web stats

CSBG Archive

Year of the Artist, Day 10: Steve Ditko, Part 5 – Creepy #14

10-14-2013 11;48;37AM (2)

Every day this year, I will be examining the artwork on a single comic book story. Today’s artist is Steve Ditko, and the story is “Where Sorcery Lives!” from Creepy #14, which was published by Warren and has a cover date of April 1967. These scans are from Creepy Presents Steve Ditko, my copy of which was published in 2013 by Dark Horse. Enjoy!

Ditko had already shown an interest in esoteric and sword-’n’-sorcery work before this, which might be why he co-created Doctor Strange at Marvel. I don’t own any of his Doctor Strange stuff, which bums me out. Someday! When he moved over to Warren, Archie Goodwin wrote him some sword-’n’-sorcery stories, apparently at Ditko’s request, and “Where Sorcery Lives!” is one of them. Let’s check it out!

10-14-2013 11;36;33AM

The first page sets up the big conflict, as Garth, the “heedless barbarian,” dares invade the domain of Salamand the Sorcerer. Salamand is a necromancer, because of course he is, and he destroyed Garth’s village but he couldn’t kill Garth! Okay, where did the name “Garth” come from? Is it just something that sounded tougher in the 1960s? Anyway, there’s some interesting racial coding in this story – Garth is a big, blond, corn-fed man who looks like he just stepped off of a U.S. Army recruiting poster. Salamand, of course, is named to imply a salamander, which is of course mythologically linked to the occult and fire. Salamand is also older and balder than the virile Garth, but he’s also an Asian stereotype, with the angled eye slits and the long, thin, mustache (which is perfect for twirling, even though he doesn’t do it in this story). Obviously, this is from an era where stereotyping was still fairly acceptable, but I have no idea if Ditko (or Goodwin, I suppose) consciously designed Salamand and Garth to reflect a colonialistic attitude and an Orientalist perspective. This story came out at the height of the Vietnam War, and Goodwin, at least, was fairly socially conscious, so I wonder if that has anything to do with it. Goodwin and Ditko could simply be reinforcing the stereotypes that stretched back to Flash Gordon, at least, without really thinking about it. At least Salamand speaks just like a grade-Z villain and not in any obviously racist way, but it’s still kind of annoying.

10-14-2013 11;38;39AM

This is the next page, and it’s a good one. That second panel is great, as Salamand shows that he has way crazy power, but Garth isn’t backing down. Actually, all of the panels are pretty great, when you get right down to it. Notice the bodies in Panel 3 – Ditko’s use of light tones makes their predicament seem worse, as the … stuff they’re wrapped in seems more taffy-like than hard, which implies that they’re writing in agony as their breath is choked off. Panel 4 is another good one, as Salamand reveals that Garth’s babe, Tanya, is still alive. If we hadn’t noticed before, we see that Salamand’s eyebrows resemble clutching claws (what the heck is up with that?) and Ditko puts a skull in his eye, just to freak us out even more. In Panel 5, his use of ink washes again help create a smoky atmosphere in which Salamand becomes a spirit. Washing helps Ditko make the setting hazier, implying a poisonous, wrathful landscape. In a regularly inked page, it wouldn’t have the same tone, but Ditko nails the eerieness of Salamand’s stronghold.

Garth kills a weird, Seussian scorpion, and then falls down a pit, where we pick up the story:

10-14-2013 11;41;12AM

This is another tremendous page, as the winged guardian and the “general” appear out of a noxious cloud of black smoke, which Ditko inks heavily in contrast to the more ethereal (yet still dangerous) vapors we’ve been seeing in Salamand’s domain. He does a nice job leading our eye – Garth’s gaze upward in Panel 3 takes us to the creature and its rider, but the page is still angled down and to the left, moving us on a slightly tilted axis down to Panel 4. In that panel, Garth leads us from his word balloon back up toward the creature with the arrow he’s about to shoot, and in Panel 5, the creature continue to fly right to left, as it’s been doing in the previous two panels, but Garth’s word balloon helps move us to the next page. It’s not bad. The skeleton shows one of the weaknesses of Ditko’s work, however – he never quite got over the stiffness in his figures during action scenes. Unlike someone like Kirby, who mastered fluidity early on, Ditko never quite got it, which tended to work with an awkward character like Spider-Man (both in the fact that he was a teenager and a neophyte hero), but doesn’t work wonderfully for other comics. It’s a minor complaint, because Ditko was good at everything else, but it’s not surprising that his work started to look old-fashioned later on in his career, as artists became more adept at depicting the human body in motion.

