web stats

CSBG Archive

Frantic as a cardiograph scratching out the lines, Day 4: JLA: Act of God #2

Every day this month, I will be examining the first pages of random comics. Today’s page is from JLA: Act of God #2, which was published by DC and is cover dated 2001. Enjoy!

Smile, Luthor! Just once?

JLA: Act of God is an Elseworlds comic written by Doug Moench, drawn by Dave Ross, inked by George Freeman, colored by Ben DiMagmaliw, and lettered by Kurt Hathaway. It was one of those “Prestige Format” books that DC used to published, with nicer card stock covers and longer stories with, presumably, more consequences (of course, they were usually shuffled off to “Elseworlds” so that the consequences wouldn’t affect the “real” DCU, but occasionally they were actually set in the “real” one, too).

If you notice from that first page, Moench tells us pretty much every thing we need to know in the first caption box: a “black light event … rendered Earth’s super-powered heroes powerless.” In this new world, “technology now reigns supreme.” A robot driven by someone who is very angry is attacking the Lexcorp complex after killing Steel, and Luthor is pissed off in general. That’s all we learn from the writing, but that’s not bad considering there are only 73 words on the page. We certainly don’t know if any of this makes Act of God a good comic (it does, in fact, not), but at least Moench gets us up to speed quickly.

Ross doesn’t waste a lot of space, either. The page isn’t complicated, although it’s laid out, we might think, counter-intuitively – why is the title on the upper right when we read left to right? One thing I remember from journalism class in college is that newspapers put their most important story on the right, not necessarily at the top but definitely above the fold, because that’s where the eye goes naturally. So the title, while not in the spot where we think we would read it first, is actually where it should be. Meanwhile, Ross draws the eye from the dialogue of the robot-driver down to the robot’s “fist” and then straight to the dialogue balloon above Luthor’s panel. It’s economical and efficient. Only when we step back and look at the whole do we notice Steel’s twisted and broken body in the foreground of the first panel. Ross doesn’t draw all the viscera, but the silhouette shows us pretty clearly how horrific Steel’s death was. The lines of the page are fascinating – the robot is angled from upper left to lower right, with the fist’s motion lines cutting across that but not completely interrupting it, and even Luthor and his minion are tilted slightly that way to aim us toward the bottom corner and a turn of the page. It’s a deceptively simple page layout but it works to keep us moving. Ross might not be the best draftsman, but he knows what he’s doing when it comes to making your eye go where it wants to.

So: a simple and efficient first page that recaps what has happened and moves us into the rest of the issue. Moench and Ross are a bit old-school, so they know what they’re doing. Act of God might not be that good, but it’s not because the technical aspects of the first page are bad!

Next: Surely Guy Davis won’t let us down!

7 Comments

AoG did suffer a couple of problems (Diana and Clark especially, I would have killed them off, Kyle also acted in a way I didn’t buy) but the journey of the four heroes learning to do without powers definitely work. Still love Wally’s new identity.

As a whole, there was a lot I liked about Act of God; I do agree that the Kyle reaction to everything was over done, especially considering that at the time he was a relatively new hero (note the villain was Sonar, an early antagonist of Kyle’s run that faded with time). Clark bugged me that he was so wrapped up in the Superman identity and forgetting he actually had a life aside from that; Diana bugged me that the Amazons were just forgotten as a whole/not addressed.

It seems like this would work better as an expanded mini rather than a 3 part story. For example, we never find out what happens in the rest of the universe, if the alien races were affected or the New Gods suffering the same ways. We never find out what happens characters like Spectre or Phantom Stranger as well, so more with the concept might have been interesting.

[…] Frantic as a cardiograph scratching out the lines, Day 4: JLA: Act of God #2Comic Book Resourcesby Greg Burgas Every day this month, I will be examining the first pages of random comics. Today's page is from JLA: Act of God #2, which was published by DC and is cover dated 2001. Enjoy! JLA: Act of God is an Elseworlds comic written by Doug Moench, … […]

A lot of the hatred towards Act of God seems to be in the wake of Linkara’s video review, which should always be taken with a grain of salt. Most of that review was him whining about the continuity housekeeping involved.

Neil: I never saw that review, so that’s not it. I don’t really hate Act of God, but I thought it was a fairly mediocre and forgettable comic.

Act of God fell for me in the same category as “Last Son of Earth” or the elsewords where all the males on Earth died except for Superman: a story with great potential but all that story couldn’t be explored in 2 or 3 books….

The issue with this kind of story is that there’s always going to be something not explored or done with throwaway explanations. Given 3 issues, you can sort of live with it, but there are gaps and it’s a legit critique.

But there is no doubt an issue with the characterization in that many of the heroes seem unable to move on from the superhero identity even if that makes little sense to the character themselves based on what we know of them. For example, beyond Clark and Kyle, it makes little sense that Arthur would want to keep hero-ing as he was always a reluctant hero to begin with. As far as we know, his people are all dead from drowning and he’s an ex-monarch, so it seems like he would be the one headed downhill rather than Clark or Kyle; I mean, lose a fight to Sonar and you go nuts, but lose your people and your kingdom and it’s all cool because I can be the Claw or whatever he became? It seems off to me.

Leave a Comment

 

Categories

Review Copies

Comics Should Be Good accepts review copies. Anything sent to us will (for better or for worse) end up reviewed on the blog. See where to send the review copies.

Browse the Archives