web stats

CSBG Archive

Review time! with Rohan at the Louvre

Manga in the museum! Whoo-hoo!

I’ve been enjoying these graphic novels that are produced in conjunction with the Louvre, so of course I ordered Rohan at the Louvre, which is by Hirohiko Araki, costs $19.99, and is published in the States by NBM.

Rohan at the Louvre is a horror comic, and it exhibits both the strengths and weaknesses of the genre. It’s also a manga, obviously, and I, for one, was very keen to see manga in actual color. Araki’s artwork on this book is spectacular, and the colors, for the most part, are superb. The star of the book is a manga artist named Rohan, and part of the story takes place when he’s 17 and the rest a decade later. Araki gives him a distinctive look – he’s always wearing that strange, Jughead-looking thing that you see on the cover, and it’s never clear what it is; he has a very nice sense of style; and he’s long and lithe, also slithering through the book (not in any evil way, like how we usually think of snakes, but just in a loose, fluid way). The other characters are nicely designed, too, even though only one – Nanase – is really that important. The first part of the book is almost a tragic love story (I suppose I should leave out the “almost,” because you could argue that it really is one, but I don’t think it quite qualifies), and Araki does a wonderful job with Rohan and Nanase interacting with each other, and the soft earth tones of the house in which they both live (it belongs to Rohan’s grandmother, who rents out rooms) helps create that feeling both of romance and the nostalgia Rohan feels about this time (he’s telling us about it in flashback). The second half of the book, which takes place in the present, is colored more bluntly, contrasting nicely with both the time of the flashback and the change in tone from a youthful romance to a horror story. Araki is marvelous with the horror – it’s terrible and tragic, even if we don’t have too much at stake in the characters except for Rohan. We already know that something bad happens to them, so when it does, it doesn’t hit us as hard as it might, but Araki’s depictions of their fates is brutal and harrowing. He also draws Rohan’s ability – he’s able to “read” people very accurately – as literal truth, so that occasionally people’s skin becomes the pages of books that he flips open and “reads.” It’s a good device to show how well he does this, although it’s not explained as well as it could be. Araki uses the stereotypical tropes of manga – lots of speed lines at occasionally odd times and seemingly overwrought emotional responses to certain events – but American comics use stereotypical tropes as well, and once you get used to them, it doesn’t detract at all from the storytelling. This is a beautiful comic, as even the horror section at the end is filled with wonderful if terrifying images.

The story is a bit less successful, unfortunately. It’s not awful, but it does rely a bit too much on horror clichés and resolves itself a bit too quickly. I wouldn’t have minded if this book were longer, honestly, to give Araki a bit of time to explain all the weird shit that happens. In horror, it seems like the most successful stuff is either completely unexplained or explained very well, and this book falls somewhere in between, so it’s just not as compelling as either of the two extremes. The 17-year-old Rohan meets Nanase, a young woman (she’s 21) about to be divorced. He’s still practicing his artwork, so he uses her as a model without her knowledge, and when she finds out, she gets very upset. They begin a strange friendship – after her initial anger, she likes looking at his artwork, and he, of course, has a big crush on her. But she receives upsetting phone calls that Rohan doesn’t understand, and she tends to disappear for long stretches of time. She does tell him about a cursed painting by a Japanese artist that is now in the Louvre, and he becomes very curious about it. Then she destroys some of his art that features a person based on her before disappearing for the last time. It’s all very odd.

Ten years later, Rohan is reminded of the painting, and he decides to find it by going to Paris. There he meets Ms. Noguchi, a Japanese interpreter who works for the Louvre. She discovers the painting in a storage area that shouldn’t be in use, so she calls in a curator, who tells them the storage area was abandoned 30 years earlier. The curator doesn’t know why the painting would be down there, but he invites Rohan and Ms. Noguchi, along with two firemen – for protection in the run-down area – to go check it out. If you think this is a bad idea, you’re not wrong. It turns into a typical “evil thing locked away for a very good reason, but God forbid anyone tells anyone about that reason” plot, and Rohan has to figure something out to stave off the evil. This is where the plot really breaks down. I mentioned that he’s able to intuitively “read” people and that Araki shows this literally even though we’re supposed to believe it’s figurative. Well, at the end of the book, it appears to be literal, and it makes no sense. Rohan also acquires a lot of knowledge about the painting seemingly instantaneously, and I really don’t understand how he came by the knowledge. There’s a lot that’s left confused in the book – what Nanase was doing, why Rohan was so important to her, how Rohan knew some things, how he escaped the evil. Technically, it’s all there on the page (well, except who she was talking to on the phone), but it doesn’t make a lot of sense. As I mentioned, if Araki had left it more ambiguous it might have worked, and if he had really explained everything it might have. The half-assed explanation we get leaves us with more questions than answers, and it’s frustrating. It could certainly be the translation – I’m always wary about blaming the original writer when the original is in a different language – but it feels like Araki had a page count and realized he wasn’t going to be able to wrap everything up, so he simply explained everything he could in as little space as he had. I’m sure that wasn’t it, but that’s how it feels.