10-14-2013 11;48;37AM

Garth, of course, defeats the vile creature, destroys the evil skeleton, and makes it to Salamand’s stronghold. There he finds Tanya, with the “pallor of death” upon her. This is the first good look we get of Tanya, and is anyone surprised that she’s blonde? Not only that, but in a world where Garth walks around wearing a loincloth, she’s demurely dressed in a long-sleeved, ankle-length dress. In the very next story, a different “barbarian” named “Thane” comes across a dark-haired, scantily-clad, curvaceous beauty whom he agrees to help. Needless to say, she betrays him. Even Goodwin and Ditko couldn’t escape female stereotypes!

That bottom panel is pretty cool, though. Again, the use of light washing helps create an ethereal quality to Salamand’s magic. When I have seen Ditko’s Doctor Strange work, the magic is solid bands, with the borders clearly inked. How much cooler that book would have looked if Ditko could have used this method!

10-14-2013 11;50;30AM

Ditko does a very nice job with the final confrontation. In the top row, we get extreme close-ups of Salamand and Garth as they contend with each other, and Ditko really sells it. Panel 3, with the skulls in Salamand’s eyes cockily grinning as the sorceror fights on, is excellent, and we see the strain on Garth in Panel 4 very nicely. Panel 5 works well, as the sword that dispatches Salamand comes from the right, so our eyes move right across the sorceror’s bent body, along the sword, and on to Panel 6, where we find out that Tanya has managed to break the trance and stab Salamand in the back. Her final statement finishes “… my trance was broken and I was free to act!” Notice, again, how well the wispy magic that Salamand employs works very well in the context of the story, as it looks so inconsequential in Panels 2 and 4 but Ditko contrasts that with Garth’s face, which shows how much he’s struggling. The non-physical aspect of Garth’s battle is highlighted very well because Ditko is able to use a light wash instead of hard inks.

So that’s part of Ditko’s career. At this point, he was 39 years old, and he was about to start working at DC. Like Kirby, we’ll check out his 1970s work later in the year, because like Kirby, I own a lot more of his art from that decade that these earlier decades. And it will be interesting to contrast them, as Kirby became more dynamic while Ditko tended to become more old-fashioned. But tomorrow, we’ll start with a new artist! Who will it be? Well, that’s a good question. Come back tomorrow and find out! I promise, he’s much more modern. You can still get your fill of olde-tyme artists in the archives!

14 Comments

While the stereotype look of the characters could be difficult in modern context, it is nice to see that in the end, it’s Tanya that saves the day! :)

I will say though that the look of the characters goes into the realm of such over-the-top stereotype that there’s a sense of a big wink to the audience in some panels. Garth in that last panel; the necromancer with his crazy everything – that mustache! those eyebrows! those eyes!

Most importantly: even though there’s so much crazy stuff on display with all the magic and effects, the eye still flows easily over the page. Some artists do stories like this and fill it with crazy stuff and you can’t tell how you’re supposed to read it. This is a testament to the skill on display.

Looking forward to your next choice!

Derek: it is kind of cool that Tanya saves the day. I would hope there’s a bit of parody in these comics, but it’s tough to suss out whether that was really Goodwin and Ditko’s intentions. I wonder if they were just using the stereotypes because it was handy. Goodwin is no longer alive and Ditko ain’t talking, so I guess we’ll never know.

That wash technique likely wouldn’t work very well in color so I’m assuming that’s why you didn’t see it on Dr Strange. Also, get your head in the game, Burgas! No more of this “I don’t have any of his 60s stuff” garbage. You’re missing some of the best stuff from a silver age master! Hell, even an Essential reprint works.

