GIANT-SIZE X-POSITION: Lemire Launches "Extraordinary X-Men" - Part 1
Welcome to the four hundred and forty-sixth in a series of examinations of comic book legends and whether they are true or false. Click here for an archive of the previous four hundred and forty-five. This week, did Mort Weisinger really use a Bizarro World comic to out John F. Kennedy’s affair with Marilyn Monroe? Was a major part of Wolverine’s history originally going to be revealed in an issue of Captain America? And was Jack Kirby’s Fourth World always going to be an ongoing series?
NOTE: The column is on three pages, a page for each legend. There’s a little “next” button on the top of the page and the bottom of the page to take you to the next page (and you can navigate between each page by just clicking on the little 1, 2 and 3 on the top and the bottom, as well).
COMIC LEGEND: Mort Weisinger alluded to the alleged John F. Kennedy/Marilyn Monroe affair in a Superboy comic book story.
STATUS: I’m Tentatively Going With a True
Longtime Superman editor Mort Weisinger was a big supporter of the Democratic party in the United States. Here he is (courtesy of Jim Shooter’s blog, from a photo Weisinger gave to Shooter at some point) with two-time United States Presidential candidate Adlai Stevenson…
Weisinger was also quite plugged into political gossip (as well as gossip in general) of the time. During the 1950s, while not working at DC Comics (his DC Editorial position was a three days a week gig), he worked at the gossip magazine Inside Story, repackaging gossip stories from other magazines (At the always excellent Comics Detective website, Ken Quattro has an “obituary” that William Woolfolk wrote for Alter Ego when Mort Weisinger died that Roy Thomas and Jerry Bails ultimately decided was too harsh for publication – the obituary has more information about Weisinger’s time at Inside Story). By the time the 1960s rolled around, Weisinger was doing similar work for This Week magazine, a magazine that was inserted into newspapers around the country…
A very popular rumor for well over fifty years now is that President John F. Kennedy (who was assassinated fifty years ago today) and Marilyn Monroe had an affair beginning sometime in 1961 after her divorce from writer Arthur Miller. While the affair has been wildly accepted as being true by the public as a whole, we still do not seem to have much in the way of proof that there was an actual relationship between the pair. However, whether they were or were not romantically involved, it is fair to say that there were RUMORS about the two being involved in 1962, especially following Marilyn Monroe’s iconic performance of “Happy Birthday” to President Kennedy at a Democratic fundraiser in New York City in April of 1962 (Monroe passed away in August of 1962).
For someone who was…
A. Such a big Kennedy admirer (as others have noted, President Kennedy appeared enough in the Superman comics of the era that he was practically a supporting cast member!) and
B. So plugged into the gossip scene
there is little chance that Weisinger did not know of the Kennedy/Monroe rumors well before the rest of the world in the spring of 1962.
Therefore, it puts the following story from the March 1962 cover-dated issue of Adventure Comics #294 (a March cover date in those days likely meant the book was actually on sale in December of the previous year) into a fascinating context.
In the story (written by Jerry Siegel and drawn by John Forte), set on Bizarro World (a world made up of duplicates of Superman and Lois Lane, only they would do everything in reverse – so instead of saying “Hello” they’d say “Goodbye”), we see Bizarro Halloween, which involves Bizarros dressing up as humans and going around “pranking” their neighbors by doing good deeds for each other. The story eventually becomes a Bizarro Krypto story, as Bizarro Krypto gets so angry at the pranks that he tries to find a new owner, which is the gist of the story (Bizarro Krypto tries out alternate owners). But at the beginning, it involves Bizarros dressed as four famous figures of the time – John F. Kennedy, Marilyn Monroe, Mickey Mantle and Jerry Lewis.
As you can see from above, the Kennedy Bizarro Superman and the Monroe Bizarro Lois were paired together often early in the story.
The great longtime comic book editor Mike Gold wrote about the story a couple of years ago at his neat column at ComicMix (the website he co-founded and is currently the editor-in-chief of).
Gold is fairly confident that Weisinger did intend for the story to be a sly reference to the Kennedy/Monroe affair and even had the chance to ask Weisinger about it in 1976 (Weisinger died two years later). Here’s Gold:
[W]e flash-forward to 1976. DC President Sol Harrison thought it would be cool if I met Mort Weisinger because of our mutual interest in politics. Mort and I had a fascinating conversation that ran about two-and-one-half hours. I asked him about the Bizarro Marilyn / Bizarro JFK story. At first I thought I made him angry, but his broad facial gesture turned into a huge laugh. “You know, you’re the only guy to ask me that!” And that was his only response.
I tend to believe the Gold is correct and the story WAS intended to be a sly reference to the rumored affair. However, obviously with Weisinger, Siegel and Forte all long since passed away, I don’t think this will ever be more than a “tentative true,” as clearly there is a chance that Siegel just picked four random famous people to use in the story. If it weren’t for today’s date, I likely wouldn’t have featured the story period (which was suggested to me some time ago by reader Tony N.), but I couldn’t help myself with the timing of this week’s CBLR being on November 22nd.
Thanks to Tony for the suggestion and thanks to Mike Gold for the fascinating story!
Check out some Entertainment Urban Legends Revealed!
Was the First Movie Vampire With Fangs Not Until the 1950s?
On the next page, did we nearly learn a major part of Wolverine’s history in the pages of Captain America a DECADE before it was finally revealed in the pages of Uncanny X-Men?
Comics Should Be Good accepts review copies. Anything sent to us will (for better or for worse) end up reviewed on the blog. See where to send the review copies.