X-POSITION: Phoenix, Upstarts & More Tear Up Bowers & Sims' "X-Men '92"
Every day this year, I will be examining the first pages of random comics. This month I will be looking at four writer/artist duos, as voted on by you, the readers! This week features Ed Brubaker and Sean Phillips! Today’s page is from Sleeper “Season One” #1, which was published by DC/Wildstorm and is cover dated March 2003. This scan is from Sleeper volume 1: Out In The Cold, which was released in 2004. Enjoy!
Ed Brubaker and Sean Phillips (Brubillips or Philbaker, depending on your preference) worked briefly together before Sleeper, as Phillips inked a couple of issues of Brubaker’s Scene of the Crime mini-series for Vertigo. But this series was the first time Phillips drew Brubaker’s scripts, and comics history was made!!!!!
Brubaker has a style, and we see it clearly here. Holden Carver – we don’t know his name yet, but that’s it – is narrating, which Brubaker likes to do, and we begin at the end of something shitty, which he also likes to do. This has the advantage of beginning with a dramatic scene, which gets us right into the story – who is that dude? what’s going on? why is that other dude dead? Brubaker also likes to set up a “man against the world/man on the run” scenario, and while Holden’s narration doesn’t quite give us that (yet), we do get a sense that Holden is somehow lost (this entire series was based on Point Blank, but that doesn’t have Phillips on art and you don’t really need to read it anyway to get Sleeper, although it’s quite good). Brubaker sets a nice mood on this page, even if we don’t get a lot of concrete information about Holden.
One thing we’ll notice about Phillips’ style over the past decade is that he’s gotten a bit harsher and a bit more abstract. How much of that is the influence of colorist Tony Aviña (who colors this) and his later colorists I don’t know, but we see here that Holden, for instance, is a bit smoother than later Phillips characters and his coat, especially, is a bit over-rendered. Phillips designs the page well – he uses this trick throughout the book, where we get a splash page with several smaller panels laid over it. The layout is nice – the panels step downward parallel to Holden, so that he’s always in our peripheral vision even as we look at the smaller panels. Phillips creates a separate panel for the dead dude in the bottom left corner even though he’s technically part of the splash page so as to highlight that he’s there. Notice that the layout creates an “X”, with the panels going from the upper left to the bottom right and Holden and the dead dude forming the other segment in the X. Brubaker’s narration follows the first segment, but Holden looking at the dead dude is important, as well, so the other segment blocks us from moving onto the bottom right panel until we account for the dead dude. Phillips gives us some information about Holden and his situation, too – the cops are outside the warehouse, and this is a universe in which superpowered being exist. The flying silhouettes in Panel 3 and the domino mask on the dead dude implies that. I imagine that’s in the script, but it’s nice that Brubaker let Phillips give us that information visually rather than stating it explicitly.
It’s tough to speak of Bill Oakley’s lettering in a vacuum, but when Ken Lopez takes over in issue #4, he uses a more italicized style, and Oakley’s upright lettering seems to fit the tone more. It’s interesting to contrast small things like that when the letterer changes, especially if the two letterers have different styles.
Next: More Sleeper, but from much later in the series. Will anything change? Be here to find out! And be sure to check out the archives!
Comics Should Be Good accepts review copies. Anything sent to us will (for better or for worse) end up reviewed on the blog. See where to send the review copies.