web stats

CSBG Archive

Frantic as a cardiograph scratching out the lines, Day 297: Swamp Thing #151

Every day this year, I will be examining the first pages of random comics. This month I will be showing pages that are either scary or are part of “scary” issues (as scary as a comic can be, of course), because it’s October! Today’s page is from Swamp Thing #151, which was published by DC/Vertigo and is cover dated February 1995. Enjoy!

Well, that's not very nice of them

Mark Millar and Phil Hester (along with a slight boost from Grant Morrison, before he and Millar had a snit about who was cleaning the dishes that night and divorced) revitalized Swamp Thing in 1994, and the run remains a, if not the, high point of Millar’s career. Believe me, if you had been reading Nancy Collins’ work on the title (which wasn’t bad, just a bit too … milquetoast, I guess), you would have been impressed with Millar and Morrison’s initial arc, in which Swamp Thing goes around killing people, but then Millar went it alone, and the run got better. So it is with “River Run,” which begins in this issue.

Millar plays Anna’s death backward, which is eerie enough, but he does a nice job with the prose, so it feels even odder. We can figure out what’s happening quickly, even in the first panel, where Millar writes of the scalpel closing Anna up. We have to adjust our perceptions, so when the nurse places the scalpel back on the tray and then paused a moment, we have to re-think the sequence of events – the nurse is considering first, then handing the scalpel to the doctor. The students “abandoning” their first drowned corpse is a nice touch – again, the students aren’t abandoning anything, but the way Millar constructs the scene, he wants to finish the page with Anna, naked and alone in the dark. Even if we know the scene is playing backward, it’s still a nice way to show that in death, everyone is alone. Millar continues this over the next few page, twisting our expectations just enough to make the sequence weird – the cops “dump” Anna’s body in the swamp, for instance, even though we know that’s not what happens. Down at the bottom of the page, we have to decipher the backward dialogue: “He’s back. They say the swamp thing is back.” It’s a good way to end the page, because it adds a layer of mystery to the creepiness of Anna’s backward death.

Hester doesn’t have a lot to do on this page, but he does it well. He, Kim DeMulder (Hester is credited with layouts and DeMulder with finishes on this particular issue), and Tatjana Wood make sure the page moves from brightness to darkness, as the first panel has very little black and the final one is almost all black. Anna has an accusatory stare in Panel 2, which helps draw us into her plight. We already know that events are moving backward, so we’re pretty confident that Anna is going to come back to life, which makes her accusatory stare a bit more interesting – is she condemning us for not allowing her to stay dead? Hester does make a mistake, possibly – Anna is looking to her right in Panels 1 and 2 but to her left in Panel 3, but it’s not too hard to imagine the doctor turning her. Wood does her usual nice job with the coloring, making Anna blue in the final panel, both because it’s dark in the examination room but also because Anna drowned, so the blue links her to the water. It’s a fine choice.

Millar wrote plenty of horror stories in this run, but not all of them have really scary or creepy first pages. This isn’t as creepy as some pages, but it does begin the book with a strange, disturbing sense of reality being turned upside down. Considering that a good deal of Millar’s run dealt with this kind of sense, it’s a pretty good way to begin a story arc.

Next: Serial killers are always fun, aren’t they? Let’s check out a comic that features one! In the meantime, feel free to glide through the archives!


River Run was seriously underrated. From this issue until the end of the series, Swamp Thing was finally exciting again. Great art, and some inventive story telling from Millar.

Why has DC not collected this? I have 80% of them, but would like to read the whole thing.

It’s not like they can’t sell people Millar (+Gmo)!

Dammit, Greg! You’ve been totally creeping me out over the last few days with these Spectre and Swamp Thing pages.

Can’t we get some Vampirella boobage or Jack Russell: Terrier by Night to lighten the mood?

“River Run” was a seriously creepy story arc. I actually have a page of original artwork by Phil Hester & Kim DeMulder from Swamp Thing #157, the penultimate issue of the storyline…


And I agree with GarBut. DC definitely should collect this storyline.

Patrick: I think the entire run is good, but you’re right – the first ten issues felt a bit like housecleaning, and with this, Millar really took off.

GarBut: I’m not sure why DC hasn’t collected this. It might be part of the late 1980s/early 1990s deal that DC had with creators, which – I think – means they have to pay them more if they collect things (which is why so much from this era remains uncollected). On the other hand, there’s a rumor that DC was really pissed that Ed Brubaker left them to go to Marvel, which is why they kept his stuff uncollected for so long (and allowed something like Scene of the Crime to go to Image), so maybe they feel the same way about Millar? Beats me.

Mutt: That’s the point! It’s October!!!!! There’s only one comic I’m examining for the rest of the month that has a bit of humor, but the rest are all pretty evil and creepy. Sorry!

Ben: Very cool. Thanks for sharing!

Real great part of the swamp thing series. Wasnt really a fan of the nancy collins stuff..but mo and mi did get me hooked on their first issue… it was one of the series i really was lloking for back in those days…

There are also some creepy things in rachel pollack’s doom patrol … but Linda medley is no hester / demulder in term of ambiance .

Greg.; will we see some of the halloween that came out some years ago .. some had good things in them ;)

Since you’ve been featuring Swamp Thing, it may be worth mentioning Moore wrote a great “Time Twisters” story in 2000AD about a man’s life reversing. Could even have been called “The Reversible Man.” Maybe not, too predictable: that’s why Moore is an renowned comic writer & I’m not.

It would have been reprinted in the “Alan Moore’s Shocking Futures” TBP thingummay, which I’m sure you said you’ve got or read, Greg?

This issue may have been the first Swamp Thing I bought. I likee the cover.

When I have tried making the argument about the ’80s/’90s deals, or Millar being persona non grata at DC, it has been pointed out to me that ST is the ONLY Millar/Morrison collab that’s not collected. Aztek got traded, there’s some other Millar stuff at DC, but apparently this is the only run that’s not. Heck, it took ‘em ages to finally collect ST 20 in the first Moore HC.

I’d say they’re turning her over here in panel 3. She’s face up in the last panel, so she had to have been turned over at some point.

Travis: That’s true, but it took years before Aztek got a trade, and that was after Morrison came back to DC, so all was forgiven in his case. If he had stayed at Marvel, would we have gotten a trade of Aztek? Beats me!

Good point about them turning her over. I missed that!

Leave a Comment



Review Copies

Comics Should Be Good accepts review copies. Anything sent to us will (for better or for worse) end up reviewed on the blog. See where to send the review copies.

Browse the Archives