story should be able to make you care when someone’s mother is taken hostage or when revealing the existence of a program to imbue an army of puppet soldiers with contractors’ stolen powers, but this one simply can’t.

But, y’know, bright side: talking cat!

The Darker Than Black omnibus is available now.


I actually think watching the anime will clear up some of the weirdness of it all. Like, Hei, for example, is shown to be a little different than most “contractors” precisely because he seems to be more emotional than the others. That said, I think the anime has some of the same problems as you pointed out in the manga (interesting premise but flawed execution)

And yes, Mao is very cool.

There’s a little bit of attention on how he seems pretty much like a normal person, but not much. I mean, I honestly did think this was a decent read, but I just don’t think I can honestly recommend it, or at least not without mentioning its drawbacks, too.

[…] Bakuman (I Reads You) Leroy Douresseaux on vol. 3 of Biomega (The Comic Book Bin) Michelle Smith on Darker Than Black (Comics Should Be Good!) Sean Gaffney on vol. 12 of Gakuen Alice (A Case Suitable for Treatment) […]

I’m glad to know I wasn’t the only one who found this manga kind of confusing. The talking cat sidekick was a plus for me, too, but on the whole, I had a hard time remembering what the story was about when I finished reading it.

Yeah, all the pieces just didn’t add up. But even so, I still kind of liked it. I’ve certainly read worse things! :)

The anime is good
The manga is bad
I think the manga sucked while the anime was interesting and fun to watch

Leave a Comment



Review Copies

Comics Should Be Good accepts review copies. Anything sent to us will (for better or for worse) end up reviewed on the blog. See where to send the review copies.

Browse the Archives