It’s too bad, because the premise, while a bit familiar, can work very well, and Araki’s idea of Rohan being able to understand everyone quickly could make for a quirky twist on a standard horror comic. Plus, the artwork is absolutely wonderful. I was enjoying the book until the final few pages, when it got first a bit ridiculous when Rohan was a target, and then dull when he started explaining everything. It’s good enough that I will Mildly Recommend it, especially if you’re a manga or a horror fan, but it’s a bit disappointing nevertheless.

11 Comments

You’re not supposed to believe that Heaven’s Gate is figurative. It’s an actual manifestation of a psychic ability. The “Stand” concept has been Araki’s stock in trade for something like 23 years now. Also, Araki isn’t exactly known for neatly explaining everything at the end. Even his fans sometimes have to shrug and say “Because Araki”. People read him for the outlandishness of his ideas, the lush artwork, and the sense of drama and suspense, not for his amazing ability to pull threads of a story together.

living planet

June 10, 2012 at 1:27 am

Imitorar is correct in everything. However I can see how it’s disconcerting to someone unfamiliar with his work. Araki pretty much makes everything up on the spot and while it shows he does it well.

Thanks, guys. This is the first time I’ve read anything by Araki, so I didn’t know that, obviously. I suppose if you’re ready for it, you can prepare yourself for it a bit more!

living planet

June 10, 2012 at 8:57 am

Well your only other legal option available in English is the 16 volumes of Jojo’s Bizarre Adventure Part 3 – Stardust Crusaders, some of which may be out of print by now. Coincidentally this is the part that introduces the concept of Stands, although it does not feature Rohan.

Well, that’s not technically the ONLY option. Viz also licensed Baoh and put it out in graphic novel format in the mid-’90s. It’s only a minor work of Araki’s (not that he has any major works other than JoJo), and it’s pretty hard to track down, but it’s not like JoJo’s easy to find anymore either. Araki’s work is too unusual to sell to the typical market for manga, but because it’s still technically manga, it’s generally overlooked by Western fans.

I had no idea Baoh was licensed, gotta try and find that now.

It’s a bit of a shame that he hasn’t hit off in America, as far as I’m concerned Araki is the most American comic influenced mangaka since uh, Tezuka himself.

I don’t know if I’d go that far (just for example, I remember Nobuhiro Watsuki mentioning how he based character designs in Rurouni Kenshin off of X-Men characters, and Watsuki’s drawing style is pretty typically Japanese), but he’s definitely more American-influenced than most. It’s a marketing problem, I think. Araki’s work would probably appeal most to the American fans who like comics but feel they’ve outgrown superheroes and look for more offbeat stuff. But they never see it, because it’s shelved with the manga. And the manga fans pay it no heed because it hasn’t got bishies, or people striving to be the best and triumph with the power of friendship, or school-life hijinks, or anything like that. So JoJo sank like a stone in America. If there were a way to publicize it outside the manga-ghetto to the general graphic novel/indie comic audience, it would probably do quite well. Or at least better than it did.

Thanks again for all the information. I did a tiny bit of research on Araki when I was putting this post together, but it’s always helpful to find out more about the creators. It’s odd that he doesn’t get more love from the manga crowd, because while it’s a bit unusual, it doesn’t seem too wild for what we see from manga. Strange.

living planet

June 10, 2012 at 1:20 pm

Well he’s highly respected in Japan, and has a decent following in places like Italy and France (which lead to him taking part in a comic book art gallery in the Louvre, which eventually lead to this comic being made). Yeah it probably is an advertising problem, but the usual manga market gets exposed to things through the animated adaptations, which JoJo has had difficulty with to say the least. (It had a movie which tanked in the theatre, Araki didn’t like and never got a DVD release, for example. )

I’m not really sure how you would advertise it to be honest, it’s kind of like trying to advertise Doom Patrol or something. I suppose X-Men fans might like it for the human + esoteric superpower aspect as opposed to straight superhero action.

No problem Greg honestly I’m just enjoying this wee conversation more than anything. None of the Rohan spinoffs are really quite as unusual as JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure itself which has things like fights with a sniper rat and a sentient plankton that possesses a corpse.

Unfortunately a lot of manga fans are turned off to Araki’s art style, probably for lack of kawaii girls. And later in the series it becomes more high-fashion, so even more complaints arose about all the characters looking like drag queens. The fact that the OVA and movie were terrible doesn’t help its popularity, and the online scanlations have possibly the worst editing ad translation of any manga (specifically the arc where Rohan is introduced)

Particularly, the major reason Jojo bizarre adventure does not get a whole ton of western fans is because most of them don’t know about the series. Licensing issues, to much of the characters and “stands” are named after “rock bands” that would involve way to much copy right issues and they would be forced to change practically 75% of the names.

Leave a Comment

 

Categories

Review Copies

Comics Should Be Good accepts review copies. Anything sent to us will (for better or for worse) end up reviewed on the blog. See where to send the review copies.

Browse the Archives