P. Boz: That’s a good point – another reason that Marvel should have printed them in black and white! I also wonder if it would take longer to figure out a comparable effect in color, and Ditko didn’t have the time. Beats me.

Sorry I don’t have a lot of 1960s comics! :) I know I’m far behind in some areas of comics history, and 1960s Marvel, especially, is one of those places (I have slightly more DC work from that time, but not much). I don’t know why – early in my comics-reading career, I know it was because I didn’t like Kirby and Ditko, but that’s no longer the case. I should get Essentials, but I just haven’t. I’m always looking for space for the comics I do own, so that’s a problem! I’m sure I’ll rectify this shortcoming some day, but right now, it’s not terribly feasible. Such is life! I’ll work around it!

Named after the british comic character perhaps? He was pretty much just a strong and determined barbarian type.

Josh: Hmm, maybe. I don’t know how much Goodwin knew about it, but it’s a possibility.

It’s been a lonnnnng time, but didn’t she end up killing Garth also? Can’t trust my memory…

That year was Ditko at his very best, with “Demon Sword” being the most memorable Ditko art yet.

*jeep! & God Bless!
—Grandpa Chet

Greg,

I can’t agree with you that Ditko lacked fluidity. The 9th panel would do Gil Kane proud. The skeleton’s stiffness suits it.

MormonYoYoMan: No, she and Garth ended the story hugging each other while Salamand dissolved. You must be thinking of another story!

Anonymous: Yeah, good point about the skeleton – not the best example. I still think Ditko wasn’t quite as good at it as a lot of other artists of his time, but I guess I’ll have to wait until I get back to Ditko later in the year to prove it!

Greg – wow these articles are great reading. I have a lot of catching up to do!

I just read over your Ditko articles and I am coming from the angle at only being barely familiar with him due to his Spider-Man work at Marvel (and having heard of him being famous for Dr. Strange). As a kid in the 70′s, I had a Spidey digest or two that had a few of those early ASM issues in it, but just recently I finally purchased the Omnibus and am digging it it’s large page glory. (Man I wish I was born in the 50′s and could have started collecting comics then, instead of the very late 70′s!)

Sorry, I ramble. My main point was, in reading the letters pages of the first couple of issues of ASM in the Omnibus, some of the correspondents really didn’t like Ditko’s rendition of Fantastic Four in ASM compared to Kirby’s. I still do not have enough art appreciation to tell their styles apart that much (plus I don’t have FF issues to compare to), so to me they are both classic styles. I hope to rectify that once I get the FF omnibus. But thought it was an interesting anecdote, since you reviewed both Kirby and Ditko. People at that time seemed to prefer Kirby over Ditko (at least, for FF). Interesting!

Thanks again for this very interesting series of articles.

David: Thanks for the nice words. I’m trying to make them interesting!

I think people still tend to favor Kirby over Ditko. Kirby is better suited to superheroes, I think, and his style, while not generic at all, fits so well with superheroes that people tend to think of him as a template for how superhero action is done. Ditko fit into superhero work a bit more unusually, and he’s a bit more idiosyncratic than Kirby. In recent years, I have to believe Ditko’s prickly personality and his rather fringe political beliefs also contribute to that, even if it’s only unconscious.

Fascinating! Although I’ve enjoyed reading comics all my life, there is so much I need to learn about the actual creators. I will definitely be keeping this in mind as I explore these older titles.
Thanks again for this wonderful series – but I could envision it going on and on for years, instead of just one year. Not sure how you would be able to afford such a project though!

David: Well, I have a lot of comics already! It’s more of the time constraint, really – these take a while to write up, and I hope I can keep far enough ahead so that I don’t feel too pressed!

my fave ditko are the shades from 77 78, tho nonetheless great choice of artist to spotlight one of if not the best

Leave a Comment

 

Categories

Review Copies

Comics Should Be Good accepts review copies. Anything sent to us will (for better or for worse) end up reviewed on the blog. See where to send the review copies.

Browse the Archives